Ceann Comhairle steps in to block Anti-Evictions Bill on behalf of the government
A Fianna Fáil spokesperson said the party had abstained from the vote because they believe the bill to be legally flawed
The Ceann Comhairle has used his casting vote to back the government in the Dáil after voting on an opposition bill aimed at protecting renters against eviction was tied at 51 votes apiece.
The Anti-Evictions Bill, put forward by the Anti-Austerity Alliance / People Before Profit (AAA-PBP) aimed to close “loopholes allowing legal eviction” ahead of a property sale or rent increase.
Longstanding Dáil precedent dictates that when there is a hung vote, the Ceann Comhairle – regardless of party history – votes with the Government.
The bill would have ensured that a tenant can remain in their home – under the same terms and conditions – when a property is sold by a landlord, bank or ‘vulture fund.’
It also aimed to address the so-called ‘family member rule’ by ensuring that compensation “equivalent to six months’ rent” would be paid to a tenant if they are evicted on the basis that a landlord – or a member of the landlord’s family – is planning on moving in to the property.
Finally it would have reduced the period of time before a tenancy is given ‘Part 4’ status – from six months to two months.
Narrow defeat
Following an initial vote the bill was defeated by 51 to 50 after Fianna Fáil abstained from the vote.
In response, the AAA-PBP called a ‘vote through the lobbies’ – in the hope that any politician who was in the building but had failed to cast a vote might be able to swing the outcome.
jusayinlike
Great work Anne
Anne
Thanks..it was just a ctrl c and a ctrl v..it’s a bit tricky all right, you gotta press your fingers on the ctrl at the same time as the c and then the v. :) Fupp all about it on the papers though.
Happy Molloy
Thank god for Dinny media or else we mightn’t have heard :-p
Anne
Yeah, thank god for that pension robbing, bank bullying, politician bribing little rascal.
Twunt
I agree with giving tenants more protection around property sale, but giving them 6 months rent for moving into a property you own is just ridiculous.
Jesus Wept
Not ridiculous at all.It prevents unscrupulous landlords from asking tenants to leave on the basis of family member moving in.Once tenant is out, rent is increased and family member who was to move in,doesn’t.
Brother Barnabas
there’s already legislation to prevent that
SB
Surely it’s better to just ensure that the family member DOES move in? Maybe by awarding a year’s rent if, a year later, the family member hasn’t been in continuous residence?
Anne
A tenant already living somewhere should take precedence over a landlord’s brother or uncle or aunt or first cousin or 2nd cousin twice removed IMO.
SB
If I owned a house somewhere that was rented out, and my child was starting in college in that city, damn right I’d want to be able to use my own property! As long as the proper procedures are followed and notice periods are given, why shouldn’t people be allowed do what they want with their own property? That doesn’t include using family as an excuse and then not following through, of course.
Anne
Tenancy rights need to be given the upmost importance IMO. If you had a tenant in on a 25 year lease in the likes of Germany, you’d just have to make alternative arrangements for a family member.
As it stands the notice period that needs to be given isn’t sufficient IMO. Also tenants are only protected from eviction when the landlord is selling over 10 properties and even if selling more than ten if he can prove that the property is worth more (20%) with the tenants gone, then they’re gone.
I mean seriously, landlords want it all ways. The want to pay no taxes, they want someone else to pay their pension fund in full and they want the freedom to kick out the tenants when it suits.
If you have policies that are turning the nation into a nation of renters, then sorry fupp your daughter and your cousin and whoever else.
Taanbuaagam
True. This government is close to collapse though that’s what I learned
Anne
If landlords keep harping on that they provide a great service, proper security of tenure and the loopholes for getting rid of people easily, need to be addressed. Otherwise it aint such a great service is it? Gougers.
The ceann whatis is a muppet too. I won’t vote with me conscious he says, I go with what’s expected of me. Useless weasels.
There’s what could be defining moments in these otherwise boring muppets lives and they’ll tow the line every time.
I meant on the front pages like..shur I found a link myself.
Thanks for the links though, you googling wizz kid.
ReproBertie
Maybe say what you mean and mean what you say. It’ll help avoid confusion in future.
Taanbuaagam
Fupp off you bullying gobspoo
Anne
Yes boss.
ReproBertie
Ooh Taanbuaagam, you barely literate white knight you! You have me all a quiver.
Taanbuaagam
How am I “barely literate” exactly?
You’re barely sentient to judge by your input.
ReproBertie
Well you clearly have no idea what the word “bully” means sweetheart.
Taanbuaagam
Bertie do you think it makes you a big fella to bully and be patronising to posters with female sounding avatars on a blog site?
*newsflash*
It is just creepy
Sido
Another unfunny cartoon Bodger? Remember when you went down this road, all those months ago. How you were so sure you were right? How you echoed the mindless drivel of the MSM, rather than analysing the information in front of you?
How does that feel Bodger? Remember when Broadsheet was an alternative site, rather than a grubby MSM echo chamber? Hows your click figures m8?
Compassion Cash
Steady on old boy.
