The recently re-opened Bewley’s on Grafton Street, Dublin 2
That was a quick €10…
Previously: Dublin Can Be Heaven
Grafton Street, Dublin 2.
Bewley’s oldest customers Denis Shields, 86, and Eileen Brennan, undisclosed age, are the first to walk through the doors of the iconic café after a multi-million-euro refurbishment.
Paddy Campbell of Bewley’s (pic 2) promise regulars will find elements of the original café have been carefully restored including the Harry Clarke windows, the banquettes and open fireplaces “as well as an open-concept bakery so customers can see old favourites such as the Sticky Buns being crafted by some of Europe’s finest pastry chefs and bakers”.
Is RTE Lol-ing At Its Own Since opening our doors in 2003, JES.edu.vn has delivered thousands of web and digital experiences, across a multitude of tieng anh doanh nghiep platforms alarge enough to offer you the knowledge website SEO – thoi trang and expertise wesite design, website thiet ke we’ve gained servicing the Corporate and SEO online marketing Government sectors, yet small enough to care. trung tam day tieng anh harvard has delivered thousands of web and digital experiences, across a multitude of website design san francisco platforms alarge enough to offer you the knowledge website design company and expertise thiet ke web chuan seowe’ve gained servicing the Corporate and madrid website design – tourist Government sectors, yet small enough to care. KABEGAMINAVI.COM
Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland
From left: Nancy Poulain, Tiffany Jones, and Dawn T Adams at Glendalough, Co Wicklow.
Fancy jumping into a lake?
“This summer up to 1,000 swimmers are expected to take the plunge into Ireland’s lakes as part of the Bewley’s Open Water Swimmer League. The league kicks off on summer solstice, 21st June, with a 750m and 1500m swim at Lough Key. On 19th July, competitors will swim past the Hodson Pillar in Hodson Bay and through the centre of Ireland as they compete in the 750m and 1 mile swim. Finally, the league will conclude on the 6th and 7th September in the spectacular Glendalough National Park where competitors will compete over 750m, 1500m and 3900m swims…”
More details here
Picture: Conor McCabe Photography.
That landmark Grafton Street, Dublin, rental judgement.
What’s it all about?
What does it all mean?
We sat down with a legal person specialising in the area of property law (who wishes to remain anonymous) for a cup of Bewley’s well-grounded and a list of questions.
What is this decision about?
It is about a dispute between a landlord (Ickendel) and a tenant (Bewley’s Grafton Street). The dispute related to an upwards-only rent review clause in a commercial lease.
What’s an upward only rent review clause?
A clause which stops the rent being reduced on review in line with market rents.
Since 2010 you can’t insert upwards-only clauses in new leases. But they are still valid in pre-2010 leases. The Bewley’s lease was from 1987.
What was the dispute about so?
The meaning of the clause and whether it should be given a broad or a narrow interpretation. The clause in this case said that the rent was to be reviewed after every period of five years, with the rent on review being the greater of (a) the market rent or (b) the rent for ‘the preceding period’.
Bewley’s said that ‘the preceding period’ meant the initial period of five years at the beginning of the lease, so that the rent could not fall below the initial rent set in 1987 but could fall below the rent set on subsequent reviews.
The landlord, Ickendel Limited (now in NAMA) argued that ‘the preceding period’ meant any of the preceding periods of five years and that because of this the reviewed rent could not fall below that set on any previous review, even when this was considerably higher than market rent.
And the result?
The High Court judge hearing the case, Charleton J, agreed with Bewley’s. He said that the words ‘preceding period’ meant the intial period of five years under the lease only. This meant that the rent could be reduced on review below the previously reviewed rent, though not below the initial rent set under the lease.
This will have huge implications for commercial property in Ireland. Most upwards only rent review clauses are in the same form as the Bewley’s one. Such clauses can now only be relied on by landlords in a limited way. Where the market rent on review is lower than the rent set on previous reviews, the landlord cannot force the tenant to keep paying the rent set on previous reviews. The landlord is entitled to stop the rent falling below the initial rent, but that is all.
Was Charleton right?
I am not sure that his interpretation of the words ‘preceding period’ was correct. The clause specifically refers to ‘periods of five years’ and as such the term ‘preceding period’ would appear to refer to any preceding period of five years and not just, as Charleton J held, the initial five years of the lease.
However the decision makes sense as in practice upwards only rent review clauses are a commercial disaster, a windfall to a landlord (assuming the tenant has money to pay) but a commercial disaster for a tenant.
Can the decision be appealed?
Yes, to the Supreme Court. It will be interesting to see what happens here. However the backlog of cases in the Supreme Court is such that it could take up to two years for an appeal to be heard.
Are you getting a bitter after-taste from this coffee?
(Graham Hughes/Photocall Ireland)
Via David Lynch