Author Archives: Bodger


[Members of the Survivors of Symphysiotomy campaign group in June 2012 after addressing the justice, defence and Equality committee]

Proposals to compensate more than 250 survivors of the medical procedure symphysiotomy will be placed before the cabinet in the coming weeks.

We asked Legal Coffee Drinker what’s it all about.

Broadsheet: “Legal Coffee Drinker, what’s it all about?”

LCD: “It’s about proposals to change the law to allow for compensation for women suffering the after-effects of symphysiotomies.”

Broadsheet: “Would it not be possible through the courts? Surely carrying out this procedure without consent is actionable?”

LCD: “Indeed it is. Most recently, in Kearney v McQuillan, where a damages award of €450,000 [subsequently reduced to €325,000 by the Supreme Court] was made in respect of a symphysiotomy carried out in 1969.”

Broadsheet: “On what ground?”

LCD: “The tort of negligence. It arises where someone who owes a duty of care to another fails to exercise reasonable care towards that other, as a result of which they suffer damage. This was a case of medical negligence involving a failure to exercise reasonable care in medical treatment.”

Broadsheet: “So the symphysiotomy survivors should sue?

LCD: “Not necessarily. Firstly, whether or not a symphysiostomy represents a breach of a hospital’s duty of reasonable care depends on the circumstances of each case: whether it was necessary; whether alternative treatments were available, or if not available whether something could have been done to prevent the necessity of a symphysiotomy arising in the first place. The circumstances of the individual case need to be looked at.
Secondly, Irish law has what is known as a limitation period of six years for actions in tort and contract. In the case of a negligence action, this means that proceedings must be brought within six years of the initial damage occurring. In the case of a symphysiostomy, that would be within six years of the operation. Most of these operations were carried out more than six years ago.”

Broadsheet: “But Kearney was 1969?”

LCD: [refills coffee] “Yes. The plaintiff in that case was able to avail of a provision in the Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Act 1991 which provides that time does not start running, for the purposes of an action in negligence, until the plaintiff can be reasonably aware of the damage having occurred. It’s known as the ‘discoverability’ principle.
Basically it means the six years run from the date on which the damage is reasonably discoverable. In this case Mrs Kearney was not told about the symphysiotomy at the time of it occurring, did not become reasonably aware of it in fact until years later. That’s why she was allowed to proceed with the case. Other women may not necessarily be able to make this argument. They may have known, or had reason to know, about the operation having been carried out at the time it occurred, more than six years before initiating litigation. If so their action risks being statute-barred.”

Broadsheet: “So would they then be precluded from suing?”

LCD: “Under current Irish law, yes. Although it would be open to the Oireachtas to amend the Statute of Limitations to change this.”

Broadsheet: “Will they?”

LCD: [Drains coffee] “At the moment it seems that the statutory compensation scheme is being favoured. Whether or not the damages awarded under such scheme will be similar to those which would have been awarded by the courts is another question. These survivors have endured a lifetime of suffering. I only hope the redress reflects this. ”

Broadsheet: “It was dark time of complete deference towards the professional classes.”

LCD: [pause] “Are we done?”

Broadsheet: “Yes. Absolutely. Thank you so much Legal Coffee Drinker. Most grateful as always”

[call ends]

Previously: “The Last Thing I Remember Was My Feet Being Pulled Up Into The Stirrups”

Redress proposal due for women who had symphysiotomies (Irish Times)

 (Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland)


[Geraldine O'Hanlon and a couple of rescue hounds]

The Kildare Animal Foundation Needs YOUR Help.

Founder Geraldine O’Hara writes:

Our Situation is now very Serious We need help. Those who supply us with food and provide veterinary care have been more than patient. It is now almost 7 weeks since we have been able to make any payments. Our electricity supply is tenuous on a very severe and unsustainable payment demand.
Every coin jar has been emptied, every pocket searched and we have nowhere else to turn.
The cause is simple – there are more animals than ever coming to us for care and fewer people in a position to donate. We have not been extravagant or wasteful, there is more going out than coming in.
We need to raise at least €8,000 to simply catch up.
The stress of this situation is difficult for all of us especially as there are more animals waiting to come in. Providing good quality food and veterinary care is the very core of what we do here. We do not engage in random and regular appeals. We ask now only when we have nowhere else to turn. Please if you can, help us to turn this situation around so we can go back to what we do best.

Donations online via the Kildare Animal Foundation’s PayPal account. (Please visit the website  for the PayPal button). Or You can  send a donation by post to the Kildare Animal Foundation, South Green Road, Kildare Town.

Kildare Animal Foundation

Thanks Cheeky Dog Bakery

90337686Ekeh Location Map

Last week’s Sunday Times reported how former Anglo Irish Bank Seán FitzPatrick’s legal costs – following the trial in which he was acquitted of 16 charges – are likely to amount be between €500,000 and €1million.

Journalist Mark Tighe reported how he asked Mr FitzPatrick – who is bankrupt – if he applied for legal aid.

Brian Harmon, a PR consultant who is also a lawyer and who accompanied Mr FitzPatrick throughout the trial at the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, said Mr FitzPatrick had no comment.

Mr Tighe also asked if businessman, and the largest shareholder in Independent News and Media, Denis O’Brien helped to foot Mr FitzPatrick’s legal bill.

Mr Harmon, who has previously acted as spokesman for Mr O’Brien, said Mr O’Brien had no involvement in the court case.

Separately, it was reported in The Sunday Independent that the sale of an oil field in Nigeria may help to pay off Mr FitzPatrick’s €110million debts to the former Anglo Irish Bank.

Mr FitzPatrick is a member of a consortium which owns the Nigerian Ekeh oil field, and Nick Webb in the Sunday Independent reported yesterday that Midway Resources has indicated that it wants to buy the field.

Mr Webb reported:

“The owner of the Ekeh field is a company called Movido Exploration, whose shareholders include Sean FitzPatrick, the former non-executive chairman of Anglo Irish Bank.”

“The other shareholders in the scheme are former Anglo director and ex-Dublin Docklands Development chairman Lar Bradshaw, oil engineer Jim O’Driscoll and a group of Nigerian business people and former military personnel.These include a former vice-admiral in the Nigerian navy, Victor Ombu. FitzPatrick, Bradshaw and O’Driscoll are believed to own about 39 per cent of Movido Exploration.”

You may recall chapter 12 of the book The FitzPatrick Tapes, (by Tom Lyons and Brian Carey). You must. It’s the one WITHOUT an index.

It tells how, in March 2009, Denis O’Brien lent Mr FitzPatrick and Lar Bradshaw – who both resigned from Anglo in December 2008 – his private jet and travelled with them to Lagos in Nigeria to convince the Nigerian businessmen involved in the project that he was good for his investment.

Mr Lyons and Mr Carey wrote “O’Brien and lent his jet and his support in order to soothe the anxieties of the Nigerian businessmen who had been following FitzPatrick’s tribulations in Ireland with increasing alarm and were losing faith in his ability to keep funding the well”.

Mr Lyons and Mr Carey wrote how Mr O’Brien lent the two men his private jet and travelled with them to Lagos to meet their Nigerian colleagues.

Good times.

(Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland)


Scenes around government buildings, Merrion Street, Dublin this afternoon as campaigners including Labour Party Anti-Water Tax Party worker Goda Akuockaite (top) and Labour’s Rebecca Moynihan prepare for the local and European elections..

It may get gnarly.

(Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland)



Right so.

Thanks Cathal O’Rourke