Author Archives: Admin

 Cartoonist Mohammad Sabaaneh (left) with the author in Galway last week and work (top) by Mohammed lampooning next month’s Israel-hosted Eurovision

What kind of country jails a cartoonist?

Is it the kind of place we should be sending Irish artists to for a celebration of diversity and European pop culture next month?

Those thoughts struck me last week when I hosted a cartoonist in my home for a night during his week-long tour of Ireland.

Mohammad Sabaaneh is no ordinary cartoonist.

He’s a man who spent five months in jail for his art and a household name across the Arab world, particularly in Palestine where he has a cartoon published daily in a national newspaper, al-Hayat al-Jadida. He has more than 500,000 Facebook followers.

Mohammad taught me a lot about the power of art last week and also how a man can use his gifts to highlight the terrible suffering and injustice which has been inflicted upon his people for decades.

He is regularly invited to cartoon festivals and arts events throughout the world and faces a logistical nightmare trying to get to them if and when he travels.

It was returning from one of those work trips six years ago that Mohammad found himself being interrogated about his art by Israeli soldiers.

He spent two months being interrogated about his work, when he was forbidden from drawing or writing. He then spent a further three months in prison, including some time in solitary confinement; time he used to document his experiences in smuggled or hidden drawings which he put together after returning home to Ramallah.

Mohammad spent five months in prison because he had collaborated with his brother on a book about political prisoners, a project which angered those in power.

This terrible experience provided Sabaaneh with inspiration. He vowed to document his feelings about what he witnessed in Israeli prisons and managed to get fellow prisoners to smuggle out his works of art whenever he had the opportunity.

He left blank spaces in all of the drawings, so that the prison authorities could not examine his strong views about life in Israeli prisons if they came across or confiscated them.

“They investigated me about everything, about my activity, about my participation in international exhibitions, and about my opinions,” he recalled.

The irony was that the charges against Mohammad were baseless – his accusers and interrogators did not seem to know or care that his cartoons have also angered the various political factions in Palestine.

He embodies the true role of an artist who holds the most powerful to account and ridicules those who abuse their power.

Before a packed house in Galway last week, he wanted to talk about the Palestinian prisoners as real people, with mothers, wives, brothers and sisters; with feelings of loneliness and despair.

He wanted to challenge the way in which his people are dehumanised so often in the Irish, European, and American media.

As we listened to him, it was impossible not to understand his rage.

His people have had their land stolen, been treated as second class citizens in their own country, and endure daily harassment at checkpoints where they are faced down by angry, hostile soldiers.

More than 200 of their children (yes, children) are in Israeli prisons, and many of the prisoners are incarcerated in places where their loved-ones can never visit them.

In prison, Mohammad was not allowed to speak to relatives on the telephone or receive visits from family members. His experience awakened him to the gross injustice which is being inflicted on so many men, women and children from his country.

“Everyone deals with Palestinian prisoners as heroes, but I wanted my drawings to show them as real human beings,” he told the captive audience at the Black Gate Cultural Centre in Galway.

“No-one talks about the Palestinian prisoner’s mother, or wife, or kids; or how they try to pass the time, by listening to a football game.”

Sabaneeh’s work is disturbing, but how else could it be for a man whose people have spent more than half a century being treated as second class citizens under military occupation in their own land?

How can they not be angry, when they see their fate being played out in an election in which they have no say in their own future.

His art work is also brilliant.

It provides a timely reminder of the real motivation behind the staging of this year’s Eurovision Song Contest in Tel Aviv.

It’s all about whitewashing an Apartheid regime which gave the people of the West Bank no voice at all in terms of the military occupation in this week’s General Election.

During the campaign, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pledged to annex the Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank if he was returned to power.

He promised to prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state by “controlling the entire area”, continuing to dominate the lives of more than 2.5 million people who have lived under a brutal occupation for so long.

Where Mohammad lives, there is no peace process.

Hundreds of thousands of people now live in illegal settlements on land which was captured in a war more than half a century ago.

World powers consider those settlements to be illegal under international law and Mohammad’s cartoons capture the daily humiliations faced by his people, at checkpoints, on segregated roads, or through dawn raids by armed soldiers in their homes.

When you hear him talk about the reality of life as an artist in occupied Palestine, you can only be filled with admiration for his bravery in expressing his rage.

How else could he be, as a wonderfully talented artist, when he sees so much suffering and anger around him every day?

Remember Mohammad and his amazing work when artists and TV crews from all across Europe congregate in Tel Aviv next month – or when Madonna turns up to play two songs.

Eurovision 2019 is not a celebration of music and culture – it’s a clear and protracted effort to “normalise” a regime which puts talented artists like Mohammad in prison, just for speaking out about the terrible injustices he sees around him in the West Bank.

Mohammad, like so many artists all across Palestine, wants Ireland and the rest of Europe to boycott Eurovision 2019.

