For The Record


Screen Shot 2014-08-01 at 11.41.119781907593963-2

From top:  A US military aircraft at Shannon Airport in July 2013 and, above, Whistleblower, Soldier, Spy by Tom Clonan, retired army officer, lecturer at Dublin Institute of Technology and Irish Times security analyst.

You may recall a post from last week concerning Margaretta D’Arcy and her appearance on Tonight With Vincent Browne, which was being hosted by Dearbhail McDonald.

Ms D’Arcy’s appearance followed her recent imprisonment in Limerick Prison – for refusing to sign a bond stating she would not enter restricted areas of Shannon Airport, on foot of her arrest for protesting at the airport on September 1, 2013.

During their discussion, Ms McDonald asked Ms D’Arcy if she had definitive evidence that US military planes flying in from the US carry weapons. Ms D’Arcy said she didn’t but she said there was no definitive evidence to prove the opposite. She then appealed for the Irish government to inspect the planes.

Readers may wish to know that during her court hearing at Ennis District Court on June 24 – in relation to her September 1, 2013 arrest – there was evidence given by Dr Tom Clonan, Irish Times security analyst and author of Whistleblower, Solider, Spy in which he stated he saw weapons on a US military plane in Shannon.

Dr Clonan’s testimony, and that of others, went largely unreported in the national media.

Much of Dr Clonan’s testimony is contained in his book, Whistlebower, Soldier, Spy, which includes an account of his visit to Guantanamo Bay, where he became the first journalist to get US Army officials to admit — on the record — their intention to execute prisoners and to admit that they force-feed detainees who are on hunger strike.

In the book, he also recounts his experience of being the first Irish journalist to interview US troops in Shannon Airport and, indeed, to board one of their planes.

On Ireland’s ‘neutrality’…

“In 2002, ‘neutral’ Ireland is providing troops, vital logistics and air support and material support for the war in Afghanistan. We are, whether the general public realises it or not, at war. In an unprecedented move, the American military at US Europe Command Headquarters in Stuttgart assign a permanent staff officer to Shannon Airport. Shannon is officially a ‘virtual’ US airbase. In 2002, NATO designates its army in Afghanistan the ‘International Security Assistance Force’ or ISAF. On NATO’s official ISAF website, Ireland and the Irish flag is listed as a member of the ‘coalition of the willing’ who are participating in the Global War on Terror in NATO’s first war on the Asian continent.”

On the costs incurred by the Irish taxpayer…

“The Irish taxpayer is paying up to €10,000 per day for the en-route navigation costs and air traffic control management of thousands of US high-altitude bombers, refuelling aircraft and other airborne weapon systems travelling through Irish airspace. In other words, the Irish taxpayer is making a direct financial contribution to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Under a European Union agreement, ‘Eurocontrol’ to which Ireland is a signatory, the Irish government has agreed to pay the navigation fees and air traffic control levies for US military aircraft passing through our airspace. Since 75 per cent of all European-US air traffic passes through Irish airspace, this presents the Irish taxpayer with a significant bill. Figures obtained from the Irish Aviation Authority reveal that in 2004 along, €3.6million in navigation fees for US military aircraft heading to or from the battle space in Iraq and Afghanistan had been charged to the Department of Finance.”


On a conversation he had with Dr Ali Mokdad, a  Hizbullah member of Lebanese parliament…

“I ask Dr Mokdad about the safety of Irish troops in Lebanon given their ongoing hostilities between Hizbullah and the Israelies. Mokdad tells me over the phone that the Irish are very welcome in Lebanon and ‘as long as the Irish don’t interfere with our social work south of the Litani river, they should not have a problem.’ Dr Mokdad does warn me, however, that any attempt on the part of the UN to interfere with Hizbullah’ combat operations would be considered a ‘hostile act’. He explains, ‘In these circumstances, let me be explicit. There should be no searches, no confiscation of weapons, or interference. If the UN did these things, it would help the Israelies and that would be a different story, with a different outcome for UN soldiers.’ I take this to be a thinly veiled threat against Irish troops attempting to execute a UN mandate.’

“Meanwhile, D Mokdad continues. ‘The Irish people have nothing to fear from Hizbullah. Orient your fear towards Israel and its intentions in Lebanon’. As I scribble down notes of the conversation and as Darach [one of Dr Clonan’s sons sitting on his lap] strains to hear the doctor, Mokdad moves on to the subject of US troops at Shannon Airport in County Clare. He pronounces ‘County Clare’ with great emphasis. ‘There is no humanity when you allow your airports to be used to move soldiers or weapons from one side to another. It is not fair. It is not good. I am not glad to say it about the Irish, but it is true. I know that you have a special relationship with America, but it should be used for peace, not moving weapons and soldiers. These weapons hurt us and our children… the Irish should not cooperate with the movement of war materials and forces.’ I thank Dr Mokdad for his time and his comments. Darach says goodbye down the phone. Dr Mokdad calls him habibi or darling. It is the first time I have heard a major Islamic resistance group condemn the use of Shannon by US troops. The Irish Times includes excerpts from the interview the following day.”

