Anonymous writes;
THREE years waiting for an outpatient appointment for an infant (now 3 years of age). How much longer?
Anyone?
Simmer.
This morning/afternoon.
Leading chefs from around the country – including Dylan McGrath (top left) and Derry Clarke – gathered to support the ‘Kitchen Charter’ a practical initiative by Chef Network developed to “improve the working environment in professional kitchens throughout Ireland”.
Maybe stop SHOUTING at underlings like sweary crazy people.
It’s grub, not Vietnam.
FIGHT!
Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland
From top: Anastasia Kriégel; Ana’s parents Geraldine and Patrick Kriégel outside the Criminal Courts of Justice in Dublin this afternoon
This afternoon
Two 14-year-old boys have been found guilty of the murder of Ana Kriégel in Lucan just over a year ago.
The jury found the first boy murdered her by causing severe and extensive injuries to her head and neck. He was also convicted of violently sexually assaulting her.
The second boy lured the schoolgirl from her home, knowing what was going to happen, watched the assaults and covered up afterwards.
The boys were 13 at the time and had pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Let’s get ready to RUMBLE.
Stephen Hanlon tweetz:
Somebody actually created President Michael D Higgins in WWEgames. Amazing!
Secretary General of the Department of Public Expenditure Robert Watt
🚨 The Oireachtas finance committee has cancelled today’s meeting into the National Broadband Plan, after Dept of Public Expenditure sec-gen Robert Watt declined to attend… He says ministers and officials have attended already, and he’s going to the Comms committee next week
— Gavan Reilly (@gavreilly) June 18, 2019
… though I hear that, at the same time the Finance committee WOULD have been hearing from him in public session, Watt is also attending the Oireachtas Communications committee in private session!…
— Gavan Reilly (@gavreilly) June 18, 2019
Secretary General at the Department of Robert Watt previously called for the procurement process into the National Broadband Plan to be cancelled.
Despite his warning, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe signed off on it.
Meanwhile…
Yesterday…
Also looking forward to Robert Watt’s appearance in front of the Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform tomorrow afternoon and whether he will reveal any of his “career ending” views on the National Broadband Plan 👀
— Donal Palcic (@DonalPalcic) June 17, 2019
Hmmm.
Previously: ‘A Harvey Smith To The Committee’
From a report by University College Dublin Geography Associate Professor Gerald Mills
Associate Professor at University College Dublin’s geography department Gerald Mills has found there are more than 4,700 trees growing within a 20m wide corridor along the 16 bus routes earmarked for possible road-widening as part of the BusConnects project.
The project aims to deliver 230kms of dedicated bus lanes and 200kms of cycle tracks along 16 of the busiest roads in Dublin.
A synopsis….
Thousands of trees may face the chop to accommodate BusConnects routes (UCD)
From top: Ruth Morrissey, barrister Aisling Mulligan
This morning.
On RTÉ’s Morning Ireland with Audrey Carville.
Barrister Aisling Mulligan, who specialises in medical cases, spoke to Ms Carville about the State Claims Agency’s appeal in relation to the High Court case of Ruth Morrissey.
Ruth and her husband Paul Morrissey were awarded €2.1million damages last month over the misreading of smear tests and the failure to tell her about it.
Ms Morrissey claimed that if her smear tests in 2009 and 2012 had been correctly reported, she could have been successfully treated and not developed terminal cancer.
When the judgment was granted, Judge Kevin Cross said Ms Morrissey’s life had been ruined.
He also said that medical laboratory screeners should have “absolute confidence” that there are no abnormalities in a test slide before giving a test the all-clear.
The term “absolute confidence” was also used by Mr Justice John Peppet in an English Court of Appeal judgment called Penney Palmer & Canon in 1999.
The State Claims Agency has said it is appealing the judgment and focussing on “a number of important legal points that may have significant implications for the State” but not the award of €2.1million to the couple.
On Morning Ireland, Ms Mulligan told Ms Carville that Judge Cross’s judgment contains almost 200 paragraphs and is an extremely detailed judgment.
She pointed out that, in paragraph of 15 of the judgment, he says that no testing is infallible.