How pathetic it seems to celebrate European pop culture in a place which has so little interest in granting artists anything approaching freedom, justice, or human rights.

The estimated 180 million viewers who watch the Eurovision next month will feast on tourism promotion clips from Israel, but they won’t see images of peaceful protesters being murdered by snipers at the Gaza border fence, families being evicted from their homes in East Jerusalem, or little children being terrorised on their way home from school in Hebron.

The brilliant cartoons of Mohammad Sabaaneh tell the world some bitter home truths about life in Palestine, home truths that won’t be screened on our TV screens on May 18, even though they are considered so subversive they result in artists like him being thrown in prison.

Shame on the Eurovision for white-washing an illegal occupation on behalf of a regime which locks up artists and tramples on human rights.

Expressing the rage of a denigrated people (Ciaran Tierney)

Sabaaneh.com

From top: Micheál Martin in 2011; Taoiseach Leo Varadkar (right) and Minister for Health Simon Harris

Retired public healthcare worker Brian Burke writes:

It’s only April in the Health Services but The Cervical Smear Programme is in jeopardy with a waiting time of up to eight months for test results.

Why? Because Minister Harris offered repeat screenings to women last year after the CervicalCheck scandal broke. This was despite the fact that he was advised that the capacity didn’t exist.

Why is there no capacity? Because of the enormous numbers involved and that the Health Services outsourced the service and didn’t develop in-house expertise and capacity.

The new National Children’s Hospital will cost at least €1.7 billion, between €400 and €700 million over budget depending on who you believe. There was a whitewash, sorry, I mean report out yesterday. So far, I haven’t learned anything that was not already known.

Leaving aside the “management” of the project that has seen the resignation of two board members, allow me to suggest another fundamental reason for the added expense: It is being built in the wrong place.

There were two greenfield sites on offer, Connolly Hospital and Newlands Cross but the government prevaricated and eventually chose the back yard of an overextended James’ Hospital.

This brownfield site resulted in fundamental extra costs caused by A confined site Limited Access Demolition Works Excavation Works Rerouting of Utilities and that’s before you even start to build.

The Department of Health has already indicated that other capital projects will be “rescheduled” to allow for this year’s overrun of 100 million. Health Service Executive has banned recruitment.

How are service providers expected to cover for annual leave, sick leave, extra demand, not to mention natural wastage due to resignation and retirement?

This was a budgetary decision to save money. But we are only three months into the year.

Disability Services are again in the spotlight for the wrong reasons. The Childrens’ Ombudsman criticised the HSE yesterday because of failures in the care system and children with autism and similar conditions are being expelled from schools because of the State’s inability or unwillingness to provide support services.

The Homeless Mental Health Team haven’t accepted referrals since last July. This is despite the fact that homeless people are at a greater risk of illness, self harm and suicide.

The National Maternity Strategy has received no new funding. The strategy was launched as a response to a spate of failures in our maternity hospitals.

The audit of Orthodontic Services for children still hasn’t been published. Evidently its with the lawyers.

Hospital trolley manufacturers continue to delight in a booming and expanding industry as the crisis continues. The count yesterday was 631, the highest this year.

In an effort to deflect from the above Minister Harris announced a plan to provide free GP care for children under 12 by 2022, three years from now. It is important to note that it’s just a plan, not costed and no consultation with GPs. But it will do as a “smoke and mirrors” exercise.

On Monday, the Taoiseach and Minister Harris launched a “Healthy Ireland Campaign”. They obviously don’t do irony or is it a warning that you better be healthy because you are in serious trouble if you get sick.

The question continues to be, what can be done?

Back in 2001 “Quality and Fairness, A Health Strategy” was launched by the then Minister for Health, Micheál Martin. It was ambitious, far-sighted, radical and what the country needed and its citizens deserved.

It promised:

“A health system that supports and empowers you, your family and community to achieve your full health potential A health system that is there when you need it, that is fair, and that you can trust A health system that encourages you to have your say, listens to you, and ensures that your views are taken into account.”

But it was very soon doomed to failure when the then Minister for Finance and future EU Commissioner Charlie McCreevy failed to provide it with the necessary financial backing and it was resisted by certain vested interests.

Move forward another 16 years and we are presented with “SlainteCare” by the Oireachtas Committee on Health. Another worthy document that seems destined for failure.

Two years later, the 2019 Implementation Strategy has four goals, two of them are about saving money, one is about healthcare and the last is about implementing the other three.

Already we can see that this is being morphed into an exercise in economics with little or no patient focus.

As if this wasn’t enough “SlainteCare” has to overcome the considerable obstacles of the interests of Big Pharma/Private Health Insurance/Private Health Care Providers/Hospital Consultants and not necessarily in that order.

The reality is that for “SlainteCare” to succeed the government needs to drop an ideology that was best described as being “Closer to Boston than Berlin”. Unfortunately, given recent governments’ history when it comes to the provision of public services this is very unlikely to happen.

Rollingnews

Yesterday: Red Flags Missed