On seeing weapons on a US Marine Corps plane that landed in Shannon…

“Another ATA flight from the US Marine Corps’ Camp Lejeune in North Carolina lands at Shannon. On board are members of the US Marine Cops Regimental Combat Team 2, 2nd Marine Regiment, bound for deployment to Al Anbar Province, Iraq. As the ATA Boeing 757 aircraft taxies to the arrival gate, I haggle with the ATA ground staff and am given permission to board the plane. With the aircraft door just opened, the sight inside is a little unusual. There are no passengers crowding the aisles, reaching for hand luggage in the overhead cabins as is the norm among civilians prior to disembarking after a long flight. Instead, stretching right back to the rear of the aircraft, there are row upon row of crew-cut marines in identical combat fatigues, sitting in total silence. The ATA announcer on board the aircraft states, ‘Folks, good morning, welcome to Shannon. You’re going to be on the ground here for 45 minutes. The bar and the duty-free are available and there is a smoking section just straight across from the bar. All weapons must remain on board the aircraft and that includes gun holsters. Thank you.’ I scan the aircraft floor. Sure enough. There are weapons on board. Assault rifles and automatic pistols. So much for Irish government denials about the transit of armed troops through Shannon.”

Meanwhile, last week in Strasbourg, Poland became the first EU country to be found complicit in the CIA’s extraordinary rendition programme.

The European Court of Human Rights ruled that Poland – which had always denied that the CIA operated a secret jail on its territory – broke the European Convention on Human Rights by helping the CIA to render two terror suspects, Saudi-born Palestinian Abu Zubaydah and Saudi national Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri.

Both men – who are currently held at Guantanamo Bay – claim that in December 2002 they were taken to Poland on board the same rendition plane.

Mr Al Nashiri claims to have been captured in Dubai in October 2002, transferred to secret CIA detention facilities in Afghanistan and Thailand, before being brought to Poland in December 5, 2002, and held there until June 2003 before being brought to Morocco and then, in September 2003, to Guantanomo Bay.

Mr Al Nashiri – accused of orchestrating the USS Cole bombing in Yemen in 2000 – that he was subjected to “unauthorised” interrogation methods, including mock executions, prolonged stress positions – kneeling on the floor and leaning back – and threatened with his family being brought to the site and abused in front of him if he did not provide information.

Mr Zubaydah claims he was captured in Pakistan in March 2002 and subsequently transferred to a secret CIA detention facility in Thailand, before being brought to Poland on December 5, 2002, where he was held until September 22, 2003. He was then taken to Guantanamo Bay.

In the judgement of his case against Poland, it states that between 2008 and 2011 he suffered more than 300 seizures and, at some point during his captivity, he lost his left eye.

The ECHR also ruled that Poland failed to conduct a proper investigation into the events surrounding the men, and ordered the Polish government to pay €100,000 to each of the men as means of compensation.

In a press release following the decision, and among other things, the ECHR said:

“[The ECHR] also found that Poland had known of the nature and purposes of the CIA’s activities on its territory at the material time. Poland had cooperated in the preparation and execution of the CIA rendition, secret detention and interrogation operations on its territory in the following manner: by enabling the CIA to use its airspace and the airport; by its complicity in disguising the movements of rendition aircraft; and, by providing logistics and services, including special security arrangements, a special procedure for landings, the transportation of CIA teams with detainees on land, and the securing of the Stare Kiejkuty base for the CIA’s secret detention. Having regard to the widespread public information about ill-treatment and abuse of detained terrorist suspects in the custody of the US authorities, Poland ought to have known that, by enabling the CIA to detain such persons on its territory, it was exposing them to a serious risk of treatment contrary to the Convention.”

In light of this decision, how does Ireland’s position look now, in relation to the use of Shannon Airport?

In February of last year, the Open Society Justice Initiative released a report, called Globalizing Torture, which named Ireland as one of the 54 countries identified as colluding with authorities in the US to operate the CIA’s extraordinary rendition programme.

The report also claimed that it is suspected planes involved in the rendition programme refuelled in Shannon before being used to transport… the very same Abd al Nashiri.

