‘If We Do Not Measure, We Cannot Improve’

at

Independent TD Catherine Connolly and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar

Yesterday.

During Leaders’ Questions.

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar, by way of justifying setting up his €5million Strategic Communications Unit, said:

“The thinking behind the unit is very simple, one I hope most Members of the House will understand, namely, that if we do not measure, we cannot improve. If we want to improve something, we have to be able to measure it.”

Further to this…

Independent TD for Galway West Catherine Connolly asked Mr Varadkar if the Government will fund another Sexual Abuse and Violence in Ireland (SAVI) report – following on from the first, and only, such study in 2002.

They had this exchange:

Catherine Connolly: “Almost four months ago to the day, I used my time during Leaders’ Questions to raise the very serious issue of domestic violence. More specifically, I raised the failure of the Government to provide funding of approximately €1 million to review the groundbreaking study that was carried out in 2002, indicating over 3,000 victims of violence generally.

“This confirmed the extraordinary prevalence of violence in Irish society. Since then, the Taoiseach has presided over a budget that utterly failed and fails to grasp the seriousness of the issue or make any provision to deal with the extent of domestic violence and its pervasive and detrimental effect not only on women and children but also on society at every level.

Simultaneously, the Taoiseach has provided €5 million for a strategic communications unit. He did so notwithstanding the urgent representations from SAFE Ireland, which represents over 30 organisations on the ground that are more than familiar with the catastrophe owing to violence generally, particularly domestic violence.

“It pointed out that 4,831 requests for a safe place or refuge – a massive number – were refused last year. It pointed out that we are dealing with the tip of the iceberg, and that 79% of women do not report abuse.”

Leo Varadkar:With regard to whether we will spend another €1 million commissioning another report, or another statistical or academic study, on domestic violence is a matter that will have to be considered by Ministers.

“Departments up to this date have said they are satisfied with the statistics and information they have. Rather than spending €1 million on another study or statistical report, they would prefer to spend it on other things, such as services or additional shelters and housing. It is, however, a matter on which I absolutely have an open mind.

If the people within the Departments believe expenditure on an academic analysis or statistical report should be prioritised over alternatives, I will be happy to consider it.”

However.

This morning.

In The Times Ireland edition.

After getting documentation under the Freedom of Information Act, Ellen Coyne reported:

Plans for a study to establish the scale of sexual violence in Ireland have been scrapped by the government, The Times can reveal.

The move means that victims of rape and domestic abuse will not be counted unless they report their crime to the gardaí or are recorded by a charity.

Charlie Flanagan, the justice minister, has reneged on a commitment by Frances Fitzgerald, the tánaiste and his predecessor, to fund the study.

… The department had previously said that such data would be supplemented by the Savi report, but a source confirmed last night that those plans had been scrapped.

… Documents obtained by The Times under freedom of information laws show that Regina Doherty, the social protection minister, wrote to three cabinet colleagues in May pleading with them to fund the research. Katherine Zappone, the children and youth affairs minister, Frances Fitzgerald, then the justice minister, and Simon Harris, the health minister, all said they supported the study but could not afford it.”

Further to this.

This afternoon…

The Rape Crisis Network Ireland has released a statement saying:

The Rape Crisis Network of Ireland (RCNI) has announced today that it will not be publishing statistics on the experience of survivors of sexual violence relating to 2016.

The decision was made on foot of significant cuts to RCNI’s funding, which have resulted in a diminution of the network’s capacity to safely analyse and publish data on sexual violence.

“Since 2005, RCNI has produced national statistics recording the collective experiences of up to 93% of survivors of sexual violence that use Rape Crisis Centres (RCCs) around the country.

“This powerful tool has been supporting survivors to becoming agents of change as they form part of an evidence base that has transformed policy and practice.”

Study to help rape victims ‘is unnecessary’ (The Times Ireland edition)

Dail transcript via Oireachtas.ie

12 thoughts on “‘If We Do Not Measure, We Cannot Improve’

  1. Daisy Chainsaw

    A portion of the budget for Leo’s Dept of Propaganda & Spin would provide sufficient funding, but Leo has his priorities… and that’s all that matters.

  2. GiggidyGoo

    Unfortunately this is the Fine Gael way. It’s a ‘kick them when they’re down’ mentality. Always has been. For all the failings of FF, at least they had some sort of semblance of duty of care now and again. FG – well you only have to look at Noonan and Hogan, and now Varadker to see what’s up.

    1. Boj

      Is it still just old rich people who keep voting them in? I know not 1 ‘out & proud’ FG voter! (but I’ve no friends)
      I’ve noticed over the last 20 years that Ireland has become a lot more greedy, it doesn’t seem to be classed as a negative trait anymore, encouraged almost, but that’s just my own perception I suppose.

  3. b

    by the end of this week we’ll have 200mln worth of spending that could have been paid for by the communications unit

  4. nellyb

    Have the ministers tried crowdfunding among non-domiciles?
    100K per person – we’ll have a million in a blink, and it won’t make a dent in their pockets, returns have been legendary. FF and FG could set up a tent in the airport on arrivals to meet and greet our exiles: Welcoming {most expensive} beverage du jour, appeal to {decency, christian morals, whatever} and a compliment on a great tan. Hopefully it ends with ‘here is your receipt, mam/sir, nation is forever indebted to you, god bless’
    Seriously though, it’s time to push for philanthropy. “Make Philanthropy Great Again”. Or at least fashionable. We’ve run out of other options.

  5. Donal

    if we do not measure it must not exist and we can save loads more money as there will be no need to fund it, whatever it is…

  6. Truth in the News

    Varadakar used to trot out in the media every Sunday on RTE when her held Ministerial
    Office, and what exactly did he achieve either in Transport or Health….nothing, the establishment of Centralised Spin or Propaganda Outfit is to mask that he is even worse
    at being head of Goverment, and I doubt if he settles for a 30 Euro Bottle of plonk either
    he’s bit more upmarket in tastes, come to think of, is Adams a teetotaler anyays

Comments are closed.