Broadband Plan Critics ‘Like Brexiteers’


Minister for Finance and Junior Finance Minister Patrick O’Donovan

Last night.

On RTÉ’s Drivetime.

Limerick County Fine Gael TD and Junior Finance Minister with special responsibility for Public Procurement, Open Government and eGovernment Patrick O’Donovan spoke to Mary Wilson.

He was on the show to talk about his proposed ‘opt-in’ eGovernment service – called the Digital Postbox – which will allow citizens to receive State correspondence electronically.

But they also discussed the National Broadband Plan – after Ms Wilson asked if there was enough broadband to make this service a reality.

From their discussion:

Patrick O’Donovan: “It’s regrettable and it seems a pity now that we have a kind of alliance building up that’s opposing the delivery of rural broadband…”

Mary Wilson: “I don’t think people are opposing the delivery of rural broadband, minister. They’re raising big questions about Government investment of €3billion which has to be, you know, up front Government investment. And is it €200million from Granahan McCourt?”

O’Donovan: “Well, I’m not going to get into what the specifics are in relation to it.”

Wilson: “Why not? Let’s get into it”

O’Donovan: “Because, as the minister for finance said, Mary, over the weekend and you know this as much as well as I do. There’s a commercial contract negotiations currently under way, the Government have said what are maximum liability is going to be.

“But it’s interesting, you know. While the opposition have given a whole plethora of reasons of why they’re against the roll-out of rural broadband to the people like the 22,000 people in Limerick that need it. They’ve provided no alternative.

“It reminds me a bit of the Brexit-type scenario. Some of the people from the Brexiteers who say ‘alternative technologies’. I mean I heard one person suggesting, you know, that we roll it out to the village. We’ll bring broadband to the village and God is good after that for the people who are living out in the hills around it.”

Wilson: “But at least, at least, at least your colleague, the Minister for Agriculture [Michael Creed] when he was asked a straight question: how much, he answered the question on Clare FM. He was asked ‘how much?’ and he said ‘something shy of €200million’. I’m asking you a straight question.”

O’Donovan: “I’ll give you a straight answer. I’m not a member of the Cabinet, I don’t know. And I don’t know because…”

Wilson: “Should you ask?”

O’Donovan: “No, I’ll tell you why I shouldn’t ask. Because it’s commercially sensitive between the Government which are the 15 members of the Cabinet and the consortium that has been put together to deliver a service that no, remember, no commercial company out there, after having dragged this around for years. No commercial company out there is prepared to deliver broadband to the 22,000-odd people in County Limerick…”

Wilson: “OK. Was Michael Creed, was Michael Creed wrong when he was asked a straight question to answer honestly?”

O’Donovan: “Well I don’t know. To be honest about it. I don’t know because I, what I can tell you, with my hand on my heart, I don’t know the answer to the question that you’re asking. What I do know…”

Wilson: “I know but Michael Creed did and he answered it. Was he wrong to answer it?”

O’Donovan: “Well I’ll tell you – we’re in the middle of commercially sensitive negotiations.”

Wilson: “But the figure is out there now. A man at the Cabinet table has given us the figure.”

O’Donovan: “But no one has, Mary, with the greatest of respect, no one has said that that’s the right figure or the wrong figure. What we know is that the maximum amount that the State’s liability will be, when you take out VAT, is €2.6billion and again, as I say, I have heard no one in the Opposition benches, or no one in the media, or nobody even in the commercial companies that are out there, who could possibly deliver this, saying ‘we could do that for a lot cheaper’.”

Listen back in full here


Thanks Bebe

Sponsored Link

15 thoughts on “Broadband Plan Critics ‘Like Brexiteers’

  1. phil

    How about the ministers agree to forfeit their pension if this BB roll-out ends up in a tribunal ?

  2. Mickey Twopints

    A junior minister with the Open Government portfolio thinks we shouldn’t have insight to the decision to allocate the Billions of taxpayer’s money that his colleagues are spending, because it’s “commercially sensitive between the Government …and the consortium that has been put together to deliver a service”


  3. GiggidyGoo

    Was listening to that yesterday. Another boy sent out to try give the impression of being capable of doing a mans work. Picture above says it all. The boy in training under the watchful eye of the old hand.

    1. axelf

      pascal looks like hell be waiting outside for O’Donovan with a sock full of batteries.

        1. Vanessa (spiritually) Frilly Keane

          We were saying that ourselves at the ILCU AGM there a few weeks ago

          He was the keynote speaker
          Then Big Phil had a turn before they did a Q&A

          I had ta be on me best behaviour
          And usual suspects were still ropey from the night before
          So the two blueshurts got away lighty

          Fierce soft altogether
          You’d swear they’d cut the ribbon at a flower show

          But Phil himself looked in better shape than Pascal

  4. Hector Ramirez

    ‘Minister for…. special responsibility for open government…etc’

    Does not want to go into it..

    Enough said.

  5. realPolithicks

    These lads are so far in over their heads its not even funny, its actually a bit scary. No doubt cian will be on soon to tell you there’s nothing to see here.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link