
From top: Alison O’Connor (second left) on Claire Byrne Live on RTÉ One on February 14; Anthony Sheridan
Irish Examiner columnist Alison O’Connor found herself all alone on Valentine’s night last. Claire Byrne/RTÉ had invited her to participate in a discussion on the dramatic rise in Sinn Féin’s popularity.
As a favourite of the establishment media and strident anti-Sinn Féin commentator Ms. O’Connor probably expected that she would be joining the usual RTE anti-Sinn Fein panel.
But, amazingly, that didn’t happen, the panel was balanced and fair. O’Connor seemed to be genuinely confused with the situation. She began by telling the nation that, given how bad things are, even an opposition of chimpanzees would find it easy to pick it [the Government] off.
This crude and insulting political analysis was followed up with the usual tired guff about Sinn Fein being a ‘strange, cultish party’ that could cause a lot of offence if it got into power.
But then, O’Connor ran out of words. It was as if she suddenly realised that nobody was really listening to her, that they had heard it all before, and, of course they had, ad infinitum
So, in desperation, she did something that no establishment journalist has ever done before – she criticised RTE for imbalanced broadcasting, complaining:
“I would say about some of the debate I heard tonight…that there was some imbalance there. Listening to some of it you’d think we live in a banana republic and that’s not true… I think balance is important.”
O’Connor was confused because by the time she joined the panel, the anti-Sinn Féin side had been routed.
Passionate, articulate Sinn Féin members backed up by others such as Martin Ward and Tony Groves dismantled every argument put by supporters of the political establishment.
Property developer Michael Flynn’s condescending claim that people were being ‘over simplistic’ on the housing crisis, and Fine Gael TD Jennifer Carroll MacNeil’s defence of the private sector’s role in solving the crisis was torn to shreds by a well-informed opposition.
The opinions expressed by the eccentric financial advisor and failed politician Eddie Hobbs provided some light relief. Anybody tempted to take Hobbs seriously has only to recall that after co-founding the far-right party Renua Ireland, he refused to stand for election because he was too busy with other stuff.
And then there was the Fianna Fáil politician, Cllr. Briege Mac Oscar who said parties should be judged on their record. Let’s just repeat that – a Fianna Fáil politician thinks that parties should be judged on their record. Surely, if that was true, Fianna Fail would be struggling for its very survival…oh, wait.
So what happened in that RTÉ studio on Valentine’s night when Ms. O’Connor, at one point, found herself all alone in her titanic struggle against the evils of Sinn Féin?
Could it be that RTÉ was testing out a new producer who was unaware of the station’s long-established policy of packing discussion panels with anti-Sinn Féin commentators?
Or…could it be that the national broadcaster has finally conceded that Sinn Féin is a legitimate political party and the 500,000-plus citizens who voted for the party deserve a fair hearing?
Anthony Sheridan is a freelance journalist and blogs at Back Garden Philosophy