Return To Censor


Screen Shot 2016-01-18 at 10.41.29 Screen Shot 2016-01-18 at 10.41.45

Ah here.

An email from Denis O’Brien to Des Carville at the Department of Finance, obtained by journalist Gavin Sheridan, under the Freedom of Information Act

You may recall how the sale of Siteserv to Denis O’Brien’s Isle-of-Man-based acquisition vehicle Millington in March 2012 came after Davy Stockbrokers and KPMG were tasked with finding a buyer by a subcommittee of the Siteserv board.

Des Carville was the Davy adviser to Siteserv during the sale. Mr Carville previously helped Davy to advise Mr O’Brien on deals involving Esat.

Some 18 months after the sale of Siteserv, in November 2013, Mr Carville, a former KPMG employee, joined the Department of Finance as Head of its Shareholder Management Unit.

Denis O’Brien’s email to Des Carville (The Story, Gavin Sheridan)

Meanwhile, separately, in yesterday’s Sunday Times, Brian Carey wrote:

“For all the world, the inquiry into loan write-offs at IBRC looks like it was built to collapse: the towering edifice, the flimsy foundation, the complex material, the entirely infeasible completion deadline.”

“It ran out of control well before it was due to begin. By estimating a duration of several years, judge Brian Cregan first rendered the whole prospect outrageous. It was the government’s decision to broaden the probe to 38 transactions and losses to the state bank of more than €10m. Now the government claims that an investigation could cost as much as a tribunal.”

There never were grounds for a probe of that scope, depth, length or expense, nor was one ever demanded. And so the public’s quest for truth runs aground in a legal quagmire of confidentiality , privilege and enormous expenses. How convenient.”

“There were only ever a handful of questions that begged answers in this affair. Did Denis O’Brien, the most powerful businessman in the country, receive preferential treatment in his dealings with IBRC? Was he unduly favoured in his purchase of Siteserv, a utilities service company which was heavily indebted to the bank? Did he get preferential rates of interest on his own personal borrowings?”

“… KPMG could review, as suggested by Cregan, the top 12 write-offs, provided once again there is no conflict of interest. It is the job of a liquidator to investigate the affairs of a bust company. As yet, the evidence is not there to justify a wide-ranging, lengthy and expensive judicial inquiry. Frankly the public should be aghast that one should take place without, at least, establishing a case for such a probe.”

By the same token, the Siteserv issue should not be buried with this administration. Right now, this looks like a manufactured botch job.”

IBRC loan inquiry risks being botched into oblivion (The Sunday Times)

Previously: Bringing The House Down

Sponsored Link

24 thoughts on “Return To Censor

  1. Zuppy International

    Step away from the conspiracy… lower your tin-foil hat… nothing to see here… move along…

  2. Kolmo

    Sky is blue, bears poo in the woods and the sea is wet. Shocker.

    Nicely played. I’m not even angry…no, wait I am.

  3. Digs

    I like Denis. He creates employment and gets rich while doing it. Is that not the aspiration of every business person?

    1. scottser

      it’s more like he gets rich by any means necessary, then employs lots of lawyers to cover his @rse.

  4. Mickey Twopints

    I’d love to be outraged at that redaction, but surely it’s just censoring the email details of the addressees?

  5. Liggy

    What a load of old ████████ Amazing how people like ████████ ████████ and ████████ ████████ can do what they want in this country and others get years in jail for describing apples as garlic.

    I would ████████ the lot of them in the Irish sea. CJ ████████ and PJ ████████ may be gone but their spirit lives on.

  6. postmanpat

    You can take a flying███████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████…till the handle breaks off and you have to get a doctor to pull it out again!

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link