Dan Boyle: Power To All Our Friends

at | 8 Replies

Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin after his election in Cork South-Central in General Election 2020; Dan Boyle

I may be imagining this. It certainly isn’t intentional but it probably is sub conscious. The recent representations I have made to my local authority seem to be responded to more quickly, and far more postively. I attribute this to being associated with a political party now a part of government.

This shouldn’t be the case. The extent to which it does is probably reflected in how that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael representatives are given similar deference.

In Cork we don’t know ourselves. The insufferability in which most of the country views us has been given a government seal of approval.

The Dáil constituency I have had the privilege of representing now has three senior government ministers at the cabinet table, including the office of Taoiseach.

It’s a situation that creates unrealistic levels of expectation that can never be met. Whatever resources Cork receives during the period of this government will looked on in the rest of the country as favouritism, even if proportionate.

This expectation is what will inform the sub conscious of the two local government bodies in Cork. Like all city and county councils, the Cork local authorities are over dependent on central government for resources.

Again this shouldn’t be the case. The ability to raise funds and allocate funds, are the ultimate determinants of power and control. Without this ability Irish local government lacks both.

For any government to create a real legacy it could do worse than to let local government free.

Remove the financial ties that bind. Stop local government being beholden to central government. Release the initiative and creativity that would flow once the Customs House would just let local government be.

How ridiculously controlling this relationship has been was brought home to me a number of months ago. The then Department of Children and Youth Affairs gave grants to local authorities for the upkeep of playgrounds.

The playground closest to Cork City Hall was given a grant of €3700. It probably costs more to administer than this grant, than any benefit it would bring about.

The programme for government agreed to bring a new government in being, makes precious little mention of local government reform.

The traditional political parties have shown little interest in bringing such reform about. During my time in public life the movement has been exactly in the opposite direction. Local government has become more centralised, ever more emasculated.

The Progressive Democrats once made the jibe that Ireland was once the most centralised country in Europe outside of Albania. What they meant is that Ireland didn’t encourage the laissez faire capitalism that as a party it preferred.

What they didn’t mean, but where the jibe would have had better effect, is that it could very much be applied to system of Irish local government. Sadly the situation has worsened since then.

My hope is that real local government reform will be a consequence of a government that initially has given it very little consideration. If it does I would be quite happy to be treated, again, with indifference by my local authority.

Dan Boyle is a former Green Party TD and Senator and serves as a Green Party councillor on Cork City Council. His column appears here every Thursday. Follow Dan on Twitter: @sendboyle


8 thoughts on “Dan Boyle: Power To All Our Friends

  1. dav

    Don’t know when ore where I 1st heard it but someone described the concise history of irish politics being available on the doors of any pub in Ireland – “Push” and “Pull”

  2. bisted

    …don’t worry Dan…now that the greens have agreed to keep FFG in power for another five years…normal service should be restored to your parish pump soon…

  3. ReproBertie

    Dan, do you think a comment is needed from the Green Party or from the Minister about the photos circulating of Roderic O’Gorman with Peter Tatchell? To be clear, I’m not looking for you to make a comment on behalf of the party or anything. Just wondering how you feel it should be handled, if at all.

  4. theo kretschmar-schuldorff

    A Cork FF Taoiseach abolished Local Authority rates (and the capacity of municipalities to manage their own affairs) to win the popularity contest 43 years ago.
    Would very much like to see this Cork FF Taoiseach reintroduce them. A Local Property Tax increase would be the correct vehicle, so long as it can be demonstrated which central tax (income/VAT/USC) would reduce.

  5. Otis Blue

    Cork South Central has had senior cabinet representation for the last thirty years, to little evident effect.

    0 x 3 is still 0.

    Big Phil and FG certainly did a job on Local Government back in 2014 making it now less effective and accountable than it had ever been. The function and financing of Local Government that you suggest is badly needed but there’s little to suggest that there’s latent talent and creativity waiting to be unleashed, should the dead hand of the Customs House be removed.

  6. Vanessanelle

    Ah c’mon Dan
    Bemoaning the pollarding of Local Authorities now, of all times btw
    When, back in the Day of Government yourself Dan,
    John Gormley held the post of Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government

    De-funding Local Authorities was well underway before 2007
    So was the privatisation of Social Housing

    So tell me how can I not say – without being accused of being mean, or a troll,
    that the Green Party helped that already established FF FG strategy for Local Authorities along?

    It was in your own hands to reverse it
    And at a unique time to buck the trend,
    Instead ye just went with the flow

    You are probably the most effective and convincing historian on all the Dáils since the founding of the State Dan, but yet you seen to have forgotten the opportunity your own party had in the 30th Dáil

    Ye actually had the Minister for Local Authorities for almost four years Dan,
    and John Gormley was more than just a member of the party with a Senior Ministry,
    He was also your Party Leader

    For all the good he was capable of achieving, he simply carried on where Dick Roche left off


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *