A Nation Holds Its Nose




From top: Emmanuel Macron Francois Fillon and Marine Le Pen; Shene Heneghan

With four candidates within 3% of one another in the polls, France’s presidential election remains volatile. The two most dramatic statistics frequently ignored in the past few weeks, however, are the high level of undecided voters (as much as one third) and those who say they won’t vote (about 28% in a country where 80% turnouts are the norm).

All this, together with the tragic shooting of a policeman in central Paris just days before voting make this easily the toughest French presidential election to call in the history of the 5th republic.

A year ago, many pundits would have said the election of Marine Le Pen as president was considerably more likely than that of Donald Trump or a vote for Brexit and she has done her best to make the most of these two events.

Her campaign has been scandal-ridden from the off with allegations of misappropriation of funds from the European Parliament to loan agreements with those close to the Kremlin in Russia. Despite all this, and despite her party’s poor record in other recent elections (the FN was expected to make breakthroughs in the most recent regional elections but failed) she is still the woman to beat.

If she wins, France’s place in the euro and the EU itself are both very much up for discussion and without France, the continued existence of both is unlikely.

Her main rival began this campaign as an outsider, but as a man who fell in love with, then subsequently married his secondary school French teacher, Emmanuel Macron is used to overcoming the odds.

Apart from a brief stint as economy minister under President Hollande he has no government experience. He left government to set up his own centrist, grassroots, staunchly pro-EU political movement, “En Marche” which has since gone from strength to strength. He now has a strong chance of meeting it through to the 2nd round.

Another candidate firing up his party base is veteran left winger Jean-Luc Mélenchon- who is perhaps best described as a French Bernie Sanders. Like Sanders, he has been drawing big numbers to rallies recently – even to ones where he appears by hologram. Though turnout with the far left is always an issue and most polls have him a few points behind he cannot be ruled out from getting through on Sunday.

The early favourite for this contest was the centre-right’s Francois Fillon who saw poll numbers tumble when it emerged he may have been paying his wife around half a million euro a year to do more or less nothing.

Despite this fall from grace, he is still hovering around 20% in polls, doing very well among the over 60s and Catholics (two groups with consistently high turnout) and benefits from a well-resourced campaign. Staunchly opposing adoption rights for same sex couples and in favour of limiting immigration and stronger relations with Russia, Fillon can be described as being on the right of his own party.

One of the main advantages Fillon would have over his rivals if he were elected is the ability to form a Parliamentary majority after the election. Officially speaking at least, none of the other three can count on more than a handful of MPs in the Assemblee Nationale.

The legislative elections that happen within a few weeks of the second round of the presidential election are bound to give the incumbent a boost but it would be highly unlikely that any of these three movements came close to an outright majority. Fillon himself has his rivals in his own party and may not always get his own way in Parliament.

We can say therefore that the next President of France is likely to be a weak figure whose tenure may change the relationship between Parliament and Presidency for the foreseeable future.

Shane Heneghan is a Brussels-based election and poll watcher. Follow Shane on Twitter: @shaneheneghan

Update: Emmanuel Macron and Marine Le Pen estimated to be through to second round (Guardian)

26 thoughts on “A Nation Holds Its Nose

    1. jusayinlike

      Both pro Israel anti Islam nutcases, 2 cheeks of the same backside, the other “candidate” is a school teacher. Hate that France..

    2. Ronan

      Disagree. If the fatally tarnished Fillon progresses, Le Pen has every chance of winning in a fortnight. Macron is more appealing to the (crucial and unrepresented in run-off) left constituency. Despite being seen as a traitor to PES and standing for nothing of substance (for Communists).

  1. shitferbrains

    ” veteran left winger Jean-Luc Mélenchon- who is perhaps best described as a French Bernie Sanders. ”
    Yeah right.

    A supporter of a blanket boycott of the Jewish state, in 2014 he praised participants of violent protests against Israel, calling their behavior exemplary despite the fact that some of them tried to burn down several synagogues. He condemned French Jews who demonstrated peacefully in support of Israel, suggesting their actions were tantamount to taking up arms “for a foreign country.”

    He’s an old style Soviet anti-semite.

      1. Ben Redmond

        Francois Fillon and his wife and 5 children go to Mass, which counts for something. He probably has a taste for fine wines and good architecture. That’s culture. What would he think of a pint of Guinness?

        1. newsjustin

          He’s sane and centre-right. Will attract votes away from Le Pen in a run-off. The French will just have to ignore the whole fake job for the missus stuff.

  2. Spaghetti Hoop

    Fillon has damaged himself via Penelope-gate and Le Pen has the majority. My French friends and colleagues are voting strongly against Le Pen (for anyone) just to ensure she doesn’t get in. It is quite convenient for her that there was a terrorist attack three days previous.

      1. Mickey Twopints

        Have you received any indication as to how your French friends and colleagues are intending to vote, Peter?

        1. Peter Dempsey

          Mickey – half for Le Pen and half against her.

          I have the ability to get on with people of all political beliefs / attitudes and don’t restrict myself to an echo chamber where no dissent is allowed.

Comments are closed.