Sinn Féin’s Martial Docility




From top: Jamie Bryson watches Daithí McKay giving testimony to Stormont’s Finance Committee; Derek Mooney

The recent Stormont resignations are an indication of the level of strict and unfaltering discipline that still operates within Sinn Féin.

Derek Mooney writes:

If there is one thing the Provos do well, it is commemorations. Give them the slightest reason and out come the banners, wreathes, black polo-necks, replica uniforms and the gang is ready to march anywhere.

So zealous are they to remember and memorialise that the objects of their commemoration do not even require any direct connection. All that is needed is a rallying cry, a route map, a bit of media attention and they are all set to go.

It is therefore curious, given this penchant for marking the contribution and sacrifice of others, that neither former Sinn Féin M.L.A. Daithí McKay nor Sinn Féin activist Thomas O’Hara can expect to find their colleagues publicly commemorating them anytime soon.

Last week, McKay resigned his Stormont seat and O’Hara was suspended as a Sinn Féin member after the Irish News accused McKay, then chair of Stormont’s Finance committee, of arranging for O’Hara to coach a witness due to appear at McKay’s committee in September 2015.

The witness, loyalist blogger Jamie Bryson, was there to give evidence about allegations of political corruption linked to Nama’s £1.3 billion “Project Eagle” sale of Northern Ireland property.

At the Committee hearing Bryson made allegations of kickbacks to a senior politician and, at the conclusion of his evidence, accused then Northern Ireland Peter Robinson of being that politician.

This is in line with the advice Bryson received from O’Hara on Sept 19th in their Twitter direct message exchanges:

O’Hara: When talking about Robinson refer to him as ‘Person A’. So say all you have to say about him referring to him as Person A. Then in your final line say: Person A is Peter Robinson MLA. Means that the committee cannot interrupt you and means that you don’t have to say robbos name until the very last second. So then it’s job done!

Shortly after the Bryson evidence, McKay was at the Dáil’s Public Accounts Committee on October 1 to discuss his committee’s investigations into the Project Eagle deal.

Responding to a specific question from Deputy Shane Ross on Bryson’s evidence and why the NI Finance Committee had decided to call him, McKay replied:

“It is well known that he [Bryson] has blogged at some length on this. It is also well known that he appears to have a lot of material which some believe may have been fed to him from another source. It was an issue of debate for the committee. What the committee agreed to do was to set a bar. The bar that has been set for him and future witnesses is that they have to prove that they have some connection to the terms of reference of the inquiry.”

Oh the irony of McKay talking about Bryson being “fed” and his setting the bar high.

So, why does any of this matter?

Well, there is more to this episode than just dodgy goings on by Sinn Féin at Stormont. Nama’s Project Eagle was the single biggest property sale in Irish history.

The investigation by Stormont’s Finance Committee was supposed to establish the truth behind the accusations of wrong doing.

Perhaps that Stormont Committee was never going to be able to uncover the truth behind the deal and expose whose fingers were in the till, but as the SDLP Leader, Colum Eastwood, has pointed out:

“Sinn Féin’s interference in that democratic investigation has only served the purposes of those who are alleged to have corruptly benefited from the Project Eagle deal in the first place”.

It is hard to imagine that was Sinn Féin’s primary intention, yet it is the likely outcome of it.

So why, after months of posturing and calling for a full public investigation of this massive property deal, would Sinn Féin undermine an element of that investigation?

Were they just eager to get Robinson’s name on the record or could they have had other pressing political considerations at the time?

At around this this time last year senior PSNI officers were linking a murder in east Belfast with the Provisional IRA. That killing was thought to have been in revenge for a killing in May.

We are now expected to believe that undermining of what is a very legitimate public concern was all done by two lone wolves: McKay and O’Hara without any input, sanction or direction from others? Really?

The current N.I. Finance Minister, Sinn Féin’s Máirtín Ó Muilleoir has described the contacts between Bryson and the Sinn Féin officials as “inappropriate”.

He denies any involvement with or knowledge of their communications, though he was a member of the McKay committee when Bryson gave his evidence and was even mentioned twice in the O’Hara/Bryson exchanges.

If the positions were reversed down here and it was a Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil Minister facing such questions, it is hard to imagine Messrs McDonald, Doherty or Ó Broin being quiet as phlegmatic and dismissive as Ó Muilleoir appears in his statement this morning.

The fact that both McKay and O’Hara have so readily been thrown under the bus without even a whimper from either is not only a testament to their loyalty and commitment but an indication of the level of strict and unfaltering discipline that still operates within Sinn Féin.

Can you imagine a T.D., Senator or Councillor in any other party being so ready to walk away so silently?

No, me neither.

