https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ed2Qlxcoj60
Jailhouse rock dance at Central Bank – #FreeThe5 #irishwater #PoliticalPolicing pic.twitter.com/3SMc66dEcA
— Michael Caul (@caulmick) February 21, 2015
Scenes from today’s protest in Dublin against the imprisonment of five Irish Water protesters for contempt of court earlier this week.
The demonstrators gathered outside the Central Bank on Dame Street before they marched to Mountjoy Prison where several speeches were made – including one by Anti-Austerity Alliance TD Paul Murphy.
Those gathered were told that two jailed protesters – Derek Byrne and Paul Moore – have been refusing food since yesterday.
The Irish Times reported the number of people outside Mountjoy amounted to ‘up to 10,000’, while RTE reported the figure to be ‘over 5,000’.
Meanwhile, in Castlebar, Co. Mayo – where the Fine Gael National Conference is being held – a similar protest took place…
Jailed anti-water protesters go on hunger strike, crowd hears (Kitty Holland, Irish Times)
Over 5,000 take part in demonstrations against jailed protesters (RTE)
Pics: Sam Boal/Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland
Videos: Mark Malone and Tír na Saor













Is Centra an official sponsor of the “Edenmore Says No” group?
Did none of the 5 have any work to go to that day of the protest????
On hunger strike?
Hahahahahahahahaha fuppoff.
Probably needs to lose a bit of weight
Is that an official fine gael statement?
‘The Five’?
Spare me.
It’s short for ‘the five that were sentenced to serve time in Mountjoy Prison’. Because, you know, there were five of them.
Ah I see…just like the Guilford Four and Birmingham Six
Kind of, I guess. All those groups are named because of the number that they consist of, but the Birmingham Six and the Guildford Four included references to the towns that they were associated with. In this case, the five are just referred to as ‘the five’ as, I would assume, reference to ‘Dublin’ would be somewhat redundant.
There is also the intention to link ‘the five’ to said other numerically associated groups based on the link to a perceived injustice in the Courts’ system.
Did 5 make them get down?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qZUn-KtTNmA
I think the plight of The Five has indeed got Eliot down.
Cylons
The idea that Ireland could have a thoughtful debate about the need for water conservation and investment in infrastructure seems like a distant fantasy now. The opportunity has been wasted and we’re left with stubborn toddler tantrums on both sides.
You can thank the arrogance and incompetence of “consultants” in Irish Water for that …that is, namely Elizabeth Arnett Head of Communications at IW for the fiasco
+1 billion and counting..
Can I Clampers? Or might this debacle be more nuanced and less black and white as everyone seems to be making it out? But thanks for telling me where to direct my ire. I love a blame game.
Are “the Five 5” different to “the 5”?
Well, apparently one of them is in Lanzarote, so, maybe The Freeloadin’ Four?
Or Z the z-idiot?
I like the way the light cover on that Mountjoy Prison sign creates such a shadow that the light should be on all the time.
In fairness, it seems a bit disproportionate that someone would go on hunger strike over being jailed for a few weeks. I get it that its the principle that counts but I don’t think I get that either. They were ordered not to go near the guys installing the water meters. They did, presumably knowingly. They were jailed for it.
Any efforts to tie this to some sort of conspiracy theory of political policing, bankers not being jailed, and the like, seem a bit far fetched to, and appear to require more of a leap of faith than a reading of the facts.
Most people are seeing turning against these protesters and their childish tactics. Their complete lack of regard for democracy and calls to violence is worrying. .
@ Banotti
Are you alleging that the anti-water charge demonstrators are calling for violence?
Provide proof of this claim or it fails.
Don’t be disingenuous Zuppy, comments are being made within the context of the article, not the protesters in general.
I’m not the one making disingenuous and false claims against peaceful protestors.
Absolutely. Head over the facebook pages of XXX says no, The Hub and a million other. Read the comments. Calling for attacks on politicians, media figures and Irish water staff.
Here’s one from earlier. JB wins another battle.
http://imgur.com/OcBBa2z
Thin. Very thin. Do you work for GuardEx by any chance?