Anomanomanom
Exactly, when I randomly found this I thought it was great. Its getting worse and worse. Oh the great line alot of people use “oh why that you go to the journal”, there is no difference anymore.
Anne
The likes of whingers like yourself have always been around. They’d whinge about the lack of serious content on a cat or a dog pic, and no comment on any posts that were a bit more complicated than the cat or dog pic. I used to make a point of leaving a comment on those very informative posts asking where are all the whingers.
Fupp the fupp off and either contribute or go away and spare the rest of us from your whinging will you.
Anomanomanom
Haha, I know you dont have the intellectual ability to realise what you’ve just done. But that was funny, its funny because you don’t see it.
Anne
Yeah, the irony of whinging about boring whingers is hilarious.
Seriously, fupp off or contribute. Same for Rotsey there. It gets old.
Anomanomanom
Look in the mirror and say that out loud. I genuinely believe your just an excellent troll. Trying out comments with content, although some very good, that you will get a reaction so you can then start your childish attack.
Taanbuaagam
Agreed. You contribute nothing here Anomonomobirdbrain
Anomanomanom
Oh but see I do, a lot more than you two. You seem to think commenting on people who you dont like is a contribution. Its not its childish. You can agree or disagree that a choice, but the way you seem to see it is Your right and thats it. Why did Ann need to comment on my post, I was agreeing with a comment that I liked yet you both seem to think by then replying to my comment and moaning about it that you some how better me.
jusayinlike
Go leering after nurses you hatchet man
Anomanomanom
I wouldn’t lower myself.
Taanbuaagam
Hello Anomonomobirdbrain
Clearly you did crave the attention from Anne no matter how negative it was as you kept the whole thing going. Just don’t bother posting any more except it’s about a cat meme or missing bike and you should be alright. That’s your level.
Kieran NYC
“You seem to think commenting on people who you dont like is a contribution. ”
Well said, Anon.
Compassion Cash
Your an angry little person aren’t you ? I like you….
Nigel
He’ll be SO embarrassed when it turns out Farage sings like an angel on helium.
Happy Molloy
I should probably know but, what’s MSM?
Listrade
I think its those crazy days of Microsoft Messenger.
Nigel
Monosodomutomate.
rotide
The mainstream media, what with their fact checking and editorial oversight. dogs.
Anne
you don’t seem very busy with that fact checking it has to be said.
jusayinlike
Yea right editor/rotide, no clicks at your rag again bitter little rotide
The inauguration is going to be GREAT now with Flatley there!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bY_SkUKvAn8&t=212s
Trump. The people’s president.
4 More years.
if he was looking for an Irish dancer we should’a sent over the Kilt wearing Dancing Priest
Flately and Trump aren’t all that dissimilar, actually.
True. They are both successful business men.
And both love the colour orange.
https://youtu.be/-RWxCkO_N50
this one is good.
Chuckle ar la.
Nothing on this on the papers it seems –
http://www.newstalk.com/Ceann-Comhairle-steps-in-to-block-AntiEvictions-Bill-on-behalf-of-the-government
Ceann Comhairle steps in to block Anti-Evictions Bill on behalf of the government
A Fianna Fáil spokesperson said the party had abstained from the vote because they believe the bill to be legally flawed
The Ceann Comhairle has used his casting vote to back the government in the Dáil after voting on an opposition bill aimed at protecting renters against eviction was tied at 51 votes apiece.
The Anti-Evictions Bill, put forward by the Anti-Austerity Alliance / People Before Profit (AAA-PBP) aimed to close “loopholes allowing legal eviction” ahead of a property sale or rent increase.
Longstanding Dáil precedent dictates that when there is a hung vote, the Ceann Comhairle – regardless of party history – votes with the Government.
The bill would have ensured that a tenant can remain in their home – under the same terms and conditions – when a property is sold by a landlord, bank or ‘vulture fund.’
It also aimed to address the so-called ‘family member rule’ by ensuring that compensation “equivalent to six months’ rent” would be paid to a tenant if they are evicted on the basis that a landlord – or a member of the landlord’s family – is planning on moving in to the property.
Finally it would have reduced the period of time before a tenancy is given ‘Part 4’ status – from six months to two months.
Narrow defeat
Following an initial vote the bill was defeated by 51 to 50 after Fianna Fáil abstained from the vote.
In response, the AAA-PBP called a ‘vote through the lobbies’ – in the hope that any politician who was in the building but had failed to cast a vote might be able to swing the outcome.
Great work Anne
Thanks..it was just a ctrl c and a ctrl v..it’s a bit tricky all right, you gotta press your fingers on the ctrl at the same time as the c and then the v. :) Fupp all about it on the papers though.
Thank god for Dinny media or else we mightn’t have heard :-p
Yeah, thank god for that pension robbing, bank bullying, politician bribing little rascal.
I agree with giving tenants more protection around property sale, but giving them 6 months rent for moving into a property you own is just ridiculous.
Not ridiculous at all.It prevents unscrupulous landlords from asking tenants to leave on the basis of family member moving in.Once tenant is out, rent is increased and family member who was to move in,doesn’t.
there’s already legislation to prevent that
Surely it’s better to just ensure that the family member DOES move in? Maybe by awarding a year’s rent if, a year later, the family member hasn’t been in continuous residence?
