Author Archives: Bodger

Graham Dwyer

This morning.

In the High Court.

Graham Dwyer – who was sentenced to life in prison in March 2015 for murdering Elaine O’Hara in August 2012 and who is appealing his conviction – won a legal action against the Garda Commissioner and the State over data from mobile phones.

He claimed data gathered from his phone should not have been used at his 2015 trial at the Central Criminal Court.

Newstalk reports:

“The data formed a huge part of the trial but Dwyer argued it shouldn’t have been used as it breached his rights.

“The data placed the phone at a specific place at a particular time – however Dwyer, who was sentenced to life in prison in 2015, claimed the use of the data was unconstitutional.

“Gardaí gathered the information using laws that were brought in under a European directive. However the directive was later declared invalid by the European Court of Justice.

“The High Court today ruled that Irish laws – which allow for mobile phone data to be retained and accessed – are in breach of EU law.”

Meanwhile…

TJ McIntyre, law lecturer in University College Dublin and chair of Digital Rights Ireland, has tweeted:

Graham Dwyer wins legal action over phone data (RTE)

Graham Dwyer wins legal action against the State over mobile phone data (Newstalk)

Related: Two data retention cases pose questions for three Ministers for Justice (TJ McIntyre, IT Law In Ireland, 2015)

Rollingnews

Brexit to United Ireland? Four vital aspects of Brexit agreement from Irish perspective.

By FRO Films.

Keano, of FRO Films, writes:

I’ve put a video together of a review of what’s in the Brexit agreement from an Irish perspective.

FRO Films on Broadsheet

Custom House and Samuel Beckett Bridge in Dublin and Run Logic in Temple Bar, Dublin

Next Wednesday, December 12.

At 6.15pm.

The Dublin Running Meet Up Group – a group of recreational runners who go for 30 minute to hour-long post-works jogs – will be meeting up for a 10km jog around the city to see the capital’s lights before having a burger.

They’ll start from the shop Run Logic at 3-4 Smock Alley Court, Essex Street West, Temple Bar, Dublin 2.

They write:

“Dublin City Council has decorated 13 buildings in and around the city centre, including four bridges. We will be running from the shop taking in the sights on this elaborate tour of Dublin, stopping at locations for photo opportunities.

“We will also be able to loop through town via the bridges – reaching as far as the East Link Bridge and back to Temple Bar.

“Closing out the night we will go for burgers at WOW on the quays.”

“We warm gear, high viz safety gear and a big smile!”

Any excuse

Dublin City Lights Burger Run 10km (Meet Up)

Rollingnews

Thanks Ultan Mashup

UPDATE:

Meanwhile…

Samuel Beckett Bridge reimagined by Dublin FX

Previously: Dublin Reimagined

Thanks Spaghetti Hoop

From top: The former Mother and baby Home in Bessborough, Cork; from left: Irish Examiner journalist Conall Ó Fátharta, Minister for Children Katherine Zappone, Dr James Gallen, of Dublin City University

In April 2017, Dr James Gallen, a lecturer in the School of Law and Government at Dublin City University, was appointed by the Children’s Minister Katherine Zappone to help the Mother and Baby Homes Commission.

Specifically, Ms Zappone asked Dr Gallen “to assist by mapping out a model of ‘transitional justice’ as a means of giving voice to former residents of Mother and Baby Homes and County Homes”.

This morning, Conall Ó Fátharta, in The Irish Examiner, reports that Mr Gallen has accused the State of being:

“more concerned with managing the ‘potential scandal and legal liability’ of illegal adoption, birth registration, and other coercive adoption practices than helping victims”.

Mr Ó Fátharta reports:

Mr Gallen said “the State simply doesn’t get it” and pointed to the fact that the Department of Children and Youth Affairs has committed to a “transitional justice” approach to the Mother and Baby homes scandal.

“Talk of transitional justice is fundamentally undermined when the ongoing relationship between citizens and the State is one where the interests of an individual are countered by the desire to maintain the reputation of institutions,” said Mr Gallen.

Mr Gallen was speaking in light of a detailed special investigation by Mr Ó Fátharta published in Monday’s Irish Examiner about a woman Jackie Power (not her real name) who had to sign a consent form for her son to be adopted under a fictitious name.

Mr Ó Fátharta reported how, in 1974, Ms Power had a baby boy when she was a teenager in the Bessborough Mother and Baby Home in Cork.

Five months later she went back to Bessborough and signed a consent form allowing for her son to be adopted through the Sacred Heart Adoption Society.

She was told to put a false name on the consent form, which was also signed by a named nun.

The boy’s birth was illegally registered under this false name while the false name was also used for the formal adoption order.

In official documentation that followed, including the adoption order issued by the State’s regulatory body, the Adoption Board, both Ms Power and her son’s names were replaced by fictitious names.

Mr Ó Fátharta explained that if Ms Power’s son, who would now be 44, tried to contact his mother, he would, unbeknownst to himself, be searching for her under a false name.

In 2005, Ms Power told the Adoption Board (the AAI’s predecessor) about the false name and illegal registration and the agency didn’t inform the gardaí.

And…

Mr Ó Fátharta reported:

“Almost half a century later, the attitude of certain State agencies — the Adoption Authority of Ireland (AAI), and Tusla — to her case is as cold-hearted as the nuns who forced her as a 16-year-old to sign away both her and her son’s identities.

“Instead of offering support or offering assistance, emails between staff members show the attitude of Tusla to be one of institutional self-preservation.

“Just last year, staff handling Jackie’s case were instructed in emails not to refer to situations like hers as “illegal” but instead as “possible illegal registrations”. Reference is made to having to “hold our powder” because “that stuff is FOI’able… and it could be used against us if someone takes a case”.

State ‘prioritising liability over adoption rights’ (Conall Ó Fátharta, The Irish Examiner)

Special Report: Women forced to give up babies for adoption still failed by State bodies (Conall Ó Fátharta, The Irish Examiner)

What every tree needs.

Glittery, bespoke baubles and frippery.

From Dublin-based start-up Cado [set up by sisters Ruth and Eve last Christmas].

Santa sacks also available.

Cado

Irish-made stocking fillers to broadsheet@broadsheet.ie marked ‘Irish-Made Stocking Fillers’. No fee.

Trinity College Dublin graduate Sean Binder; Hundreds of thousands of lifejackets in a makeshift dump outside Eftalou, northern Lesbos in December 2015

Further to the arrest and detention of Sean Binder, 24, from Togher in Cork – who was working as a volunteer with asylum seekers on the island of Lesbos in Greece – last August…

The Guardian reports:

“After 107 days of incarceration, Sarah Mardini – the Syrian human rights worker who saved 18 refugees in 2015 by swimming their waterlogged dinghy to the shores of Lesbos with her Olympian sister – has been freed from Greece’s toughest jail.

The 23-year-old was released late on Wednesday from the high-security Koryallos prison in Athens, where she was being held in pre-trial detention on charges of people-smuggling.

She was allowed to walk free after her lawyers posted €5,000 (£4,450) in bail.

Sean Binder, a 24-year-old volunteer born in Germany and resident in Ireland, was also freed from custody in Chios [a separate island] along with two others from the NGO for which both had worked.

…Mardini and Binder had faced prison sentences of up to 25 years after being accused of facilitating people-smuggling through membership of a criminal organisation. Charges of espionage and money laundering were also levelled at the activists.

Both had been volunteering in search and rescue operations with the now-defunct Emergency Response Centre International (ERCI), an NGO based on Lesbos.

…But [Zaccharias Kesses, the lawyer heading the aid workers’ legal team in Athens] said a trial was still likely to take place. “The charges may be amended but I think it very unlikely that the trial will be dropped. There is vast pressure in local society against NGOs, who are perceived to be pull factors for refugees at a time when few want them.”

Syrian aid worker who swam refugees to safety freed from Greek jail (The Guardian)

Related: Sean Binder’s Arrest Represents the Criminalisation of Compassion (University Times)

Pic: University Times


;

From top: Prime Time logo; tweet from last night; Barrister Paul Anthony McDermott

before the jury was brought into court, Mr Grehan raised a segment from last night’s Prime Time programme with the judge.

He explained that, following a report on the recent Kerry murder trial, there was a general discussion about the law of provocation between the presenter and a well-known senior counsel, lecturer, author and media commentator.

The defence team then played the segment for the court on the RTE Player.

“I’m not saying there can never be media, academic or legal discussion in relation to a defence or its merits,” said Mr Grehan afterwards.

“But we are, in this trial, at a particularly sensitive time where a jury is deliberating.”

Murder trial collapses after jurors reveal they watched Prime Time programme last night (Irish Examiner)

Last week: During Deliberations

Meanwhile…

From top: Harvard food boffin’s tweet; tea time at Fusco’s

Ultan Mashup writes:

Starch Bombs”….This would never fly in the best chipper in Dublin, Fusco’s, Meath Street…

FIGHT!

A professor said 6 chips at a time is enough. Twitter revolted (RTÉ)

Previously: Great Food, Brilliant Menu