Tag Archives: Vincent


FionnannnPolitical editor of the Irish Independent Fionnan Sheahan appeared on Vincent Browne, alongside Constantin Gurdgiev, finance lecturer at Trinity College and Ian Kehoe, assistant editor of the Sunday Business Post, last night to speak about the Anglo Tapes.

But first there was some ‘sickening’ bias’ business to deal with.

Vincent Browne: “Fionnan, let’s talk a bit about the tapes and their provenance. I gather that you had the tapes, or Independent Newspapers, had the tapes for quite a while before you published them?”

Fionnan Sheahan: “Yeah, we’ve had them for a while. Obviously you’d put a lot of research into a story like this Vincent before putting it out there. That’s normal journalistic practice.”

Browne: “And how long did you have them?”

Sheahan: “For a while.”

Browne: “Can you tell us how long?”

Sheahan: “No.”

Browne: “Why not?”

Sheahan: “Why should I?”

Browne: “Because I’m asking you. And I’m sure…”

Sheahan: “We’ve had them for a while Vincent. And we were using the time, within which to actually, to actually gather information about this, about the significance of it and so on and so forth, and get photographs.”

Browne: “But I’m just asking you ‘how long’, you don’t have to tell us the exact number of days but all right, OK. OK, like if politicians behaved like that…we don’t.”

Sheahan: “No Vincent, you spend so much time showing your bias towards Independent Newspapers, it’s getting sickening at this point.”

Browne: “All right.”

Sheahan: “Can you not just acknowledge it’s a good story and move on. Is that too much for you, is it?”

Browne: “Of course it is a good story.”

Sheahan: “Yeah, right, I didn’t hear you say it.”

Browne: “No, I didn’t say it because it’s not…I don’t have to say it.”

Sheahan: “I’m sick, I’m sick of your attitude towards the Irish Independent.”

Browne: “Do you have a problem?”

Sheahan: “I do, I do Vincent. I do have a problem.”

Browne: “You do?”

Sheahan: “I do, when you bring a colleague of mine in here a couple of weeks ago and just kick him around for your fun. So can you not just acknowledge in this case Vincent, it’s a perfectly good story and let’s talk about it.”

Browne: “Let’s get on with it. And let’s get rid of this problem that you have, or rather let’s ignore it.”

Sheahan: “It’s not a problem I have.”

Browne: “Ignore the problem, let’s get on with it.”

Sheahan: “It’s a problem you have with the Irish Independent.”

Watch here


Staff and freelance workers at the Irish Sun office in Dublin, above, yesterday after former Communications Minister and Green party leader Eamon Ryan, on Tonight With Vincent Browne, claimed there were only “very small numbers” of Irish people working in the News International office, which includes The Sunday Times.


Also on the panel were former Sunday Tribune editor, Noirin Hegarty, Sunday Independent deputy business editor, formerly of The Sunday Times, Tom Lyons and former business correspondent with the Sunday Independent, Martin Fitzpatrick.

Eamon Ryan: “Vincent, can I tell you where some of the money is going, in Irish media. Half a billion is going out of this country to Rupert Murdoch every year. (Inaudible)…huge profits made in Irish media – some of those, Vodafone, O2, some of those phone companies. They’re making a fortune out of Irish media. Now they’re actually carrying it, they’re not the content provider. But there are areas in Irish media which are hugely profitable and I think we have to look at a public policy basis to say are we happy with that? Do we want to just let Irish journalism run out, run to real trouble? And allow Sky take a fortune out of the country every year?”

Noirin Hegarty: “But Eamon, in fairness, Irish journalists are employed in The Sunday Times. They’re employed in The Sun. They’re employed in Murdoch titles.”

Ryan: “Very small numbers.”

Hegarty: “There are jobs being created here.”

Ryan: “Very small numbers. Very good people, but very small numbers. And very little of that money is invested back in this country.”

Hegarty: “But you were talking about how little opportunities there are (for young journalists to get jobs)..you know?”

Ryan: “Sky drains money out of this country and with the exception of some very good journalists in The Sunday Times and elsewhere, they don’t put the same resources back in. And we should be pushing them towards that.”

Hegarty: “But the reality of the new media feature is your competition is from everywhere, it’s from Facebook, it’s from Google, it’s from all of the other, it’s from Microsoft, it’s from everybody, where the advertising revenue is going.”

Vincent Browne: “Tom.”

Tom Lyons: “Sky is employing…it’s hiring 800 people in the middle of a downturn. It’s said it’s going to invest a billion here. You know, yes, there are profits being taken out but I can certainly say that, you know, The Sunday Times. They’re not making huge supernormal profits here. They’re making a good product here. And but I wouldn’t say it’s that much far ahead of break even.”

Watch here @23.15

(Pic: Jennifer O’Brien)



Who you gonna call?

Last night on Tonight with Vincent Browne, the host disclosed to his panel – co-authors of Fingers (Gill & MacMillan),Tom Lyons and Richard Curran and Elaine Byrne, of the Sunday Independent – that he had got a loan from the Irish Nationwide.

And he wasn’t alone.

Vincent Browne: “One of the interesting things about the Fingleton saga, I think Elaine, I’m not sure if you’re familiar with this is the degree to which he co-opted journalists into his practices and  his orbit. And it meant that, not only was there no accountability exercised on Irish Nationwide, or little accountability regarding Michael Fingleton through the regulator and other supervisory bodies but the media played dead, again, on this.”

Elaine Byrne: “Yeah, I was struck at the launch tonight in Hodges and Figges in town, as we were waiting around, talking and listening to the various speeches was the number of journalists who said to me ‘Oh, I got a loan in Irish Nationwide’..but often at high interest rates and often because journalists then didn’t have secure positions and weren’t very good prospects for mortgages in other institutions. So he may have given them very large mortgages or given them mortgages where the interests were a lot higher…”

Browne: “I should own up. I got a mortgage from Irish Nationwide Building Society.”

Byrne: “See?”

Browne: “But anyway, go on, yeah. And I didn’t know what interest rate it was, like many other journalists.”

Byrne: “Did you pay it all off?”

Browne: “Oh, eventually yeah. But by getting a mortgage from somewhere else. I fell out with the building society because I launched a magazine on the basis of not paying the mortgage for a number of months.”

Byrne: “OK. But did it..did it colour your views of Michael Fingleton?”

Browne: “Em. I can’t remember to be quite frank. It coloured my views of the person I was dealing with in Irish Nationwide”

Bryne: “You’re a little bit older than me but..

Browne: “What?”

Byrne: “A small bit. But..so I’m not in the position of having met with Michael Fingleton or mortgage, so it’s more your generation, being very polite but, I mean, was it something that you thought was very prevalent in your time? That people of your generation, journalists, getting mortgages that perhaps, they were a little less difficult to make scrutiny of him or analyse his activities.”

Browne: “Since I myself never engaged at all hardly, virtually in examining financial issues, it didn’t impinge on what I was doing. But I was struck by the fact that, in one newspaper, a Sunday newspaper, during the 70s and early 80s, Michael Fingleton’s picture appeared every Sunday, which I thought was odd at the time.”

Byrne: “On social occasions?”

Browne: “Usually giving a prize to somebody for something or other.”

Byrne: “Well one of the things, one of the journalists said to me this evening actually,  an old hack was saying that he was a great guy for going for quotes and that’s how a lot of journalists got to know because often, within the banking, financial world it was a very closed shop, a closed society and that he was actually very publicity aware and that’s how a lot of journalists got to know him. So I guess maybe he was the Fr Brian D’Arcy of the financial world.”

Richard Curran: “I think one of the things Vincent aswell about the journalists and the mortgages with Irish Nationwide, it seems to have been, with all due respect, among a certain generation. I kind of started in business journalism in 1992/93 and I never would have thought of or dreamt of particularly going to Irish Nationwide if I wanted to get a mortgage or anything else. But I kind of discovered that quite a lot of people, who were older than me and might have got their first mortgage in the 70s, or in the 80s even, had gone to Irish Nationwide. And if you get into the issue then or whether or not the media performed its role adequately in relation to Irish Nationwide, over a long period of time. Journalists are consumers, the same as everyone else. So the question is so if I have a mobile phone, and I’m a customer of one mobile phone company, does that compromise me? No. The question is whether I feel I owe them something, whether I feel beholden to them for something in some way. So I think in Irish Nationwide’s case, because of the way mortgages were given out at the time, because of the way journalists earn their income, a lot of journalists felt that they wouldn’t get a mortgage anywhere else.”

Browne: “Yes, that was certainly the case.”

Curran: “So they felt they owed him.”

Byrne: ” A loyalty, deference.”

Curran: “Yeah, so the question is whether that would have coloured how they wrote about the society or how they wrote about him.”

Browne: “Building societies coloured journalists as a bad risk, not just because they didn’t have secure jobs, many of us did have secure jobs at the time, but we weren’t good at managing the finances we did have, or whatever those finances were. And therefore the word would spread around that it was possible to get a mortgage from Irish Nationwide whereas it was not possible to get it elsewhere. And I’m sure that was a compromising factor.”

Curran: “And you also have to remember then that during those years Irish Nationwide was incredible profitable. So if you were a business journalist, writing about it, what were you going to say? ‘He’s making loads of money for the members, everything seems to be going fantastically’. He was paying himself a lot of money, that was known. But then, in around, you know, the early 2000s is when we saw some journalistic campaigning, particularly done by Bill Tyson, as personal finance editor of the Sunday Independent, where he challenged Irish Nationwide and the way he treated small borrowers and he went on to win two national media awards on foot of his Irish Nationwide coverage so clearly any sense that people might have had that Irish Nationwide was not being heavily criticised, or not being acknowledged if it did anything wrong, that it clearly was gone because many of the judges would have been peers of journalists at the time and they would have felt this is really, really good word that you’re doing. So I think that there’s a generational element to that.”

Watch here

Previously: Brought To Book


Vincent, a 1982 animation written and directed by the reigning king of gothic stop-motion Tim Burton, tells the story of Vincent Malloy, a boy obsessed with Edgar Allen Poe who wants to be just like Vincent Price.

Narrated, rather wonderfully, by a 71 year-old Vincent Price.