Tears Are Not Enough


Minister for Children Katherine Zappone and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar have made emotional responses to the latest adoption scandal.

This evening.

The Coalition of Mother And Baby home Survivors (CMABS) are “united in rejecting Taoiseach Leo Varadkar’s assertion that it is too early to consider redress or free DNA tests” for the victims of the latest adoption related scandal.

Paul Redmond of CMABS writes:

Once again, the Government’s instant response to survivors and victims is to fob them off and began the endless series of excuses, stalling, scoping exercises and sub committees, while illegally adopted people and their natural mothers continue to die by the hundreds.

CMABS notes for the record that despite extensive lobbying by campaigners, Minister Zappone has already rejected including illegally adopted people in the current Inquiry into Mother and Baby homes and related matters.

Illegally adopted people are the victims of crime and as such, have a right to ‘legal remedy’ under domestic and international law. Minister Zappone has denied illegal adoptees and their natural mothers this most basic human and civil right, and now continues to do so with the support of an uncaring Taoiseach.

Campaigners have long insisted that a national DNA database for adopted people and natural mothers is one of the very few ways progress can be made here but, it has been consistently rejected.

The victims of this latest scandal will almost certainly need long term counseling to assist them in dealing with their new situations but there is no sign of any such facility or funding at present.

There should be modest interim payments to victims – both illegal adoptees and their natural mothers – to give them the time and space to deal with the shock, possibly take time off work and, source local counseling.

Taoiseach Varadkar and Minister Zappone need to urgently address this matter by meeting with representative groups and listening, instead of never ending cheap soundbites in the media followed by years of inaction while survivors die.

A national DNA database with free tests for survivors, an moderate interim redress payment and free counseling are the bare minimum required in this instance.

CMABS notes that there is also a severe deficit of political will in Ireland to deal with the dark history of our country and the living survivors who still bear the scars to this day.

CMABS also notes our calls for a dedicated unit of civil servants, Gardai and social workers with the power to seize records, and pro actively investigate illegal adoptions, has been consistently rejected for many years.

There is still time to prosecute any persons left alive who have been complicit in these inhuman crimes.

Survivors of Mother and Baby homes, forced adoptions, illegal adoptions and a myriad of immoral and criminal activity, are a dying community.

It seems state policy is currently to carry on denying and stalling every inch of the way, while we die, to reduce the final cost.

This is nothing but a shameful reflection on our national politics and a lack of courage and political will by Varadkar and Zappone who have once again shamed themselves personally with their mealy mouthed response to the elderly victims of odious crimes.

Paul is author of the recently-published Adoption Machine: The Dark History of Ireland’s Mother and Baby Homes and the Inside Story of How Tuam 800 Became a Global Scandal (Irish Academic Press)

Coalition of Mother And Baby Homes (CMABS)

Adoption registration issue is ‘another dark chapter’ – Varadkar (RTE)

Earlier: Orientated Toward The ‘Better Class of Girl’

Yesterday: ‘People May never Know They Were Adopted’

24 thoughts on “Tears Are Not Enough

  1. Starina

    Zappone is such a disappointment. and if they’re worried about money, dna tests cost 99$ on 23andme, i’m sure it would be pennies to the government to get them wholesale

    1. Ina.

      Never expected much from Zappone, nobody who’s ever worked with her has left with admiration for her. But she’s been totally co-opted by FG.

      1. bisted

        …if Zappone were half as creative with these issues as she is with her expenses they would be solved overnight…

        1. GiggidyGoo

          A point not forgotten either. The distance as far as i’m aware is ‘as the crow flies’, and not the road that enables her to go into the €20k extra bracket. Another gift from Varadkar.

    2. GiggidyGoo

      Zappone didn’t uncover this scandal. 2014 Aevril Power brought this to the attention of the Seanad back in 2014 as far as I know.
      Zappone is full of it.

  2. Emily Dickinson

    Great. More politicians sobbing.

    I was in London when Princess Diana died.

    It’s like that every day now.

    1. Spaghetti Hoop

      What has London’s emotive mourning a royal got to do with the Irish adoption scandal?

      1. Emily Dickinson

        We pay our pols €200k to fix problems, not to emote and feel our pain. And as has already been pointed out, the sentimentally comes to a sudden halt when Zapper starts calculating her expenses.

  3. PlumBobSmearPants

    I think calling this an adoption scandal is somewhat flawed. It’s a ‘stolen baby’ scandal of the highest order. How many mothers actually had their children stolen from them?! Told lies they were born dead and sold on?! It’s a series of staggeringly evil crimes and with the Church and State both complicit.

    1. blonto

      Absolutely. And it’s definitely not a new scandal. What’s new is the government is being forced to deal with it.
      I read an article about 5 years ago about how De Valeras son was involved in selling babies to american couples.
      All the crimes committed in the laundries and mother and babies homes need to be investigated for the sake of the survivors. And it needs to be done before the evil bastards all die out.

  4. phil

    If we did DNA tests, I wonder what the chances are of Bishops, priests and PEP’s or politicians being the fathers of these illegally adopted children ?

Comments are closed.