‘It Doesn’t Matter How It’s Done, Audrey’





From top: Audrey Carville; Eugene Cummins, chairman of the national sub-committee on housing of the Local Government Management Association and chief executive of Roscommon County Council

Further to the publication of Minister for Housing Simon Coveney’s Action Plan for Housing and Homelessness earlier this week, which included plans to provide 47,000 new social housing units between now and 2021, RTÉ’s Audrey Carville spoke to Eugene Cummins about the plans on Morning Ireland earlier.

Mr Cummins is the chairman of the national sub-committee on housing of the Local Government Management Association and chief executive of Roscommon County Council.

Ms Carville introduced her interview by posing the question: how many of these social housing units will be built by local authorities.

Audrey Carville:How many houses will local authorities build, under this plan?”

Eugene Cummins: “Well, over the life of the plan, the local authority social housing stock will increase by 47,000 units and we are confident that that figure will be achieved, if not exceeded.”

Carville:But how many houses will you build?”

Cummins: “Well, over the life of the plan – and in the first years of that – we will be focusing on the Housing Assistance Payment (HAP), acquisitions and the returning of units, void units into use. It will of course, the size of the scale of the investment, it will require the planning for estates, it will involve the private sector getting back into building so it’s going to take a few years, a few years, until we start actually building. But, over the next two years in particular, we will continue to acquire properties and to bring social housing by way of the Housing Assistance Payment.”

Carville: “So out of those 47,000 houses, how many will you build?

Cummins: “In terms of the 47,000 units,  some of those units, a considerable number of those units will actually be acquired from the private sector…”

Carville: “But how many will local authorities build over the next five years?

Cummins: “We will, we have to have regard to the market. We will be building where it is cheap to buy units, we will buy units from the private sector, but we will be building a considerable number over the next few years to make sure that, at the end of the plan, that whether we acquire them or build them, there will be an additional 47,000 units added to the social housing stock in this country.”

Carville: “But you don’t have a figure for how many you will build between now and 2021?

Cummins: “As I said, Audrey, we will be acquiring properties, we’ll be leasing properties and we will also be building considerable numbers of properties to increase…”

Carville: “But you’re not giving me actual figures. How many? That’s what has been absent. Simon Coveney, this week, said he believed that local authorities would build 26,000 houses in five years. Is that a realistic figure?

Cummins: “Yes, that is a realistic figure.”

Carville: “But you hadn’t mentioned it, so…”

Cummins: “What I have said..”

Carville: “Where does that fit in with local authority plans?”

Cummins: “What I’ve said is we will be increasing the social housing stock in this country by 47,000 units and we will be doing that by acquisitions and by building.”

Carville: “But I’m asking you, how many will you build? And you haven’t given me a number.”

Cummins:We will be increasing the social housing stock by 47,000 and that is all that matters.”

Carville: “No. The 47,000 is between, there’s no breakdown, we don’t know how much will be local authority housing, we don’t know how much will be private housing.”

Cummins: “But as long as the social housing stock is increased by 47,000 units, that’s all that matters and that’s what we will be doing. And we will be working with the private sector. Remember this is not just about the local authorities. There are many stakeholders, including the private sector, that are involved in providing solutions to this problem.”

Carville: “But people say it does matter how many local authorities are building because, when the private sector gets involved, it becomes a for-profit venture. And the targets and the figures rarely materialise.”

Cummins: “No, what I’m saying is that local authorities will build social houses but we will also buy social housing from the private sector. We will not be expecting the private sector to provide social housing per se; we will be acquiring them from…”

Carville: “How many?”

Cummins:47,000 units, in total, we will be increasing the social housing stock by. It doesn’t matter how it’s done, Audrey. We will be having a significant build programme and we will be acquiring properties and we will increase the social housing stock for people who are on our housing list by at least 47,000 units over the life of the plan.”

Carville: “Why aren’t you able to start sooner than two to three years? Alan Kelly’s plan was laid before the councils nearly two years ago – why aren’t you in a position to begin building sooner?”

Cummins: “Because, first of all, the solution to his problem requires a collaborative approach from all of the stakeholders, that will mean a huge increase in building output. And that can’t start overnight because there’s a plan in process, there’s a tendering process, there’s a procurement process…”

Carville: “But you have all those powers at the moment. You can give yourself those powers to give yourself planning permission to build. Why isn’t the process going to happen sooner?”

Cummins: “No, it’s important for your listeners to understand that there’s a process involved when a scheme of houses is planned. It has to go through the planning process, it has to go through a tendering process and all of that takes time.”

Carville: “But what have you been doing in the last nearly two years, since the previous plan by Alan Kelly? Which this one [plan] has built on?”

Cummins:Last year alone local authorities brought 13,000 units back into social housing stock.”

Carville: “But you only built around 70.”

Cummins: “That is correct because that’s all the money we had and the reason we got out of building houses in the past was because, in recent years, is because money hasn’t been provided and the minister – and indeed the Taoiseach – at their announcement on Tuesday, they’ve clearly allocated €5.35billion… We didn’t…we stopped building houses because the funding stream stopped. Now that the funding stream has been committed, we will start building again but that takes time.”

Carville:So are there any sites, so? There must be sites at this stage? That are shovel-ready? That are ready to begin building on?”

Cummins: “There are sites and, as we speak, houses are being built.”

