Dan Boyle: Making Up The Numbers (Again)


From top: Fianna Fáil leader Micheal Martin (left) and Fine Gael leader, Taoiseach Leo Varadkar, at the seven way RTÉ leaders’ debate at the National University of Ireland Galway campus last Monday; Dan Boyle

One of the more curious aspects of the number of candidates contesting the general election is the relatively few who are contesting on behalf of Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael.

Fianna Fáil are running an additional thirteen candidates but that is from the historically low figure of 71 in 2016. Fine Gael is running seven fewer candidates this time, although that is still much higher than its historic low of 51 candidates way back in 1944.

If either succeeded in having all their candidates selected, a bare majority Dáil would be achieved. Between them FF and FG are running 164 candidates nearly 100 down the historic collective high of 264 in 1981.

Traditionally the overwhelming majority of candidates in any general election would have been either FF or FG. This hasn’t been the case during the last number of elections, as the electorate has been offered a more varied choice.

Only at two general elections has a third Irish political party offered enough candidates to seek to to be able to govern in their own right.

In 1948 Clann na Poblachta ran 94 candidates winning ten seats. In 1969 the Labour Party, wanting the Seventies to be socialist, stood 99 candidates winning eighteen seats.

It may be the case that by the time of the next General Election, no Irish political party will be presenting enough candidates to be a single majority government.

Perhaps this has been inevitable. A single party majority government hasn’t been elected in Ireland since 1977. A stand alone single party government, without a majority, hasn’t been  brought into being since 1987.

Despite this our traditional political parties have not changed their culture all that much, still intent on practicing a winner takes all approach.

For this we can be thankful we have a voting system that is far fairer than those found in the UK or the US. The more political choice that exists the more fair our voting system becomes.

The likelihood is that future Irish governments will be made up of three, four or more parties – making government formation more and more difficult.

Of course this might be all be stymied if a grand coalition were to be agreed between FF and FG, or even if the long awaited merger between the two were ever to come about.

This remains unlikely.

While in terms of principles, such as they are, and certainly in terms of policies there is nothing that distinguishes one party from another. They also know that the only reason they are not one party is that neither could not exist without the separate existence of the other.

They also know that if they ever were to join together that the sum of them together will be less than the value of them apart. The union would also be subject to diminishing returns, at a far quicker pace than their duopoly has been.

So, somewhat pathetically, both parties will avoid any coming together on the grounds that neither wants to become just another ‘ordinary’ party.

Our future political maturity depends on this coyness being overcome.

In the meantime it is also unlikely to be matched by a coming together of the centre left any time soon. The insistence of not being able to match the moral purity of each other, means that the over contested progressive vanguard will remain weak.

There stands the moribund dynamic of Irish politics. A receding uncertain centre right there to be overtaken by a non assertive progressive left that continues to argue about whether or not it wants to be government.

We deserve better.

Dan Boyle is a former Green Party TD and Senator and serves as a Green Party councillor on Cork City Council. His column appears here every Thursday. Follow Dan on Twitter: @sendboyle

Top pic: Niall Carson/PA Wire

Sponsored Link

8 thoughts on “Dan Boyle: Making Up The Numbers (Again)

  1. garrett

    We deserve better………………….. than the Green Party, a party with no policies other than taxation
    Everyone should read their manifesto, full of vague plans with the exception of tax increases

    Tax on rock
    Carbon tax on home heating
    Aviation tax
    Tax on Ferries
    Tax on sand and gravel
    Increase tax on diesel

    other than the above it’s all “work towards” “review”. Absolute b***p**

    1. Rob_G

      All of those things are bad for the environment, so why are you surprised?

      Taxing people is the quickest way to change people’s behaviour – there were loads of public information campaigns about the dangers of smoking, etc, to limited effect. It was only when they began to tax the bejaysus out of the things that smoking rates really began to tumble.

    2. ReproBertie

      Among the non-taxation policies listed in their manifesto are:
      – Introduce a childcare payment, and mandate a price ceiling for childcare services.
      – Limit the financial demands schools makes on parents by subsidising school books and eliminating other charges.
      – Remove sale of a property as a reason for ending a lease
      – Create transport hubs and orbital bus routes for better connectivity
      – Introduce hybrid and emission-free buses
      – Invest in an all-Ireland rail network
      – Enshrine public ownership of water in Bunreacht na hÉireann.
      – Allow homes with rooftop solar panels to sell excess energy to the national grid.
      – Expand the Rural Transport Programme.

    3. Cú Chulainn

      We do indeed deserve better: here’s one: when a smaller party get into coalition government they stick to their policies. When the GP got in we got diesel cars, a massive death trap incinerator, Corrie gas, motorway through the Skyrne valley.. I could go on.. oh, I nearly forgot, we got 10 car charging points using electricity made from burning oil.

      1. Cian

        Not feasible to stick to their policies. When you have a coalition there needs to be compromise on both sides. The compromise will be based on their relative sizes.

        The “problem” they had in the past is that (for the Greens + FF coalition) the Greens has ~10% of the power, but got 90% of the blame for the FF/Green government. From a FF perspective it was a massive win; the Greens were wiped out.

  2. Zaccone

    The Greens, SocDems and Labour combined should get the guts of 20% of the vote this election. With almost nothing different between them in terms of major policies.

    If the individual egos in each party could get over it a merger would create a reasonably strong centre-left party, to benefit from the decline of FF/FG. But thats probably unlikely any time soon I fear.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link