Facing Down



From top: Garda Keith Harrison; Garda Commissioner Nóirín O’Sullivan

You may recall Garda whistleblower Keith Harrison whose allegations will be looked at as part of the Charleton Inquiry.

He’s been on sick leave from Donegal Town Garda Station since May 2014.

He was on partial pay (33%) from May 2014 until September 2015 but has not received any pay from An Garda Siochana since September 2015.

Garda Harrison is going back to work on Monday, following mediation talks this week which were chaired by the former head of the Workplace Relations Commission Kieran Mulvey.

The mediation talks, which focussed on returning to work and the payment of arrears, followed a report on RTÉ’s This Week last weekend concerning Garda Harrison.

The report effectively explained how, in late January of this year, Garda Harrison was ordered to return to work in Donegal Town Garda Station – despite a series of Garda-commissioned medical assessments recommending that Garda Harrison not be returned to the station where he had previously worked.

Some more details about these reports:

In September 2014, Garda Keith Harrison met Dr Oghenovo Oghuvbu, who was a specialist occupational physician with the Garda Occupational Health Department at the time.

On October 6, 2014, Dr Oghuvbu wrote a report to the Executive Director Human Resources and People Development at An Garda Síochána John Barrett, about Garda’s Harrison.

In his report, Dr Oghuvby stated that he believed Garda Harrison’s illness could have been born out of a work-related environment and that he would be fit to return to work, on the basis that a safe work environment would be provided for him.

He wrote:

“[Garda Harrison] continues to experience some impairment in his sense of well-being. This is particularly in respect of his returning to his current workplace (Donegal division) while the investigation is ongoing. This is also of concern to his treating clinical physicians.”

Dr Oghuvbu also required an “urgent case conference” in relation to Garda Harrison’s return to work that would encompass local Garda management, staff from Garda human resources and the Chief Medical Officer.

It’s understood this case conference did not take place and it’s unclear how Garda management actually responded to Dr Oghuvbu’s call for an “urgent case conference”.

In November 2016, the Garda’s Assistant Chief Medical Officer Dr Richard Quigley met with Garda Harrison.

Dr Quigley carried out a more in-depth assessment of Garda Harrison and determined that Garda Harrison should return to work and that his issues or illnesses were related to the work environment.

Specifically, Dr Quigley wrote to Garda human resources, stating:

“Given work circumstances, which are well known to management, I consider it prudent if consideration is given to Garda Harrison being assigned to duties in a station other than his previous location.

In addition, Dr Quigley recommended that Garda Harrison be seen by an independent specialist.

In turn, the Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan commissioned a report from Dr Patrick Devitt, a Dublin-based consultant psychiatrist.

In January, 2017, as the commissioned independent specialist, Dr Devitt stated that Garda Harrison’s injuries were born out of his workplace environment and that he firmly agreed with Dr Quigley’s recommendation for Garda Harrison to return to work.

But it was also stipulated that Garda Harrison should not be returned to the station he previously worked in.

Garda Harrison only obtained details of these three reports, and their findings, last Friday – days before the This Week report and the mediation talks earlier this week.

Had Garda Harrison and his legal team not had sight of these reports – in which the Garda’s own medical assessments state his illness was work-related and that it was recommended he be placed somewhere other than Donegal Town – it may have been difficult for him to argue for a placement other than Donegal Town station.

If An Garda Siochana insisted that he still had to go to Donegal Town station, this would have contradicted the advice given to them by their own medical assessments.

It should also be noted that Garda Harrison and his team continuously looked for these reports since 2014 but didn’t get anywhere with their requests.

At the mediation talks, during which the chief superintendent involved sat in another room, Garda Harrison did eventually get permission to go to a station other than Donegal Town station.

However, on the matter of pay, and getting paid in arrears for the time he’s been on sick leave, An Garda Siochana did not budge – despite their own reports stating he was out because of work-related issues.


Garda Harrison’s legal team was told by mediator Kieran Mulvey that Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan will “face down” any complaints and had the support of every garda in the Donegal division.

A Garda press officer said the force does not comment on “remarks by other parties” but denied the Commissioner had ever made such a statement.

Previously: A Breathtaking Timeline

Listen to the This Week report in full here

Rollingnews, Irish Mirror

Sponsored Link

18 thoughts on “Facing Down

  1. Panty Christ

    Noirin leaves Arlene foster in the ha’penny place when it comes to being an absolute hatchet wagon

  2. newsjustin

    I wonder why the views of other Gardai on paying him arrears matter.

    I suppose the message must be put out, despite the nice talk of reform for the media and the public, that “If you rock the boat for us, we will focking ruin you.” It’s important for all Gardai to learn that – for the good of the force and the citizenry.

  3. Daisy Chainsaw

    They have an anonymous tip line on Crimecall and encourage people to come forward with information when crimes have been comitted; ie they rely on people “ratting out” wrongdoers. Do it “in house” and AGS will fupp you over bigtime.

    O’Sullivan has to go, plain and simple. She’s a vindictive bully towards decent people shining a light into the dark corners of garda corruption. People like Harrison and McCabe deserve to be lauded and rewarded, not put through the ringer and made to suffer both emotionally and financially.

    1. ahjayzis

      We should all call Garda Confidential line and report O’Sullivan and her whole wretched cabal of endangering state security by being petty, vindictive bullies running a protection racket.

  4. Lord Snowflakee

    There are official fora available to disgruntled employees for settlement of HR disputes.
    Broadsheet is not one of them.

  5. Ron

    Keith is a very good friend of mine and the full extent of what they have done to him is both mind boggling and disgusting. I sincerely hope he gets justice

    1. Daisy Chainsaw

      Please tell him on behalf of someone who has gardai on both sides of the family (3 generations on one side) that, for what it’s worth, I applaud and support him 100% and wish him well.

  6. Joe Small

    I notice these things are never as straightforward as they seem. I don’t know the first thing about Garda Harrison but I did work with someone in the public service who became a whistleblower and was lauded in the press. It was quite strange because she was barking mad and had no place in paid employment. Not one word of her bizarre behavior in the workplace ever leaked out though and some TDs called her a hero. It was surreal.

    1. Joxer

      But Joe ….was she telling the truth? Was there substance to her whistleblowing? not sure why her being barking mad would make a difference if what she was speaking was the truth.

      1. Joe Small

        Most of what she said was nonsense, reflecting her mental state. But people wanted to believe it. It fit the prevailing narrative. Sorry about the delay in replying – Broadsheet are moderating my comments now for some reason.

        1. Kieran Nice Young Chap

          Probably in case you name the person and leave Broadsheet open to lawsuits

    2. ahjayzis

      Joe I don’t know you at all at all, but I did know someone, let’s call him Moe, who was very consistent in throwing mud at whistleblowers with vague assertions and the like, and well I suppose my point is Moe beat his wife and was awful to his mother. Just thought I’d talk about Moe for no reason x

    3. Ron

      I know him quite well. I can tell you that the Commissioner and garda management are evil evil filthy scumbaggggs

  7. Romeo C

    I have it from a source very close….An Garda Siochana have refused to pay him what they are lawfully obliged to do despite reports by the Commissioners own doctors…..and more disturbingly the commissioner has the full support of his peers

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link