Democracy? Where?
Ireland. Do I need to explain the concept of democracy to you?
Except for the thousands protesting that is
In other countries, it might be called a conspiracy but in Ireland it’s public policy…
And FG/Lab are damn proud of it.
Well, they’re escalating, they’d be a bit dim not to spin it to maximise the outrage and injustice. The point is not to be outraged at the injustice of them being jailed, but that in order to object to a stupid, wasteful policy by our political overlords one has to push it to the point of going to jail. I think Irish people will largely refuse to make the connection between political dysfunction and protestor intransigence because it’s all a bit too real and on the nose. It’s embarrassing. We repress it the way we repress unwelcome emotions. There’s no conspiracy. The money is gone and will continue to go. That is fixed. The height of austerity, and all that money gone. The structures are in place. The contracts for the sinecures have been signed and are legally binding. When you look at what that says about the way you are governed you can either repress your anger or do something about it. The more you do the less support you receive because embarrassment and shame, old Catholic bugaboos, compete with the anger and if the shame and embarrassment win, then the anger is repressed. Shame and anger will defeat effective protest more surely than batons and tear gas. That’s what the government has going for them. No matter how revolted we are by them, it’s nothing compared to the prospect of the sheer embarrassment of supporting The Five.
There is no embarrassment in supporting people wrongfully imprisoned for not breaking any law.
The embarrassment is in those who support a corrupt and venial system that imprisons non-criminals because they are too effective at frustrating the scam that is Irish Wasters.
The conspiracy to defraud is relentless and ongoing:
http://directdemocracyireland.ie/questions-need-answering-water-meter-purchase-contract-procurement/
Ah so you were against Sean Quinn being imprisoned.
Take your Strawman elsewhere.
You underestimate middle-class propriety and fear of change.
You may be overestimating the power of the Class-bait gambit within the strategy of divide and conquer.
http://www.fairsociety.ie/why-the-governments-propagandised-attempts-to-divide-of-water-protests-are-failing/
They broke a court order and this is the penalty. They knew the outcomes of their actions. Anyway, im sure they are happy to be in there visiting other family members and getting 3 square meals a day.
Comment of the week
That Jailhouse rock dance is weirdest thing I’ve seen in months.
It’s absolutely inspired
Not in my name. What a bunch of ar**holes.
It’s the ‘Lanzarote One’ I’m concerned about.
Why?
Id have to think any Irish man that can go off food for a week, believes in something. Its a type of protest Im more inclined to take notice of.
Or, it could just be his Lenten Resolution?
I think the hunger strike guy is Derek. I think he wears a hat saying ‘Je Suis Derek’; his intoxicating self-awareness will see him right.
I.R.S.P. hunger strike for me!
Ooooooooh, sock it to me, sock it to me, sock it to me, sock it to me IRSP hunger strike for me!
Amazing that the imprisoned protesters are being so ridiculed on here when between 4-10,000 (depending on whose estimates you believe) turned up without very much notice for a protest march yesterday. As for the hilarity surrounding the hunger strike, that may soon change, when’s the last time any commenter here didn’t eat for 72 hours, which is what these men are up to this evening.
No word from Irish Water about registrations since the fiasco of the undeadline at the start of February. Do they have more than 50% of those who’ll be required to pay yet? Maybe, but I doubt it, they’d be shouting it from the rooftops if they did.
Government seems to think that just because the protests a fortnight ago were smaller than in November, they have gotten Irish Water over the line. Let’s wait for 21st March.
This. You may disagree with them but they clearly have support
Broadshytees, lend me a hand…please.
I want to e-mail Paul Murphy a question*, but I’m not on Facebook. His e-mail address is not listed amongst the rest of the embarassment of ‘representatives’ in Teachta Dail. I’ve looked on-line and keep ending up at Facebook. I need your help.
A direct e-mail address would be very much appreciated.
*Totally NOT related to Water Charges. I need to know his standpoint on a totally different issue, and reassure myself that my vote goes where I want it to go.