Meanwhile, Outside (And Inside) Leinster House


This afternoon.

Members and supporters of the Mental Health Warriors demonstrated outside the gates of Leinster House.

The group, which is calling for 24/7 mental health services and more funding for mental health services, included Fiona Twomey (red coat) whose 11-year-old daughter Milly from Templeogue, Dublin, took her life in 2016.

Kathy Maguire (third picture), from Newbridge, Co Kildare, also took part in the protest.

Kathy’s daughter Maxine, aged 25, died by suicide in February 2017.


Taoiseach Leo Varadkar; Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald

Earlier today, during Leaders’ Questions, Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald told Taoiseach Leo Varadkar that the protest would be taking place today.

She also recalled the death, by suicide of Grainne Gault’s daughter Elisha on St Patrick’s Day last year, and told him Grainne would be taking part in the protest.

Ms McDonald told Mr Varadkar that, over the past two years, 744 people in Ireland died by suicide.

She added:

“The Government’s failure is most evident in the child and adolescent mental health service, CAMHS, which is on its knees.

“It is crumbling while families and communities cry out for help, which the Government is not providing. Staffing shortages have led to CAMHS beds lying empty and children waiting months for mental healthcare.

“In August, 2,440 children were waiting for mental health services. Half of those children were waiting at least 12 weeks to be seen, while 748 were waiting six months. That is far too long to wait when a young person’s health, and possibly life, hangs in the balance.”

In his response, Mr Varadkar told Ms McDonald:

“Since 2012, the budget for mental health services has increased by 44%.

“I doubt one could find such a large increase in mental health funding in any seven-year period in Irish history.

An additional €40 million for mental health was announced in the budget last week, which brings the mental health budget to over €1billion for the first time.”

He added:

“The Deputy will be aware that the rate of suicide in Ireland has fallen by about 30% in recent years.

“Of course, any suicide is one too many, but we all welcome the fact that suicide rates in Ireland are dropping. It also reminds us that there is more to do.

“The Minister of State, Deputy Jim Daly, who has responsibility for mental health, informed me last week that the CAMHS waiting list is down 25% and still falling.

“That is a very positive development, on which we need to build. We have also invested in improving psychological services in primary care, by hiring an additional 114 assistant psychologists, for example.”

The Taoiseach added that, last week, a 24-hour mental health helpline was established for the first time.

He said:

“People often do not know how to access the 1,000 or so different mental health services out of hours, whether in the evening, at nighttime or on weekends. That helpline, which is based in the National Ambulance Service, is making a real difference.”

Ms McDonald, during her response, said:

“The death of Elisha Gault, the child I mentioned, was not captured in the official statistics.

“She is not officially recorded as a death by suicide. Instead of claiming – I believe erroneously – that deaths by suicide are falling, the Taoiseach would be better served by looking at those real live statistics and understanding that they do not represent the full picture.

“The Taoiseach rattled off figures to me, citing a figure of €40 million. However, only €14 million of that is new money. That is a fact.”

Transcript via

Leah Farrell/Rollingnews and Mental Health Warriors (second pic)

Sponsored Link

6 thoughts on “Meanwhile, Outside (And Inside) Leinster House

  1. Lilly

    RIP sweet Millie Twomey, only 11 years of age. Here’s one thing I don’t understand though. ‘She died waiting’ but why were a middle-class family prepared to wait? People are always bemoaning the two-tiered health system in Ireland but in a crisis, you go private. You find a good psychiatrist and pay. You don’t put your name on a list and wait. Is this not a given?

    1. f_lawless

      Eh, didn’t you read the linked-to article? They did initially try to go private but the psychologist was unavailable. Under advice from another therapist who saw the child, they made an appointment with the HSE’s Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services. “In their statement, the family said they discovered there are no clinical protocols for when a child has a mental health crisis.’In 21st-century Ireland this is simply not acceptable.’ ”

      Anyway your comment smacks of an “I’m all right Jack” mindset. Don’t the people who can’t afford to go private come into your consideration? Are those the very people who are justified in bemoaning the two-tiered health system?

      1. Lilly

        It’s probably too late to go into this and yes, I read the article. If one psychologist is no longer taking patients, i’d have thought it’s not too difficult to find another. And of course the people who can’t afford to go private come into my consideration, but my question wasn’t about them. It specifically addressed ‘she died waiting’.

          1. Lilly

            Yes, I know. I’m not condoning the health set up but I don’t understand why someone in a crisis situation wouldn’t work with it until the crisis had passed. A lot of people have no choice and have to wait, but in extreme circumstances, no one would hold it against anyone who decided to hell with the waiting list.

  2. Joe Small

    Interesting comment from SF about Grainne Gault’s daughter saying she died by suicide butt isn’t recorded as a suicide. Coroner’s courts tend to be very reluctant to classify a death as suicide unless the case is ironclad. If there is the slightest doubt, its classified as death by misadventure.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link