Yearly Archives: 2016
Too Soon?
atNorthern Ireland Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness who called for a ‘border poll’ in the North following the Brexit result
Recent speculation about a referendum in Northern Ireland on reunification of the island has sent a shiver up my spine. A divisive referendum in Northern Ireland alienating both sides further is not what anybody needs right now.
A referendum result in favour of reunification would stress the political system in the South at a time when we need to deal with Brexit in an undistracted way. To paraphrase Augustine of Hippo: Lord, grant me chastity, continence and a united Ireland, but not yet.
Tom O’Rourke,
Gorey,
Co Wexford.
Border poll (Irish Times letters)
Previously: Please Note Your Nearest Exit
From top: Independents 4 Change TD Mick Wallace in the Dáil last night and Irish Times deputy political editor Pat Leahy
Further to last night’s debate on Independents 4 Change TD Mick Wallace’s bill to allow for terminations in Ireland in the case of fatal foetal abnormality – a bill which has been deemed unconstitutional by the Attorney General Máire Whelan.
Pat Leahy, deputy political editor of the Irish Times, spoke to Seán O’Rourke on RTÉ Radio One this morning.
During their discussion, Mr Leahy insisted that, having seen Ms Whelan’s advice, it is ‘utterly unconstitutional’.
He also suggested that if the Government doesn’t accept Ms Whelan’s advice, she may have to step down.
Readers may note that Mr Wallace has called for the advice to be published – to allow for a debate on the advice.
From the interview…
Pat Leahy: “At present the Government is unable to reach a collective position on Mick Wallace’s bill which was debated in the Dáil yesterday evening but won’t be voted on until next Thursday. And normally what would happen is with a private members bill like this, the Government would oppose it or not oppose it. But normally would oppose it, put down a countermotion and Government TDs would be whipped into voting for the countermotion or the amendment but, at its meeting last Tuesday, the Government was unable to reach a decision. Now, constitutionally, legally, the Government must act with collective authority. That means that it must, all its members must agree to act and speak as one…”
Sean O’Rourke: “I’ve just happened to find that article 28 in Bunreacht na hÉireann, it says, one, well it says, ‘the Government shall be responsible to Dáil Éireann’ and then, ‘the Government shall meet and act as a collective authority and shall be collectively responsible for the departments of state, administered by members of the Government.’
Leahy: “Yeah. And at present in relation to this issue, the Government is unable to do that. And that’s despite having been advised by its chief law officer and legal advisor, the Attorney General, that the bill that Mick Wallace has put before the Dail is unconstitutional. And I’ve seen that advice, I wrote about it in the Sunday Business Post last year and again recently in the Irish Times, and that advice is utterly unequivocal, it’s not, ‘on the balance of probabilities, this is probably unconstitutional’. It’s completely unequivocal that, it couldn’t be stronger that the bill is unconstitutional. And despite that clear advice, the Government is unable to come to a collective position on that.”
O’Rourke: “Why?”
Leahy: “Because the Independent Alliance members want a free vote. Now it’s my understanding that the Independent Alliance members of the Cabinet are prepared to sign up, if you like, to a collective decision to oppose this bill. But they want to be allowed the right to abstain on it themselves. Now that sounds slightly constitutionally shaky to me but it may be a way out. And, ultimately, if you were to ask me, I suspect that that’s the way out that will be found. As of yesterday, I’m told, that the Taoiseach and Sarah Bardon writes about this in our paper [Irish Times] today, the Taoiseach was absolutely firm that that would be impossible. That having been advised by the Attorney General, the Government must follow his advice and ministers must act in accordance with that advice.”
Later – after Mr O’Rourke played clips of Fine Gael TD Kate O’Connell speaking during last night’s debate and Independent Alliance TD John Halligan speaking earlier today on RTÉ’s Morning Ireland
Leahy: John Halligan gave a very powerful speech last night in the Dáil. Not the first powerful speech he’s given on this subject and there was motions on this in the last Dáil as well and it’s peroration was that he didn’t care what the Attorney General’s advice does, sorry, didn’t care if it was unconstitutional. Anyone who was there last night or anyone who was watching last night, couldn’t have been in any doubt other than he’s certainly, if he’s not going to vote for this, he’s certainly not going to vote against it. I think that presents him with a problem.”
O’Rourke: “Here’s a question and I’m just wondering, I’m no constitutional lawyer but is John Halligan part of the Government in the sense of being part of the Cabinet, he’s not?”
Leahy: “No, he’s not. No, he’s not. He’s not. The Government in the constitution, we use it as a generic term to mean everybody in Government buildings and so forth.”
O’Rourke: “So could it not be said, look he’s not in the Cabinet, so he’s not, he doesn’t have the same constitutional responsibility, we’ll cut him a bit of slack. On the other hand, it’s very bad, is it not, for political discipline?”
Leahy: “That deal could perhaps, maybe that’s what happens. But he’s got a slight problem with the programme for Government that he spoke about there and in the programme for Government it says that where the Government reaches a decision that all members and office holders specifically, and he is an office holder, are bound to support that decision. Now, so under the terms of that, under the terms of the programme for Government…”
O’Rourke: “That’s where his difficulty will lie…”
Leahy: “If the Government decides that to oppose this bill, and that depends on the independent ministers in Cabinet, resiling from their opposition to that collective decision being made, then he’s got…but there’s another problem here I think Sean, which is that if this is let slide and the Government does not reach a position on it, I think that’s a very serious situation for the Attorney General, whose advice to the Government is unequivocal. Now if the Government is unable to follow that advice, I think it probably puts her in a more or less untenable position.”
