‘May 15, 2015 Is The Date Everything Changed’


From top: Sgt Maurice McCabe; former Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan and former Minister for Justice Frances Fitzgerald; Labour TD Alan Kelly

You may recall a post from Friday, entitled The Legal Strategy Against Maurice McCabe.

It centred on questions put to the Department of Justice, by Labour TD Alan Kelly, in relation to what knowledge, if any, the department had about the legal strategy employed by An Garda Siochana at the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation in 2015.

Readers will recall how at the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation – which was set up to examine complaints of Garda malpractice made by Sgt McCabe – legal counsel for former Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan said it would argue that Sgt McCabe made his complaints because of a grudge and that evidence of this would be based on a particular meeting Sgt McCabe had with two other gardai.

This line of argument was dropped after Sgt McCabe produced a recording of the meeting which proved this was untrue.

Mr Kelly has written to the Department of Justice asking what knowledge the former Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald had of this legal strategy.

He’s also written to the Ceann Comhairle Seán Ó Fearghaíl, the now Justice Minister Charlie Flanagan and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar about the same.

He’s now calling for Mr Varadkar to make a public statement on the matter.

He also said he believes that, if the Department of Justice was aware, then the terms of reference for the Disclosures Tribunal – which is being overseen by Supreme Court judge Peter Charleton and is examining allegations of a smear campaign against Sgt McCabe – need to be widened to include the department.

Further to this…

Mr Kelly spoke to Sean O’Rourke on RTE Radio One this morning in which he reiterated his questions.

From the interview…

Sean O’Rourke:You lay particular emphasis on contacts between the Commissioner’s office and the office of the Secretary General of the Department of Justice on the 15th of May 2015. Why is that date important?

Alan Kelly:It’s very important because this is the day that everything changed in relation to O’Higgins and that Maurice McCabe became aware of a different strategy as regards the Commissioner and their legal strategy to him. And, in relation to the whole aspect of whether he had had motives, different motives…”

O’Rourke: “Yeah, a grudge.”

Kelly: “An agenda or had a grudge in relation certain aspects of the gardai and that’s why he acted in the way in which he did. It was proven to be false…”


Kelly:If they [Department of Justice] come out and say ‘no, they weren’t aware in any way, shape or form, this dies. Because it’s effectively saying look no they weren’t privy to anything. The issue is this: in the questions and answers that I’ve got back from Minister Flanagan, he doesn’t deny that there were meetings. He doesn’t deny that there was something going on.”

Readers may wish to note that, although it hasn’t been mentioned on RTE, Broadsheet previously reported how, at the outset of the O’Higgins Commission, the legal counsel for Ms O’Sullivan argued that the reason for this so-called grudge was that Sgt McCabe wanted the directions made by the DPP in 2007 – in respect of a “dry humping” allegation made by the daughter, Ms D, of a guard previously disciplined by Sgt McCabe in 2006 – overturned.

But the DPP’s directions were categorically in Sgt McCabe’s favour.

And what the gardai didn’t know, going into the commission, was that Sgt McCabe had been fully briefed of the DPP’s directions back in 2007 when they were first issued.

These were the DPP’s directions:

Dear Sir,

I acknowledge receipt of your letter dated 1st March 2007 together with copy Garda investigation file.

I agree with you and the Guards, that the evidence does not warrant a prosecution. There was no admission. The incident as described by the injured party is vague. It appears that it was only when she was eleven/twelve that she decided that whatever occurred was sexual in nature.

Even if there wasn’t a doubt over her credibility, the incident that she describes does not constitute a sexual assault or indeed an assault.

Further, the account given to her cousin [redacted] differs in a number of respects to that given to her parents and the Guards.

There is no basis for a prosecution.

And the date Sgt McCabe informed the O’Higgins Commission that he was fully aware of the DPP’s directions, knew they were strongly in his favour and, therefore, had no desire for them to be overturned?

May 15, 2015.

(Readers should note the ‘humping’ allegation mentioned above was revived in 2013 when Ms D went to a counsellor and the counsellor sent a botched referral outlining a much more serious allegation of rape to Tusla.

This botched referral would eventually reach Ms O’Sullivan’s office in May 2014 and the false allegation against Sgt McCabe remained on file in the Commissioner’s office until the Disclosures Tribunal began earlier this year).

Previously: Absence Of Malice

Listen back to Today with Sean O’Rourke in full here

Related: McCabe smear: Fitzgerald refuses to clarify what she knew of planned campaign (Juno McEnroe, Irish Examiner)

15 thoughts on “‘May 15, 2015 Is The Date Everything Changed’

    1. LW

      Don’t be fooled again. Although to be fair, he’s impressing with this. Is it a poor reflection on the rest that this basic level of competence shines so bright?

      1. snowey

        i was only going to comment the same..
        is this matter redemption for ak-47?

        I really disliked him before but he playing a blinder here

  1. bisted

    …could Alan not have asked Frances himself when they were sitting beside eachother at the cabinet table…all these things happened before labour got dumped at the last election…

  2. Increasing_Displacement

    This is so drawn out and as a result painful to follow despite interest

    I presume this is the plan?

  3. RuilleBuille

    It’s as plain as the nose on your face FitzGerald knew about this. She is so evasive about answering questions on this matter.

  4. Catherinecostelloe

    Frances Fitzgerald stated on This week in Politics that the first she knew of Maurice raping a child was the Primetime programme a few days before. Katherine Zappone contradicted her. Jim o Callaghan visited Fitzgerald the day before Primetime, to alert her to the fact the programme was going out the following day and to ensure the terms of reference included Tulsa in Charleston Tribunal. Did you not think Ms Fitzgerald that
    the creation of a false file labelling a man as a paedophile is the lowest of the low? Your very actions and false utterances does a great disservise to a Justice Dept. You should step aside. Its the right thing to do.

  5. Catherinecostelloe

    British MP’s imprisoned since 2011.
    Denis Mc Shane, 3 months fiddling expenses
    Elliot Morley, 16 months fiddling expenses
    Jim Devine, , 16 months fiddling expenses
    Lord Hanningfield, 9 months fiddling expenses
    David Chaytor, 18 months fiddling expenses
    Eric Illeley, 12 months , getting wife to take penalty points?
    Lord Taylor , 12 months fiddling expenses.
    The law is seen to apply without fear or favour. This is why the law is totally disrespected in Ireland by elected TD’s. No accountability, no transparency , no fairness to like of Maurice Mc Cabe . We are lucky the poor man didn’t take his life. Shame on every single TD that doesn’t seek accountability in yet another dark chapter in Justice Dept. Yellow bellies.

  6. JoneyL

    Frances Fitzgerald should be ashamed of herself…what has happened to Maurice Mccabe is horrendous. ..you couldn’t write it! you can be sure Leo knows all about the dirty tricks and lies.

Comments are closed.