A tenant already living somewhere should take precedence over a landlord’s brother or uncle or aunt or first cousin or 2nd cousin twice removed IMO.
If I owned a house somewhere that was rented out, and my child was starting in college in that city, damn right I’d want to be able to use my own property! As long as the proper procedures are followed and notice periods are given, why shouldn’t people be allowed do what they want with their own property? That doesn’t include using family as an excuse and then not following through, of course.
Tenancy rights need to be given the upmost importance IMO. If you had a tenant in on a 25 year lease in the likes of Germany, you’d just have to make alternative arrangements for a family member.
As it stands the notice period that needs to be given isn’t sufficient IMO. Also tenants are only protected from eviction when the landlord is selling over 10 properties and even if selling more than ten if he can prove that the property is worth more (20%) with the tenants gone, then they’re gone.
I mean seriously, landlords want it all ways. The want to pay no taxes, they want someone else to pay their pension fund in full and they want the freedom to kick out the tenants when it suits.
If you have policies that are turning the nation into a nation of renters, then sorry fupp your daughter and your cousin and whoever else.
True. This government is close to collapse though that’s what I learned
If landlords keep harping on that they provide a great service, proper security of tenure and the loopholes for getting rid of people easily, need to be addressed. Otherwise it aint such a great service is it? Gougers.
The ceann whatis is a muppet too. I won’t vote with me conscious he says, I go with what’s expected of me. Useless weasels.
There’s what could be defining moments in these otherwise boring muppets lives and they’ll tow the line every time.
Nothing?
http://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/oireachtas/government-saved-from-defeat-on-evictions-bill-by-ceann-comhairle-1.2943076
http://www.independent.ie/irish-news/politics/fragility-of-the-minority-government-evident-as-eviction-bill-narrowly-passes-in-the-dil-35380879.html
Typical MSM, hiding the big stories.
I meant on the front pages like..shur I found a link myself.
Thanks for the links though, you googling wizz kid.
Maybe say what you mean and mean what you say. It’ll help avoid confusion in future.
Fupp off you bullying gobspoo
Yes boss.
Ooh Taanbuaagam, you barely literate white knight you! You have me all a quiver.
How am I “barely literate” exactly?
You’re barely sentient to judge by your input.
Well you clearly have no idea what the word “bully” means sweetheart.
Bertie do you think it makes you a big fella to bully and be patronising to posters with female sounding avatars on a blog site?
*newsflash*
It is just creepy
Another unfunny cartoon Bodger? Remember when you went down this road, all those months ago. How you were so sure you were right? How you echoed the mindless drivel of the MSM, rather than analysing the information in front of you?
How does that feel Bodger? Remember when Broadsheet was an alternative site, rather than a grubby MSM echo chamber? Hows your click figures m8?
Steady on old boy.
Exactly, when I randomly found this I thought it was great. Its getting worse and worse. Oh the great line alot of people use “oh why that you go to the journal”, there is no difference anymore.
The likes of whingers like yourself have always been around. They’d whinge about the lack of serious content on a cat or a dog pic, and no comment on any posts that were a bit more complicated than the cat or dog pic. I used to make a point of leaving a comment on those very informative posts asking where are all the whingers.
Fupp the fupp off and either contribute or go away and spare the rest of us from your whinging will you.
Haha, I know you dont have the intellectual ability to realise what you’ve just done. But that was funny, its funny because you don’t see it.
Yeah, the irony of whinging about boring whingers is hilarious.
Seriously, fupp off or contribute. Same for Rotsey there. It gets old.
Look in the mirror and say that out loud. I genuinely believe your just an excellent troll. Trying out comments with content, although some very good, that you will get a reaction so you can then start your childish attack.
Agreed. You contribute nothing here Anomonomobirdbrain
Oh but see I do, a lot more than you two. You seem to think commenting on people who you dont like is a contribution. Its not its childish. You can agree or disagree that a choice, but the way you seem to see it is Your right and thats it. Why did Ann need to comment on my post, I was agreeing with a comment that I liked yet you both seem to think by then replying to my comment and moaning about it that you some how better me.
Go leering after nurses you hatchet man
I wouldn’t lower myself.
Hello Anomonomobirdbrain
Clearly you did crave the attention from Anne no matter how negative it was as you kept the whole thing going. Just don’t bother posting any more except it’s about a cat meme or missing bike and you should be alright. That’s your level.
“You seem to think commenting on people who you dont like is a contribution. ”
Well said, Anon.
Your an angry little person aren’t you ? I like you….
He’ll be SO embarrassed when it turns out Farage sings like an angel on helium.
I should probably know but, what’s MSM?
I think its those crazy days of Microsoft Messenger.
Monosodomutomate.
The mainstream media, what with their fact checking and editorial oversight. dogs.
you don’t seem very busy with that fact checking it has to be said.
Yea right editor/rotide, no clicks at your rag again bitter little rotide
ah right, thanks Ted
The leader they deserve.