Author Archives: Bodger

Claire McGettrick, co-founder of the Adoption Rights Alliance

There is an unhelpful and wholly inaccurate paradigm encompassing the discourses around adoption in Ireland, which assumes that adopted people and natural mothers are on opposite sides, engaged in an almighty war around privacy.

On one side you have the needy adopted person, and on the other, the natural mother who is terrified of her adult child coming back into her life.

An adopted person’s right to information about themselves and contact with natural family are entirely separate issues.

Adopted people want the same access to their personal data as every other Irish citizen; no adopted person is demanding the right to a relationship.

Moreover, not all adopted people want contact with natural family members, and in fact, a significant number of natural mothers wish to seek out their adult children but feel powerless to do so.

Evelyn Mahon’s claim (“Women who gave up their children for adoption should not be made to suffer twice,” Opinion & Analysis, July 4th) that the institution of adoption is based on “the welfare principle of the best interests of the child” is entirely at odds with the archival evidence and testimony of human rights abuses gathered by Dr Maeve O’Rourke and myself as part of the multi-award winning Clann Project.

Ireland’s closed, secret, forced adoption system was not child-centred, nor was it rooted in anything resembling a feminist ethos: natural mothers insist they were forced to swear that they would never contact their children again.

There is no evidence that natural mothers sought or were guaranteed secrecy from their children, and in practice such a guarantee could never have been given as birth registrations have been public records since 1864.

It is long past time to move on from the myth that adopted people and natural mothers are competing against each other for privacy rights.

It is inaccurate, offensive, and damages our efforts to address the injustices against women and children in 20th-century Ireland.

Claire McGettrick,
Co-founder, Adoption Rights Alliance,
Irish Research Council
Postgraduate Scholar,
UCD School of Sociology,
Dublin 4.

Adoption and the right to information (The Irish Times letters page)

Previously: With Philomena

Update:

Border between Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland

Dara Doyle, of Bloomberg, reports:

Ireland is set to acknowledge publicly for the first time the need to set up checks at or around its border with Northern Ireland in a no-deal Brexit scenario, people familiar with the matter said.

The government will accept that checks, especially on livestock, will be required at least close to the frontier if the U.K. crashes out of the European Union when it publishes no-deal contingency plans on Tuesday, the people said, asking not to be identified because the plans haven’t yet been discussed with cabinet.

…The European Commission has pushed the Irish government to lay out its plans for the border in a no-deal Brexit, a person familiar with the matter said earlier this year. Ireland was proving elusive when the Commission has attempted to pin down the government on its plan, according to the person.

Irish to Accept Need for Border Checks in a No-Deal Brexit (Bloomberg)

Pic: Bloomberg

UPDATE:

UPDATE:

In respect of its article, Bloomberg has added:

“The location of any checks is still to be determined, one of the people said.

“An earlier version of this story said the government would accept that checks would have to be at or close to the border.

“A spokesman for Foreign Affairs Minister Simon Coveney said that was “incorrect.” Updated contingency plans will be published in full later Tuesday, after the cabinet has had its discussion, the spokesman said.”

Irish Said to Accept Need for Checks in No-Deal Brexit (Bloomberg)

Ireland’s EU Commissioner Phil Hogan with Leo Varadkar in 2012

There had been some speculation in recent days that the former Fine Gael minister and election organiser might lose out due to the anger of Irish farmers over the EU-Mercosur draft deal allowing large quantities of South American meat into European markets.

But today the Cabinet is expected to give the former Kilkenny TD the nod for another five years in the post, which has a salary package of €300,000 per year.

Phil Hogan left Irish politics during recessionary times in 2014, as his name was associated with two new taxes, the ill-starred domestic water charges and the local property tax.

Hogan set to be renominated as EU commissioner (John Downing, Independent.ie)

Rollingnews

Last night.

Dungannon, County Tyrone.

10,000 pallets.

Meanwhile, across the county…

Mickey Harte Apologises After Players Filmed Singing Rebel Song In Front Of Parade (Balls.ie)

Judge Iarfhlaith O’Neill

This afternoon.

A judge has concluded that the State has misinterpreted a ruling by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and in doing so has denied victims of child sexual abuse access to a redress scheme to which they are entitled.