While it is tempting to speculate that Michéal, Enda or Brendan might yearn to have such command and mastery over their flocks, I suspect they are content to forego such control as they see the bigger picture and know that democratic accountability is not well served by such martial docility.

Derek Mooney is a communications and public affairs consultant. He previously served as a Ministerial Adviser to the Fianna Fáil led government 2004 – 2010. Follow Derek on Twitter: @dsmooney

Top pic: Irish News

Sponsored Link

25 thoughts on “Sinn Féin’s Martial Docility

    1. Redzer

      You mean SocDem hackery – when it comes to politics, Broadsheet is a mouthpiece for the Social Democrats and nobody else these days…

  1. Neilo

    Shoot the messenger. *Whispers to the Provos – not literally, lads, ‘peace process’ and all that*

  2. Tish Mahorey

    “If there is one thing the Provos do well,…”

    That’s where you stop reading because clearly it’s yet another predictable Shinner bashing tirade.

    This default Sinners Are Bad mantra is tired and long out of date. Using their past as a way to undermine their current economic and social policies is wearing thin. Their detractors only fear losing their grip on the inner workings of this country and their faux outrage at the violence of the past is transparent and obvious. Fianna Fail and even Fine Gael condemnation of the IRA wasn’t always that forthcoming during the 70s and 80s because they knew many of their own voters secretly supported the IRA campaign in the north.

    But now FF and FG are on their high horses 20 years after the signing of the GFA as if they had always been so during the worst of the troubles. Hypocrites.

  3. Vote Rep #1

    Is there any other party that has followers with such a weird obsessive need to defend the party at all cost as SF does?

  4. Neilo

    Nope. The whip extends far beyond Stormont and Leinster House (Westminster excluded – though happy to claim fat stacks for expenses).

  5. Yupyup

    FF guy makes a big meal out of the no no that was SF mess up here. Tumbleweed on the actual NAMA dirt. The real story

  6. Kolmo

    Whom ever was feeding Bryson (a low-brow ambitious careerist politician) nuggets about the largest alleged theft from the Irish Taxpayer and misappropriations has decided to pull the plug on him, pull in SF to the mix to muddy what was actually being investigated. Seeds of doubt have been planted, Operation ‘Dilute Namagate’ has begun..

  7. abaddon

    You only need to read the first two paragraphs to know that this post is nothing but a sneer from a party hack.

    There is absolutely nothing of substance in this post.

    It is littered with innuendo after innuendo.

    Is broadsheet just a platform now for (current\former) political advisors to come on and post attacks on other parties?

    I thought Mooney’s post last week likening Jeremy Corbyn to Trump was a low for broadsheet.

    I have been a long time visitor of this site since it began, while i wouldn’t agree with the position it takes on every issue, I’ve found it to be a reputable and informative site.

    The above post and previous from Mooney damages this sites reputation.

    1. topsy

      Well said. Mooney asks if we can imagine a TD, Senator or Councillor “so ready to walk away so silently”.
      Once again this from a consultant to a Government which wrecked a country and then slipped away with massive pensions at the expense of those they ruined. Words such as Kettle and Pot come to mind.

  8. bisted

    ‘…Can you imagine a T.D., Senator or Councillor in any other party being so ready to walk away so silently? ‘…not since Ray Burke…was sure he would spill the beans but the FF omerta seems stronger than SF discipline…

  9. some old queen

    I do not accept for one moment that McKay or O’Hara was feeding that clown Bryson off their own bat. It was approved and sanctioned and then, made public by Bryson because he took the huff about a banned march.

    So SF felt that getting one over on the DUP was way more important than potentially discrediting the biggest fraud investigation in Ireland. Who is being partitionist now?

    Absolutely disgraceful behavior by SF.

  10. Truth in the News

    FF backroom flunkeys expression of their indignation of SF discipline, if the Shinners
    diclipinary rules were applied to Fianna Fail, they’d have no one left, and it would be
    no great loss, in fact a great leap forward…..come to think of it, they haven’t much to
    say about NAMA either…..or indeed their why the great party got us into such a mess

  11. Mé Féin

    I saw the big fat Fianna Failure face and didn’t bother reading. Shinner bad, NAMA good. Was that the gist of it?
    NAMA was an unqualified success because Sinn Féin threw the economy down the crapper? Or did I get that back to front?

  12. Joxer

    Derek instead of bashing SF why not do a piece on the shennanigans at NAMA and this project Eagle carry-on?

    a couple of lads do some ticket touting and the Dail is holding an enquiry and yet we have the murky goings on witn Nama being investigated by US and UK law enforcement/Regulators due to ‘irregularities’ and our Dail couldnt be less enthused to look into it… ah sure grand little country we have here.

    Broadsheet – is Derek Mooney the equivalent of Genee Kerrigan in the Indo? Someone to give the ‘other’ view?

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Link