Jesús, María Y José

at | 26 Replies

This year’s nativity scene at Claremont Methodist church in Los Angeles.

The ‘most well-known refugee family in the world’, according to Pastor Karen Clark Ristine, caged and isolated to highlight both California’s homeless crisis and the separation of migrant children at the US/Mexico border.

designboom

26 thoughts on “Jesús, María Y José

  1. MaryLou's ArmaLite

    They were not migrants, they were in Jerusalem to take part in a census after which they returned to Nazareth.

    Reply
    1. Slightly Bemused

      Ehm, remember the whole ‘fleeing to Egypt with a donkey bit to escape the slaughter of the innocents by Pontius Pilate? That is when they were refugees and migrants.

      Reply
      1. Spaghetti Hoop

        No, it was King Herod. When he heard from the three Magi that a chisler was born and proclaimed the son of God, he was sure he would be usuped and so ordered all boys in the Bethlehem area under two to be killed. That’s why jesus and his ma and da stayed in Egypt.

        Reply
          1. Spaghetti Hoop

            A friend of mine once status-posted on FB proclaiming ‘Just back from a tough session at Pilates – I’m going to be dying tomorrow!’
            Calling her Jesus ever since.

    2. newsjustin

      Bethlehem MaryLou. They were in Bethlehem.

      And as Slightly Bemused rightly says, they were very much refugees, fleeing the threat of persecution.

      Reply
  2. Termagant

    They weren’t migrants, they traveled to an urban centre to be documented and when it was finished they went back home to Nazareth

    Reply
  3. Nigel

    Is… is there a talking point going around about how the Holy Family aren’t like those pesky illegal Mexicans being caged and seperated by the US government? Because the fundamental spirit of the story of the Holy Family (which iincludes fleeing from a military forced intent on ‘seperating’ them from their child) revolves entrely around the legal technicalities of their citizenship status?

    Reply
    1. pedeyw

      Apparently the bit where they fled from genocide of infants doesn’t count because it didn’t happen when Jesus was born.

      Reply
      1. Slightly Bemused

        Well, they were clearly a white family of good Anglo-Saxon descent. Sure don’t all the pictures show that?

        Reply
      2. Nigel

        Two comments making the same rather obtuse point? The same bad-faith interpretation of the scene?
        They WERE a refugee family whe they fled to Egypt – and it seems thuddingly wilful not to have a sense of why their story might resonate with modern refugees and migrants and with people concerned with the plight of modern migrants and refugees.

        Reply
        1. Slightly Bemused

          I was trying to be sarcastic. I guess it does not come across in text. Should I adopt the social media option of /s ?

          Reply
  4. Murtles

    They travelled to the city to watch a show with their child and the fact they were brutally murdered in front of him in alley but he overcame the bitterness of the situation to become a crime fighter. This shows…… oh wait, that’s Batman.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *