From top: Michael Barnier and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar; Foreign Minister Simon Coveney, Mr Barnier and moderator: Áine Lawlor at an event called “The Brexit Negotiations: State of play and future direction” this afternoon
This afternoon.
Dundalk Institute of Technology, County Louth.
The All-Island Civic Dialogue on Brexit: Fourth Plenary Session featuring the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator Michael Barnier.
He said there can be no Brexit withdrawal agreement without a “backstop” option for the Irish border,
Mr Barnier denied claims from Arlene Foster, the leader of the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), that he has been “aggressive” towards Northern Ireland unionists in the Brexit talks.
The DUP leader said earlier that Mr Barnier did not understand the dispute and was not an “honest broker”.
In response, the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator said he was not ready to engage in “polemics” with Mrs Foster.
He said he had not approached the negotiations in a “spirit of revenge”
From top (left to right): Head of the new US Center for SafeSport Shellie Pfohl; Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan; George Gibney; and journalist Irvin Muchnick
Former Irish swimming coach George Gibney was charged with 27 counts of indecency against young swimmers and of carnal knowledge of girls under the age of 15 in April, 1993.
He sought and won a controversial High Court judicial review in 1994 which quashed all the charges against him.
After this, he left Ireland for Edinburgh, Scotland and then the US.
Gibney was granted a visa during a visit to the United States in 1992 – seemingly aided by a Garda character reference – a year after people who had been abused by him started to speak up and organise themselves.
Readers may also recall how, in March 2015, it was reported that police in Colorado, America, investigated a complaint of sexual assault made by a young swimmer against Gibney in October 1995 – a year after the sexual abuse and rape charges against him were dropped in Ireland.
At the time of the complaint, Gibney was working as a coach in the North Jeffco Parks and Recreation District.
The Arvada Police Department in Colorado couldn’t establish if any crime had been committed.
Last month, US journalist Irvin Muchnick, of Concussion Inc, reported that the police officer who investigated the complaint made in North Jeffco was the mother of a swimmer at North Jeffco.
Further to this…
Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan has written to Shellie Pfohl, head of the new US Center for SafeSport, formally requesting an investigation of George Gibney.
Mr Muchnick reports:
“The center had told this reporter that it would undertake, at minimum, a preliminary investigation on the basis of third-party reports. Lawyers who work in the abuse field had advised that O’Sullivan was best situated to initiate the process.
“In her letter request to Pfohl, O’Sullivan cited two known incidents on American soil involving Gibney, the former Irish Olympic swimming head coach who fled to this country after being charged with 27 counts of indecent carnal knowledge of youth athletes in his charge.
“In the course of an Arvada police investigation of that incident, which might have been spurred at least in part by a complaint about the incident itself as well as information about his Irish past, Gibney was separated from the North Jeffco club and, apparently, did not coach again.
“However, he remains a resident alien in the US to this day, even though his 2010 application for citizenship appears to have been rejected on the grounds that he lied on it about past criminal charges in Ireland.
“Concussion Inc. has sought unsuccessfully for access to the 1995 Arvada police report from the department and the city manager.
“On April 12, a prominent First Amendment attorney in San Francisco, Karl Olson, of Cannata O’Toole Fickes Almazan, sent on our behalf a request for reconsideration of their denial to Mayor Marc Williams.
“Olson argued that the city has the discretion to release the material under the Colorado Criminal Justice Records Act, and urged it to do so in light of the passage of time, the fact that there was no criminal complaint or charge against Gibney and the matter is closed, and the narrative is of great public interest in the current Irish-American campaign on behalf of Gibney’s numerous victims.
“Arvada has acknowledged receiving the Olson letter and promised a response.
“In Irish legislator O’Sullivan’s other new move, she has confirmed that she also wrote on April 12 for the assistance of Congresswoman Diana DeGette of Colorado’s First District.
“DeGette, the Democrats’ chief deputy whip, is ranking minority member of the subcommittee of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, which is investigating the handling of the abuse issue by USA Swimming and other US Olympic Committee national sport governing bodies.
“O’Sullivan had appealed previously to Senator Dianne Feinstein of California, chief sponsor of the Safe Sport Act of 2018, and Congresswoman Jackie Speier of California, a leading voice of the “#MeToo movement” and the Democrats’ unofficial House of Representatives watchdog on the youth sports abuse problem. Speier referred the Gibney matter to the House Judiciary Committee.
“O’Sullivan’s letter to DeGette states in part: “I know there is tremendous work going on in the US in relation to uncovering the abuse of young people by their sports’ coaches and it is in that light that I am contacting you, hoping that this case of George Gibney be examined, especially due to your work with the House Energy and Commerce Committee investigating USA swimming.” Gibney’s victims, O’Sullivan added, “have been waiting a very long time.”
A newspaper committed to a Yes vote in the referendum on the Eighth Amendment.
Therese Caherty writes:
Tomorrow – May 1 – the Trade Union Campaign to Repeal the 8th launches a special edition referendum newspaper.
The 20-page tabloid carries articles by Prof Sabaratnam Arulkumuran, Judge Catherine McGuinness, Prof Veronica O’Keane, Deputies Brid Smith (PBP), Clare Daly (Ind4Change) and Louise O’Reilly (Sinn Fein), Parents Together for Yes, Catholics for Choice, Dr Peter Boylan and, most importantly, unions including the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, Unite the Union, Mandate, CWU Ireland, Connect, and SIPTU….
We see our publication as a significant resource for repeal canvassers and campaigners and for unsure voters who want more information to help them decide on May 25.
Vicky Phelan, her husband Jim and her solicitor Cian O’Carroll (in background)
Earlier this morning.
On RTÉ One’s Today With Seán O’Rourke.
Solicitor Cian O’Carroll, who represented Limerick mum-of-two Vicky Phelan in her recent High Court action, said he doesn’t trust the HSE’s position that just 206 women who developed cervical cancer after having a misdiagnosed smear test should have received earlier intervention.
Mr O’Carroll explained he cannot trust the figure because it was reached by the very same company that gave the wrong test results in the first place.
Readers will recall Ms Phelan was awarded €2.5 million in a settlement against Clinical Pathology Laboratories in Austin, Texas – which receives outsourced smear tests from Ireland – last week.
She was given a false negative smear test in 2011 and subsequently diagnosed with cervical cancer in 2014.
She was only informed of the 2011 misdiagnosis last year.
Ms Phelan now has terminal cancer.
During Today with Seán O’Rourke, Mr O’Carroll was asked what type of inquiry should be held into the matter.
He said:
“HIQA [Health Information and Quality Authority] is geared towards clinical standards and if the focus of this investigation is solely around clinical standards, that would be wrong.
“Because what’s happened here is well beyond that.
“This has got to do with corporate governance within Cervical Check, the HSE and the Department of Health.
“We have to find out why a direction was given to deceive the families of women who are dead and to deceive women who are now gravely ill. That was clearly done deliberately, having consciously considered what the plan would be to inform clinicians as to what they would do next and that’s clear from the correspondence we’ve seen and, of course, that letter from July 2016. I think an inquiry has to look at, first of all, the quality issue.
“What were the quality standards? Were they acceptable, benchmarked against international expected standards for cervical screening?
“That is a clinical governance issue.
“Secondly, there must be an inquiry, whether it’s part of that or by a separate agency, looking at the cover-up.
“Who was responsible? Who knew?
“And thirdly, related to Vicky Phelan, why is it that her case was fought so vigorously, even when the minister [for health Simon Harris] himself was informed about this case two or three days before it began?
“What was it about this case that they were so determined that she would be forced into a confidentiality clause that, through her courage, she ultimately defeated them on.
“Clearly, people in office knew that this case was going to cause serious trouble for people, in Cervical Check, the HSE and the Department of Health – enormous efforts and energy were put into forcing her to remain silent.”
“There are a lot of people out there who are very worried and a lot of people who feel, from their own experience, they’re telling a story that’s remarkably like Vicky Phelan’s and I think that’s why people are making contact [with him].
“They can see that they’ve had a diagnosis of cervical cancer after a history of clear smears.
“They haven’t been notified by anybody about a clinical audit. Now they’re expecting a telephone call.
“I wonder will they all get a phone call? Because I don’t trust this 206 figure.
“Remember the 206 cases – that ultimately comes from an analysis of cases performed by Med Lab which is the organisation that performed the screening of the smears in the first place.
“So Cervical Check thought it was appropriate to have the clinical audit and lookback performed by the very people who had done such an appalling job at reading the smears in the first place.”
“I would have thought that the 1,480 or so cases, that were identified, of women who had diagnosis or cervical cancer, following a clear smear – all 1,480 of those cases will have to be taken out and examined independently by cytologists.
“That’s not such an enormous task as it sounds – each slide, as I understand it, would take about five minutes to be correctly viewed and then reported on thereafter.
“But that’s the only way that it’s going to be, that trust for these figures will emerge.
“Because you cannot have a system where an organisation, no matter how conscientious they may be, clearly, there is a risk that their reporting would tend to way from liability against themselves.”
[To clarify, Med Lab did not carry out Ms Phelan’s original screening in 2011. This was performed by Clinical Pathology Laboratories in Austin Texas – whom Ms Phelan settled her High Court action against for €2.5 million last week. However, Med Lab and Clinical Pathology Laboratories are sister companies and have the same parent company, Sonic Healthcare.]
From top: Director General of the HSE Tony O’Brien and Minister for Health Simon Harris; Dr David Gibbons
This morning.
On RTÉ One’s Morning Ireland.
RTE’s Jackie Fox interviewed Dr David Gibbons, a former member of the National Cervical Screen Programme, who raised serious concerns about the outsourcing of cervical smear tests to US labs ten years ago.
He raised his concerns when he realised that the US lab tests were detecting fewer cases of cervical cancer than the tests done in Ireland.
When nothing changed as a consequence of him raising his concerns with the head of the HSE Tony O’Brien, he resigned.
But not before he warned health officials that there would be problems in ten years’ time – 2018.
David Gibbons: “From 2006, to 2008, I was the QA chair, the Quality Assurance chair of the Quality Assurance Committee for Cervical Cytology and Pathology in the Cervical Screening Programme, just as it was about to be rolled out. I was also running a large cytology screening laboratory in Dublin.”
Jackie Fox: “Now David, you had some concerns about the cervical screening programme. Tell me about them.”
Gibbons: “Well at that time, we had a backlog and we never sacrificed quality for [inaudible] and we had a backlog, due to under resourcing, the backlog was outsourced, some of it was outsourced to America. And when we got the smears back from America, we looked at their figures and they were finding significantly fewer high-grade dyslpasia [pre-cancerous changes] then we were in the same population. We were finding 1.8 per 100 and they were finding 1.2 – which was a third less.”
Fox: “So these are high-grade smears, is it?”
Gibbons: “High-grade smears. Predicting pre-cancer – the smears you’re trying to intercept.”
Fox: “OK, what are the differences between the US system and the Irish system?”
Gibbons: “The US system screens on a yearly basis and they do a quick screen every year so they get repeated bites at the cherry. In Ireland, the system was being set up for an every three years scheme. And a three-year scheme works. A three-year recall works, if you have a deep screen every three years. Our scientists were screening 25 to 30 cases a day, whilst the American scientists were screening 80 to 100, so they were screening three to four times as many in a day. So we were worried. With the figures we were getting back from America and with this mismatch of the systems, that there was going to be a problem. The three-year screening interval – it’s what they use in Britain – was the system we were introducing. But we were using an American screen for the three years but the American screen is repeated every year. So even though they screen quickly, they do it often. And we weren’t doing it often so we were having a substandard smear once every three years which lead to, which could potentially lead to problems.”
Fox: “Just to make it clear though as well. It wasn’t that there was an issue with the American system, it’s just that they do things differently compared to the Irish system?”
Gibbons: “Yeah, in the United States, they screen yearly. So the percentages of miss go down each year because you do it three times for each one time we were doing it here. The programme was based on a British system of a three-year screen but that would be based on a screen done as we were doing it in Ireland at the time, not based on a screen done as it was done in America at the time. The American system works for them but it’s just a different approach.”
Fox: “So what kind of results were you getting back then?”
Gibbons: “Well, when we got the figures back, at one point, we were getting one third of the high-grade cases that we were finding in our population, they were finding one third less – that was worrying for us. Now you might think we were finding too many, or we were over calling, but we were heavily audited and we doing positive [inaudible] for our cases and our cases were real. So they were finding too few.”
Fox: “What did you do about those concerns?”
Gibbons: “Well as QA, chair of the QA committee, I went to see Mr Tony O’Brien, who was at that time, heading up the Cervical Screening Programme and I met him in his office, there was one other person there, I can’t remember who it was.
“And I started off saying ‘lads, QA advisor’ and then I continued, I expressed those concerns and I said that over a ten-year period, this will cause problems and the problems won’t become apparent for ten years. And he dismissed my concerns.
“So, subsequently…I resigned then from the committee and the committee was composed of very talented scientists – all resigned as well.
“So then, representing the faculty of pathology, myself and three people who were running lab, went to see Tony O’Brien and there were two other people in the room on his side, to talk about our concerns about this outsourcing problem – to tell him that we thought it was dangerous, that we thought it could lead to problems, that the problems wouldn’t become apparent for ten years.
“They didn’t really address our concerns, they continued to push on with introducing this outsourcing – despite our advice.”
“So it went to the Dáil then, passed through the Dáil, but it became a political football, as democracy works, the majority pushed it through and unfortunately, this is where we’ve got to now.”
Fox: “Did you make any predictions, any estimates at the time of when these, when your concerns would become apparent?”
Gibbons: “We did, we estimated ten to 15 years and I don’t think we were wrong.”
Fox: “Did you make any predictions or estimates aswell on how many people might be affected?”
Gibbons: “We estimated from our figures, that we got back from America, that approximately 1,000 cases a year might be missed of high-grade dysplasia [pre-cancerous cells] but we couldn’t be at all certain. They were so many variables but that was our best estimate.”
Vicky Phelan is told by host Ray D’Arcy of the resignation of Dr Gráinne Flannelly from her position as the Clinical Director of CervicalCheck following the current controversy over smear test results.
Minister for Health Simon Harris and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar
RTE News reports:
RTÉ News has learned that an audit on the CervicalCheck controversy identified more than 12 women who have died.
It also found that around half of the 206 women affected were not told they may have had a delayed diagnosis and may have benefited from earlier treatment.
A serious incident management team is continuing to gather information from around 13 hospitals on the scale of the controversy.
More than 2,000 people had contacted the Health Service Executive helpline by last night.
A report on the affair is likely to be presented to the Director General of the HSE this evening.