From the report:

Ireland permitted the use of its airspace and airports for flights associated with CIA extraordinary rendition operations. A 2007 European Parliament report “express[ed] serious concern about the stopovers made by CIA-operated aircraft at Irish airports that on many occasions came from or were bound for countries linked with extraordinary rendition circuits and the transfer of detainees.”

It added:

Richmor-operated flights were involved in the extraordinary rendition of the Egyptian cleric Abu Omar and are also suspected of having refuelled at Shannon before transporting Abd al Nashiri. Diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks in 2010 revealed that former Irish Foreign Affairs Minister Dermot Ahern told US Ambassador Thomas Foley that he was “quite convinced that at least three flights involving renditions had refuelled at Shannon Airport before or after conducting renditions elsewhere. Other cables revealed that former US Ambassador James Kenny noted in 2006 that the Irish government had “acted to ensure continued US military transits at Shannon in the face of public criticism” despite public concern that the airport was being used for extraordinary rendition flights.”


“In June 2011, the U.N. Committee against Torture stated that it was “concerned at the various reports of [Ireland’s] alleged cooperation in a rendition programme, where rendition flights use the State party’s airports and airspace,” and that it was “also concerned at the inadequate response by the State party with regard to investigating these allegations.”

Read the ECHR’s press release following the ruling from here, the judgement in the case of Al Nashiri V Poland here and the judgement in the case of Abu Zubaydah V Poland here

Read the Open Society Justice Initiative report, Globalizing Terror, here

Poland broke human rights convention on al-Qaida suspects held by the CIA (The Guardian)

Related: Anger at rendition flights through Shannon (Irish Examiner, Seán McCárthaigh and Mary Regan, September 2, 2011)

Previously: Dirty Stop Overs

Whistleblower, Soldier, Spy (Tom Clonan) Liberties Press

Pic of plane: Clare Daly

Sponsored Link

16 thoughts on “For The Record

  1. Odis

    So managing Irish air space is an act of war?
    Its this sort of junk, that rubbishes the worthwhile protest against American imperialism

  2. jungleman

    Tom Clonan’s IT profile states that he “is a retired army officer with experience in the Middle East and former Yugoslavia.” I wonder how much of his time in the DF he spent overseas in total.

    1. Dr Tom Clonan

      My overseas service in DF is covered in detail in my book, ‘Blood, Sweat and Tears’ and in my latest book ‘Whistleblower, Soldier, Spy’. I served with the Battalion Mobile Reserve, 78Bn Lebanon during Israeli ‘Grapes of Wrath’ operation against Hizbullah and Lebanese civilian population south of Litani 1995-1996.
      I spent further periods in Lebanon and Syria as Staff Officer in Chief of Staff’s Branch (Captain) 1998-2000.
      I also blew the whistle on Sexual Harassment and bullying within the DF as part of my PhD. My findings were vindicated by an Independent Govt Enquiry (Study Review Group)
      I am proud of my military service and proud to have made a positive contribution at home and overseas.
      Captain Tom Clonan (Retired)

  3. lolly

    I’ve heard Clonan discuss this many times on the radio and on TV. Of course the soldiers have guns on them, doesn’t surprise me in the least. I doubt anyone except maybe Ian O’Doherty is happy about the Americans stopping in Shannon and Ms. D’Arcy’s protest is a noble thing but I can’t see anything changing.

  4. Anne

    So renditions and weapons confirmed on flights that stopped at Shannon.
    Some amount of information there.. Thanks.
    (3 comments. Wondering where are all the numpties who give out about the less serious posts?)

  5. Am I Still on This Island

    Ireland is not neutral, in any sense of the word this, was confirmed when an ex Irish army officer and current peace protestor took a case agains the state in early 2000’s and was beyond any doubt informed that there is no law, or appeals process if the 3 branches of government decide to engage in conflict or partake in a particular event.

    1. Anne

      and was beyond any doubt informed that there is no law, or appeals process if the 3 branches of government decide to engage in conflict or partake in a particular event


      The ECHR also ruled that Poland failed to conduct a proper investigation into the events surrounding the men, and ordered the Polish government to pay €100,000 to each of the men as means of compensation…Poland ought to have known that, by enabling the CIA to detain such persons on its territory, it was exposing them to a serious risk of treatment contrary to the Convention

  6. scottser

    so if there’s all this evidence of extraordinary rendition by the US, how come they aren’t facing sanctions? how come, as seems to be presented here, there is more scrutiny of countries colluding with the US than is aimed at the US itself? surely the way to stop ireland’s collusion is to ban the US from these activities through international courts?

  7. steve white

    they do this thing of claiming there no weapons on the planes when the planes themselves are machines of war and then carry the soldiers on civilian planes and then claim, they are not transport more instruments of war.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link