Not The First Time


Fire-damaged Caiseal Mara Hotel on Foyle Street in Moville, Co Donegal


Gardai launched an investigation into an arson attack at a Donegal hotel which was due to be used as a direct provision centre for 100 asylum seekers in the coming days.

The fire happened at the Caiseal Mara Hotel on Foyle Street in Moville at around 4.30am on Sunday morning – hours before Fáilte Inishowen was to hold a public information meeting at the Methodist Hall in the town.

It’s been reported one man, in his 50s, was injured in the fire and he was taken to Letterkenny Hospital for treatment.

This isn’t the first time such a fire took place at a hotel earmarked for a direct provision centre.

In April 2000, there was an arson attack at the Vee Valley Hotel in Clogheen, Co Tipperary which was scheduled to start accommodating 30 to 40 asylum seekers at the time.

Following the fire, it was reported in The Irish Times that Clogheen’s residents, at a public meeting of about 400, voted to hold a picket outside the hotel and to negotiate for just 10 asylum seekers to be allowed stay in the hotel.

Three years later, the trial of a man charged over the fire in Clogheen collapsed.

At the time, the Irish Independent reported:

“The trial of a painter who allegedly threatened to burn down a hotel where it was planned asylum seekers would be housed, and hang the previous owners of the building, collapsed yesterday at Clonmel Circuit Criminal Court.

Noel Grey (45), single, who lives in a caravan in Clogheen village, Co Tipperary had pleaded not guilty to three counts of arson and damaging property on April 25, 2000.

A total of €33,000 worth of damage had been done to the Vee Valley Hotel, Clogheen, Co Tipperary.

The court heard that Mr Grey had threatened to burn the hotel and had been protesting outside as he was opposed to it housing asylum seekers.

However, the two-day trial collapsed following 90 minutes of legal argument regarding the non-availability of certain exhibits.

Judge Yvonne Murphy discharged the jury. A re-trial is not expected.”


The Fáilte Inishowen meeting at the Methodist Hall went ahead yesterday with hundreds reportedly in attendance.

Fáilte Inishowen writes:

“We in Fáilte Inishowen and Inishowen Together awoke yesterday to dark, alarming news of the arson attack on the Caiseal Mara hotel in Moville.

“A family were in there, in their beds – perhaps whoever sent fire through the windows did not think of that.

“Whatever it was that the perpetrator or perpetrators thought they were achieving, they have failed. A hateful and cowardly act, done alone in the dark was resoundingly answered in much brighter hours that followed in Moville, by the hundreds of people who gathered at our community meeting to affirm our support, solidarity and welcome for the asylum seekers who will be arriving in the town in the coming weeks.

“The meeting, which packed out the Methodist Hall, sought to illuminate the realities of the Direct Provision system and to offer ideas and advice on how the community can prepare in order to do our best by the new Moville residents. Its key speakers – who very kindly travelled from Dublin to be with us – were activist Lucky Khambule of the Movement of Asylum Seekers in Ireland, and artist and researcher Vukasin Nedeljkovic of Asylum Archive.

“Lucky and Vukasin also gave great examples of the effectiveness of simple kindness that they have encountered.

“Both Lucky and Vukasin have experienced what it is to have “your life placed on hold” as an asylum seeker in Direct Provision in Ireland. Having heard their insights into the dismal system by which our State fails to offer a genuine welcome or real home to people escaping dire circumstances, we can see that having open hearts is not enough. We will also need watchful eyes to hold the Government to account. We need to ensure the best provision, while appealing for an end to Direct Provision and the introduction of an immediate right to work without restriction

“Contributions also came from local clergy – Methodist reverend Alison Gallagher and Catholic priest Fr Pat O’Hagan PP – who presented a united stand of the town’s religious communities in solidarity with the refugees, and pledged their time, space and help.

“Several gardai attended, and Sergeant Goretti Sheridan spoke at the outset to assure the people of Moville that the force was doing its level best to get to the bottom of the incident of arson that had taken place in the early hours.

“Speakers from Fáilte Inishowen and Inishowen Together included Tracy Cullen-Sheehan, Caroline Maguire; Siobhán Shiels and Therese McKenna.

“Many people throughout the room stood to speak about how they would like their organisations to contribute to welcoming the asylum seekers to Moville.

“These included the local librarian, the town’s educators from pre-school to secondary level, the Inishowen Development Partnership, the Moville and District Family Resource Centre, Moville Men’s Shed, mental health advocates, among many others.

“Politicians and activists in attendance who vouched their warm support included Thomas Pringle TD; civil rights campaigners Eamon McCann and Goretti Horgan; and local councillor Martin Farren.

“A significant number of supporters had travelled from Derry – with organisations such as Derry Well Woman committing their input and expertise; and Eamon McCann noting, amid Brexit talks, the sad fact that there is already a hard border for refugees in Ireland and that those arriving in Moville may not visit or even travel through the North.

“At the end of the meeting, more than 50 people queued to give their contact details and volunteer their time and individual talents to help in welcoming the new residents to Moville.

“The strength of feeling and warmth in the room was incredible. The atmosphere was respectful and hopeful.

“The dark and alarming act that happened hours before has galvanised the community of Moville to show what we are really made of; that this is a beautiful town of compassion and openness.”

Anyone who wishes to get involved in Failte Inishowen can email

Previously: A Warm Welcome

Pic: Greg Hughes

Sponsored Link

8 thoughts on “Not The First Time

      1. Rep

        I wonder will her more recent twitter posts be the final nail to BS support for her.

        She has said similarish things before and has still appeared on da BS telly but she really has seemed to jump off the deep end at the moment.

    1. Rob_G

      There were also tens of thousands of other people in Donegal that weekend; I don’t think that that your correlation does anything to prove causation.

      On another note, I am surprised that the far-right would associate themselves with a very camp gay man, but it takes all sorts, I suppose.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link