Ms Mulligan said:
“He goes on to use the really practical example that we found in Mrs Morrissey’s case where, in 2014, she was diagnosed with cancer while receiving treatment but actually one of her screenings came back as negative.
“So that’s one of the practical examples that nobody asserted that there was negligence even though there was an outcome that was in fact incorrect.
“And that’s a really important thing for the general public to realise, that while the sentence ‘absolute confidence’ seems to be causing people an awful lot of concern; that this is going to close off the concept of cervical screening and, indeed, other screening.
“It’s very clear that, within the judgment and within the case itself, that there was an acknowledgement that there is always an aspect of limitation from the use of cervical screening.”
Ms Mulligan went on to say:
“The test of ‘absolute confidence’ is I suppose it finds its basis in Penney, in theory, but in reality what Judge Cross has identified in his judgment is: what do the medical practitioners set as their test for their standard of care?
“And it appears to me, at least, having looked at what he has determined as facts, is that there were five different witnesses who accepted that absolute [confidence] was the test that the medical professionals…was what was required of the appropriately qualified medical practitioner.
“And what follows from that argument is that it’s not absolute confidence that you do have cancer, it is absolute confidence that, if there is something on the screen, that it’s followed up on, that it is escalated.
“And that is the extent to which the test applies.
“….so if there is a grey area, if there is room for uncertainty, the question that the reasonable practitioner has to ask themselves is: am I certain that there’s nothing there?
“If the answer to that is ‘no’, I should refer on.”
Ms Carville asked Ms Mulligan if screening suffered as a consequence of the Penney judgment in the UK.
She said:
“I’m a lawyer and I’m not a healthcare expert so I would be careful not to draw, not to extrapolate too much but one of the comments that has been identified is that there were different problems in Penney and I think that’s probably true.
“There was a different factual nexus in Penney to what we have in Mrs Morrissey’s case. The relevance of that, I suppose, is whether or not it closed off screening in the UK.
“Respectfully, it hasn’t, the result hasn’t occurred.
“Whether it will happen here is a question that will have to be seen in reality.
“But the purpose of this judgment is to reinforce…the certainty that people have in cervical screening.”
In reference to the State Claims Agency that the appeal won’t affect Ms Morrissey’s award of €2.1million, Ms Mulligan said she’s not sure if the sum can be ringfenced before adding:
“There have been circumstances where appeals have gone over to superior courts on technical points after the other side have been, after the applicant, who has won their case, has been allowed to continue.
“I’ve not seen it on a financial basis. So it depends on two-fold: what are the State appealing, which we’re not clear on at this stage.
“What are the second and third defendants [two labs] appealing, which we’re not clear on, at this stage.
“And then the second question is: what will Mrs Morrissey’s position be.
“If the State were to indemnify, for example, Mrs Morrissey, that may result in a different, it may make it easier for the case to go forward on, I suppose, a point of public importance.
“But I have seen examples of where it has happened but not one where the issue of quantum or the issue of payout or compensation or financial settlement has been determined.
“I’m not familiar with one so we’re sort of in uncharted territory respectfully.”
Listen back in full here
Yesterday: State Appeal
From top: Bill Clinton’s portrait; from left Denis O’Brien, artist Colin Davidson and Mr Clinton at its unveiling yesterday
As does the nose strangely.
Yesterday.
Clinton Foundation HQ, Manhattan, New York.
Standing beside the painting, Bill Clinton said: “This actually captures a part of my personality I often try to keep hidden because I try always to be upbeat, I always try to be positive I always to think that the best is around the corner.”
…Irish businessman Denis O’Brien was among the guests at the function and he was thanked for supporting the role of the Clinton Foundation in a number of countries.
FBI Agents (out of picture).
Clinton moved by a ‘very Irish portrait’ Tommie Gorman, RTÉ)
Previously: Shaky Foundation
Pics: RTE
This afternoon.
Sandymount Strand
Love Hate’s Johnny Ward ‘launches’ LloydsPharmacy Heart Health Hubs, as part of its charity partnership with the Irish Heart Foundation.
60 LloydsPharmacies are now Heart Health Hubs, focusing on “cardiovascular risk assessments, lifestyle advice and blood pressure checks”.
No free balloons.
Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland
Save Poolbeg.