In a decision that will be welcomed by survivors, Judge Iarfhlaith O’Neill has ruled that the State’s interpretation represents:”a fundamental unfairness to applicants” and involves “an inherent inversion of logic”, because of its insistence that survivors of sex abuse in primary schools need to prove that there was a complaint made to authorities about their abuser before their abuse took place.

….Figures revealed by RTÉ News earlier this year showed that out of 50 applicants to the scheme no applicant has been successful, and that all of the cases refused have been declined on the grounds of a failure to show evidence of a prior complaint….

Judge rules State misinterpreted ECHR abuse ruling (RTÉ)

Pic via Juris Resolutions

Outside New York Fedaral Court today

This afternoon.

Manhattan, New York City.

An indictment charging Jeffrey Epstein with sexually trafficking multiple underage girls was unsealed in federal court in New York City today, the latest twist in a decade-old legal saga.

The charging document says Epstein, from 2002 to at least 2005, enticed girls as young as 14 to come to his estates in Manhattan and Palm Beach for what were supposed to be massages. Instead, he induced them to engage in sex acts, according to the indictment.

Epstein would pay the girls hundreds of dollars in cash after the encounters, then, in what resembled a sexual pyramid scheme, he would allegedly pay them more to recruit other young girls to perform similar acts

Sex trafficking charges against Jeffrey Epstein unveiled (Miami Herald)

The fresh move against Epstein follows on the failure of Alexander Acosta, now Trump’s labor secretary but then a Miami federal prosecutor, to bring Epstein to court on a 53-page indictment by cutting a widely criticized plea deal that was seen as far too lenient….

…Flight logs from Epstein’s private jet showed that former president Bill Clinton took at least 26 trips aboard the plane between 2001 and 2003 – the same period from which the new charges are believed to stem

Epstein sexual abuse casecould push powerful friends into spotlight (The Guardian)

Pic: Getty

Meanwhile…

Philomena Lee (above fourth right) with members of the Tuam Mother and Baby Home Alliance at the grave  (top) of Philomena’s son Michael Hess (born Anthony) 

Yesterday.

Sean Ross Abbey, Roscrea, County Tipperary.

Tuam survivors joined the annual pilgrimage taken by Philomena Lee a to commemorate her forcibly-adopted son ‘Anthony’.

Anthony was sold to an American couple and he arranged to be buried at the Abbey in the hope that his mother would find his grave.

Philomena’s story was dramatised in a 2013 film starring Judi Dench,

Breeda Murphy, of the Tuam and Baby Home Alliance, writes:

We attended the Memorial yesterday at Sean Ross where Philomena was in attendance with her daughter Jane. She truly is an incredible lady. Returning year on year to speak at the event remembering her beloved son, Anthony known as Michael Hess who is buried on the site.

Meanwhile…

Pics: Breeda Murphy

From top: Siteserv now Actavo offices in west Dublin; David McCourt

Yesterday.

In The Sunday Times, Justice McCarthy reported:

David McCourt, whose company Granahan McCourt is the state’s preferred bidder for the €5bn national broadband plan, has also been contacted as a witness by Cregan [Commission [looking into the sale of Siteserv to Denis O’Brien].

Granahan McCourt was involved in a bid to buy Siteserv subsidiary companies in 2012 along with the Gores Group, a Californian private equity company.

“Several months ago, the Cregan Commission sent a list of questions, which Granahan McCourt replied to in full to assist with their investigation,” the company said. “[We were] not the bidder in the sale process — it was led by the Gores Group, which we understand also assisted with the investigation.”

Meanwhile…

Karl Brophy, a public relations consultant, has been called as a witness by the Siteserv inquiry to answer allegations made by Denis O’Brien that he leaked the businessman’s banking information to politicians and journalists.

Brophy, the chief executive of Red Flag, a PR and lobbying company, has told the Cregan Commission that he did not give anyone information about O’Brien’s dealings with IBRC and never had the information to give.

READ IN FULL: Red Flag boss Karl Brophy to face Siteserv inquiry over Denis O’Brien leak allegations (Justine McCarthy, The Sunday Times)

Previously: What’s Another Year

Last night.

Marley Park, Rathfarnham, Dublin

Dressed for the beach rapper Cardi B closes the Longitude Festival with a tribute to Baphomet.

She could use a cardi.

In that cold.

Never mind.

Friday: Meanwhile, At Longitude

Okurr?

Pics: Anamaria Meiu/AM Photo Star via Photocall ireland