From left: Simon Coveney, Leo Varadkar, and Vice-President of the European Parliament Mairead McGuinness MEP
A lot of people speculating that Simon Coveney or Mairead McGuinness will replace Phil Hogan.
The decision is at the discretion of the Taoiseach who is Fianna Fail.
Don’t be surprised if he appoints one of his own.
— Ken Murray (@NewsMurray) August 26, 2020
One of his own?
But who?
The obvious replacement for #philhogan is Bertie Ahern. He knows the European scene inside out and is a first-rate negotiator who has shown an unrivalled ability to bring people with him.
— Michael Kelly ن (@MichaelKellyIC) August 26, 2020
YIKES.
Earlier: A Limerick A Day
Dan Boyle: Phil The Fluter’s Other Ball
Sponsored Link
Annie Oakely and Fitzer’s names have been bandied about. If either of those get this position, that would be another insult to Von der Leyen and the EU.
Just thinking about the “optics”. Leo & Micheál will be very aware that Golfgate highlighted an old image of crooked, crony politics. It’s an image they very much want to put behind them (I presume).
Picking Bertie would be….. unhelpful. To say the least.
EDIT- I’m not saying there was anything crooked going on, but it’s the “same old politics” & “Galway tent” conversations that this has inspired.
yeah, “New Politics” heeheee
I guess we’ll find out soon enough…but there seems to be large assumptions going on that whomever it is will get to simply pick up the portfolio (off the back seat of Phil’s motor :) :) ) I reckon it could go to anyone but us pixieheads
pixieheads?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olD8Nv7C8qs
Is Michael Kelly a comedian?
…worse…a catholic…absolutely no sense of humour…
you should check out presbyterian if you wanna see a bunch of dry dry folks,
hindus now, they like a giggle
I think Bertie would be a good choice- despite his faults of which there are many, he was a champion of the Good Friday Agreement and his appointment would be very popular in the north.
genuine question, soq: why should we care what pleases the north?
Because what happens there directly affects what happens here.
You may think of the two jurisdictions as separate entities but you clearly have little knowledge of the border region and how interdependent the communities are there now.
Should we also make our appointment dependent on what pleases the English? They’re only across the Irish sea, and are very interdependent with us.
NI’s residents are residents of an entirely different country to us, their opinion is of no relevance to politics here.
You memory is obviously failing you. NI’s unique status between the two countries is what had the British houses of Parliament toed in knots for over a year? And, it was the Irish government who were insisting that it’s special status must be retained.
I’m aware how interdependent the border communities are – but that has zilch to do with our choice of commissioner
it would be bizarre to base the decision of how it will be received within a jurisdiction that’s leaving the EU
But NI is not leaving, at least not in the same way as GB. The GFA must be protected and I happen to think that Bertie is the best person to do it.
@BB – It is not leaving the EU, completely. Our fellow Irish citizens will remain fellow European citizens. We should not pick our commissioner to please them but we should represent them.
NI will follow some EU rules and enforce EU customs code, but it is ‘leaving’ the EU
…loads of loyalists now hold Irish passports…known locally as Shrodingers Catholics…
I don’t think Bernie would impress them, though. I think he should be in jail.
Any alleged popularity in the north would be completely negated by how incredibly unpopular that appointment would be everywhere else except Drumcondra. It will be a Fine Gael person. It has been agreed that FF will appoint the next commissioner if the government survives. For Michael Martin to appoint Bertie would result in the collapse of the government.
The nominee also isn’t automatically accepted. France’s first nominee to the current commission was rejected due to questions over her finances. Bertie would be rejected too due to the many unanswered questions over his own finances and previous tribunal findings.
So Von der Layen says that Ireland must nominate a woman and a man for this position.
– Helen McEntee may be a good choice as she can’t have been totally indoctrinated into the totality of the quagmire that is Irish Politics yet.
– Surprised that Varadkar isn’t high up the list, given his penchant for the limelight.(Still would like to know if Hogan’s version of having met him on 12th August is true mind you as it doesn’t add up to Hogan’s timeline of that day (went home that evening after meeting Varadkar, to Kilkenny, yet was in Adare at the same time?) Something fishy.
last time round, we sent them phil hogan so they’re probably not expecting anything too hot from us this time
…and the FFers sent Charlie McCreevey and Pee Flynn…maybe they think the only way is up…wrong…
Maybe they could see if either Mary Mitchell O’Connor or Maria Bailey are still looking for a job?
I don’t get this. There were no such conditions on other member states who picked their own commissioners. Now she wants a competitive process?
There were. We just ignored her request last time. Not sure we’re in a position to do that this time..
McEntee is new to the quagmire in ways…in other ways she was born into it.
Yep. But it hasn’t manifested itself (yet, anyway).
Whoever has failed the most in Irish politics is a prime candidate. There are dozens eligible so
Unfortunately, true.
…ex-Taoisigh will be elbowing their way to the top of the list…but who’ll be the token woman…failure is definitely gender neutral…
If there have to be two nominations, then who decides the winner, who today has come first in this competition which decides who, indeed, has succeeded in this celebration etc. etc.
Evening wear, swimwear and interview then is it?
Ha haaaa. Good one.
Arise, Sir John Brutal.
Guffaw! Wait till I stuff my napkin over my top collar button.
Step forward Eoghan Murphy, you’re time has come!
It would not surprise me one bit
Donie Cassidy to the rescue!
Could we be about to witness the political return of Brian Haze?
Ivor Calleary?
Cometh the hour, Cowen the man?
no way would michael martin allow bertie to be the commissioner from ireland.
id say it will be a woman. helen mcentee looks very strong being seen to be part of brexit negotiations.
frances fitzgerald could also.
not as many FF females with as high a profile.
Fitz has a lot of baggage though. McEntee would be a better bet as she’s rubbed shoulders (before Covid-19) with the people that matter [in relation to Brexit anyway] and hasn’t really put a foot wrong. And no baggage.
(Doherty may be happy if McEntee did get the calling, as she may think she’d once again get to the Dail)
https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/politics/downing-street-is-laughing-at-ireland-over-phil-hogan-resignation-fine-gael-td-39483481.html
Paul Kehoe smarting over his mate Phil’s dumping. And sure, why wouldn’t he? Sure didn’t Kehoe get a great bargain when he bought the house from Hogan. The house that Kehoe had rental income from but ‘forgot’ to declare it in his members interests, saying it was his residence – but he had been renting it out.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2140216/Chief-Whip-Kehoe-altered-2011-Register-Interests-MoS-questions-Minister-hid-house-bought-Hogan.html
Fair old fine could have ensued.
My earlier post doesn’t appear to have made the cut
So in brief
Replacement won’t be a sitting TD
That would reduce the Whip numbers
And make Sinn Féin the biggest Party in the Dáil
Unless they’re 100% on the By-election. In which case more likely Richard Bruton or Patrick Donovan (‘help us all ) if it’s to be a Blueshirt
My money is in the Mná tho’
Regina, Mairead or even Francie Fitz
From the eFFers – Lisa Chambers is about the only one worth shortlisting
But more likely they’ll go with a disappointed oul’ FFella over Chambers. In which case Callery might yet get some gravy as his seat will be won back handily enough. And a win would do Michéal the world of good, especially a By-election one
My missing post updated ye on the Brian Hayes party of three (plus btw)
I’m not inclined to repeat meself
All in my Twitter feed anyway
If anyone has a book open
A tenner on Regina
“Hayes says social media speculation over his golf dinner guests is ‘all made up’”
https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40039022.html
school pals says he
well now
If Bertie is being touted, then there wasn’t much point in getting rid of the Hog. Swapping out one cute hoor for another makes no sense.