Carville: “Where?”

Cummins: “In Dún Laoghaire Rathdown and in other areas around the country..”

Carville: “How many are being built there?”

Cummins:There are hundreds of houses being built but it’s not near enough. But, again, can I say we’re not just relying on building. When we exited the boom, there were tens of thousands of units vacant, there still are 200,000 units vacant in this country..”

Carville: “And you have the power to make compulsory purchase orders so how many of those homes, vacant homes, derelict homes, how many have you bought in the past year?”

Cummins: “Last year, we bought 1,000 units. We’ve bought over 2,100 units from Nama over the last couple of years; there are another 500 units in the process of being delivered through Nama and we’re also, as I said, we required 100 units.”

Carville: “How many more do you plan to buy through compulsory purchase orders?”

Cummins: “We don’t need to exercise our compulsory purchase powers to buy on the market. We are successfully buying properties every day…”

Carville: “But how many? Because there are 100,000 families on the social housing waiting list.”

Cummins: “There are actually more and that’s why this action plan is so important and that is why we and the Government, and indeed the minister, are committed to increasing the housing stock by 47,000 units and we will do that. But it requires all of the stakeholders to get together in a collaborative way and we are up to the challenge.”

Carville: “But how many…”

Cummins: “We did it before…”

Carville: “Yes, you did, absolutely. But we’re trying to establish how many properties you are going to buy through compulsory purchase orders or other measures over the next five years.”

Cummins: “As I’ve said, at the very start of the interview, by the end of the plan we will have increased the social housing stock by at least 47,000 units and we will do that by building, leasing, by bringing voids back into use and we are committed to doing that and we will do that.”

Carville: “But is that exclusively through your management, through the management of local authorities?”

Cummins: “As I said, it requires a collaborative approach from all of the stakeholders, not least of all the private sector…”

Listen back in full here

20 thoughts on “‘It Doesn’t Matter How It’s Done, Audrey’

    1. realPolithicks

      This pedal and cranker is a perfect example of why nothing ever gets done in Ireland.

  1. Murtles

    “But how many houses will you build?”
    Long winded sentence with obscure jargon like “bringing back voids”
    “But how many houses will you build?”
    Talk about buying stuff, mention figures, hope question will go away
    “But how many houses will you build?”
    Purple monkey dishwasher

    1. rotide

      “But how many houses will you build?”
      We will provide 47,000 units
      “But how many houses will you build?”
      We will provide 47,000 units
      “But how many houses will you build?”
      We will provide 47,000 units
      “But how many houses will you build?”
      We will provide 47,000 units

      That’s not what an interviewer is supposed to do.

    1. Back In Black

      I was watching it on the rte news now channel. it was truly brutal. he was reading from a script and actually Audrey was quite gentle. Disturbed me to be honest how truly incompetent and useful as tits on a bull he sounded

  2. Coles

    Whatever it takes to force up property rents/yields/prices/values. There is no other plan except to enrich property owners.

  3. Rainy Day

    Clever move to put a civil servant up for sacrificial ambush by RTE, one wonders would she have been as tough on Coveney if he came on to explain the figures. She did her job well though for what was put in front of her.

  4. Tish Mahorey

    “As I said, Audrey, ”
    “As I’ve said, at the very start of the interview, ”

    Arrogant and misleading.

  5. Tish Mahorey

    Oh and Carville is from a Fine Gael household so don’t expect too much prodding of Fine Gael policies by her. Nobody makes it far in RTE if they don’t play the game.

  6. 15 cents

    we the public have had to really make a racket for the government to decide to do something about the housing crisis .. and what do they do? turn it into a money spinner. before even beginning.

    the absolute waffle out of this idiot. the usual guff, he’s been given one line to fall back on, and just keeps repeating it. and his reason for it taking so long is so frustratingly made-up. just flat out lying. making things up. clown. he embodies almost everything thats rotten in this country.

  7. 15 cents

    i wouldnt have the patience of the interviewer.. half way through i wouldve said “i have to stop you briefly just to let you know, if you say ‘collaborative approach’ and ‘stakeholders’ im going to stab you in the neck with my pen.. ok, continue, so you were saying how many units you were going to build?”

  8. Jake38

    “But as long as the social housing stock is increased by 47,000 units, that’s all that matters…”

    Seems reasonable, despite all the usual Irish public servant deer-in-the-headlights media-terrified culchie waffle..

  9. rotide

    What a rubbish interview. It was clear in the first 3 answers that the guy was not willing to put a figure on actual builds and his point was there would be 47,000 extra housing units through various means by the end. He wasn’t actually being that evasive, just using the usual govt/managerial waffle.

    He gave an answer. Carville kept repeating herself getting the exact same answer every time when she could have been pushing on other details of the plan.

  10. Mulder

    How to answer a serious question with another question.
    Does this mean they are not going to build some 47,000 houses in ehh 5 years.
    If they use prefabs, then bingo.
    Does the figure also include large tents.

  11. Truth in the News

    The local authorities haven’t a notion of building anything, what’s being done is a
    purchasing programme to buy up housing stock and keep the property prices
    up, if the local authorities build houses, they’d lose the planning fees and development charges and depress the value of houses, quite a few people
    stuck with property would have a second tiger property crash….would there the
    odd politican, guard, or even a county manager or too involved.

Comments are closed.