10 thoughts on “Siren Song

  1. John E. Bravo

    Anyone know the tune? Seems to start off similarly to Auld Lang Syne, but I’m not great on reading music.

  2. Carlos

    Oddly if you whistle it, it doesn’t sound a million miles away from the Last Post.

    49,000 Irish were killed in WW1.

    1. Eamonn Clancy

      No, it’s accepted that figure is way over the top. It relates to men killed in Irish battalions. Still doesn’t get away to the fact they were all conned into fighting for an army that saw them as cannon fodder and nothing else.

      1. rotide

        Wasn’t just the irish that were seen that way, most battalions were treated that way. It was the accepted way to fight a war at the time.

      2. Casey

        No, it’s accepted that figure is way over the top

        By who may I ask?

        All the reseaech I have seen on this indicates that the figure is much hiugher nearer to the 100000 mark as the Irish soldier serving in British (and Canadian) batallians were often counted as losses for the armies of that country rather than being counted as an Irishman.

        Source: The book Irishmen or English Soldiers
        http://books.google.co.uk/books/about/Irishmen_Or_English_Soldiers.html

        Peter Karsten’s research paper, “Irish Soldiers in the British Army, 1792-1922
        http://jsh.oxfordjournals.org/content/17/1/31.full.pdf+html

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link
Broadsheet.ie