‘A Time To Be Disruptive’


At the weekend in Ballybunion, Co Kerry.

The annual Women In Media event was held at Kilcooly’s Country House Hotel.

On Saturday, there was a panel discussion about homelessness involving journalist and political correspondent Justine McCarthy, of The Sunday Times; Fr Peter McVerry, of The Peter McVerry Trust; Junior Minister for Housing and Fine Gael TD Damien English; and Labour TD Jan O’Sullivan.

The discussion was chaired by Mary Dundon, Head of Journalism at the University of Limerick.

During the discussion, Ms McCarthy pointed out that when Opposition TDs raise homelessness in the Dáil and ask the Government to stop providing tax incentives to developers and land owners, Government ministers or TDs usually respond by way of one of three defences.

She said they either say the Government is doing a “great job” but the problem is just getting worse; Government TDs say they don’t have any ideology about homelessness – insinuating that the Opposition does; and they say the Opposition is being “too emotional”.

In regards to the first answer, Ms McCarthy said the homelessness problem has been highly visible on the streets of Dublin since 2011/2012; and as for the claim the Government has no ideology, Ms McCarthy said this is “stark, ravingly untrue”.

As for the claim the Opposition is “too emotional”, Ms McCarthy said:

“If you’re not emotional about homelessness, there’s something deeply wrong with you. Our homes are our sanctuary, they’re where we go for love and shelter and security.

“They’re places that are full of emotion and feeling.

“And the very idea of being without that refuge is horrific.”

She added:

“Mary Robinson says ‘there is a time to be disruptive’ and if we can’t be disruptive about homelessness, if people don’t go out and march and protest and shout – there is no hope for us.

“But I always think, as a journalist, the most reassuring thing in my career has been knowing that the vast major of people are good and the vast majority of people care.

“And we showed that in the last general election, actually. Homelessness was a huge issue on the doorsteps and I think it will be again this time.”

A national protest on homelessness will be taking place in Dublin on Saturday, May 18.


Ms McCarthy congratulates RTÉ’s Political Correspondent for RTÉ Current Affairs Katie Hannon after Ms Hannon was announced as the winner of the Mary Cummins Award for outstanding journalism.

Killarney photographer Valerie O’Sullivan (above middle) received the Joan Kennelly Award and Celine Crawford (above right) won the event’s social influencer award.

Pics: Women in Media Ballybunion (Facebook)

Sponsored Link

6 thoughts on “‘A Time To Be Disruptive’

  1. Specific Gravity

    Justine McCarthy is an outstanding journalist.

    We would be well served by a sizable press pack of her calibre. Too many seem unwilling to upset the applecart for fear of missing out on ministerial special adviser positions down the line.

  2. eoin

    Sarah Carey and Bertie Ahern? More reputation laundering at WIM, but remember producers, what happens in Killarney stays in Killarney and more diverse audiences mightn’t be as understanding. Maybe WIM should get Terry Prone next year.

    1. bisted

      …wikileaks showed us how easily the labour heads could be bought…Gilmore up in the yankee/zionist embassy being debriefed…Mary drawing down the riyals…Ruairi and the cousin on the shekils…sick…

  3. Liam Deliverance

    What did that little ****weasel Damien English have to say about housing/homelessness crisis, did they get Murphys speech writer to spin up a load of garbage for him to spout too.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link