O’Rourke: “You think she might resign if the Government doesn’t stick by and accept the Taoiseach’s insistence, they have to vote against this…”
Leahy: “If the Government doesn’t take the Attorney General’s advice on an issue such as this then it would be hard to know what the Attorney General is for…”
Listen back in full here
Previously: ‘You Allow An Unconstitutional Bill On Property Rights But Not Women’s Rights?’
Skinny Downers – ex-bedroom project turned electronic duo comes home
What you may need to know…
01. The latest incarnation of Skinny Downers is a two-piece based in Berlin. A far cry from the project’s beginnings as a few instruments and a loop pedal somewhere in Waterford.
02. Founded by Dean O’Sullivan, formerly of the Deise’s Black Robots and Percolator, the project quickly shape-shifted to a live collective, to a band, to a duo, fronted by Sardinian punk performance artist Stella Sesto.
03. Streaming above is the band’s newest EP, Kill Figures, released in April of this year.
04. Catch them tomorrow night in Cork at The Kino, in a BYOB affair also featuring local lads Land Crabs and Kinsale’s Foreign Bodies.
Verdict: Oddly groovy, moody, sparse alternative with tinges of noise and electronica.
Quite possibly.
FIGHT!
Jeremy Banx in today’s Financial Times.
Thanks Reppy
Meanwhile…
Adrift by Conor Ryan.
John Horan writes:
Really cool short film some Swedish friends of mine [including Nami Kawakita] made while on a visit to Dublin.
The Woodlands Caravan Park, Tralee, Co Kerry
Have ye opened up da’van?
How did it get on over the winter?
So are ye down now?
This is Caravan Park Talk.
Frilly Keane writes:
You’re either are a caravan person or yer not. I am, with over 40 years ov’it in fact, from my mother’s ‘van in Ardmore, to my own-ie-oh one now; which it must be said, is a bit closer to sunny South Central.
Things have changed since those days in Ardmore, ‘vans now have indoor toilets, so no more bucket or key to the toilet block. Indoor plumbing also means that there’s no more running out to the tap to fill the kettle, the pot, the bucket, to wash your teeth or rinse the dishes.
The whinging about being asked to go out to the tap is another one of those things that are no more, yet somehow is still there to be missed; like the smell of the match lighting the gas under the kettle or toast done under a gas grill.
And the all up and beds put away before an egg gets boiled or fried is gone too.
Go into a ‘van today and you’ll see microwaves, tellys, fancy coffee machines, fridge freezers, and I’ll even admit to having a dish washer in mine. FFS.
So let me help out the non-caravan’er reading this and clue them in a bit.
Originally all caravans were the ones you see on the M11 trying to pull in front of ya. But then around the early ta’ mid 80’s there was a conversion that sounded like this;
“Is it a mobile home or a caravan you have?”
So now on the caravan parks plotted around our coast line you’ll pretty much see them filled with mobile homes, but to caravan people, they are still ‘vans.
The others, the ones spreading all over the lane in front of ya are, for the want of a more ideal explanation, touring ‘vans.
A few weekends ago I called down to my old site, as in me Mam’s, to make sure all “the jobs” were done. These are the opening up jobs; airing the mattresses, cleaning off mould, washing the outside of the ‘van, getting steps repaired, making up the beds, that kinda stuff.
On her site the pals I knocked around with every summer from when I was 4 ish ‘till my late teens, now all have their own vans on that same site. They’ve all turned into their Mams and Dads.
The striking thing about the dolling up of ‘vans over the years, and the staying power of caravan people through falling outs, bad spells & immigration, increased rents and fees, the rain and the rain and the muck and the wind and the rain, is not that one great heatwave in every ten years, nor is it the home from home comforts now assumed; it’s caravan people.
And every site is the same.
Whether it’s the Hot Tub Set in the pricey posh ones with decks the size and function of the Parade Ring in Leopardstown, or the scattery sprawling of wagons of every shape and size with gas bottles like bollards looking to take your toenail off, and droopy washing lines from window to window.
Caravan people are the same.
Who got new cars,Who got away to Spain/ Portugal etc over the Easter Who lost their job t’ who’s changed job, who’s done well etc. Who’s aged, who’s lost weight (don’t look at me btw.), Who’s got new stuff, like kayaks, ribs, boards etc to shove under the ‘van or leave on a trailer blocking someone’s way.
The almighty one; the one weeping across every site over the last few wee… who got a new ‘van.
Tis gas. Once the vans are opened up, the residents do their annual sizing up of each other, including the kids by the way; but by the end of the first week of the season ‘tis like they were never apart for the last 10 months.
That is until the Leaving results come out, then there is a similar staying in-close-quarters with Mammies answering every enquiry with a “got what they wanted.”
Another thing in caravan parks is the big entrance. This is the crowd that arrive and open up mid-season. The crowd that were away; Italy, Florida, France, a Cruise, etc in June/ early July.
That’s their new ‘van moment. These are the same that might also be seen to lock up mid-August because they’re off ta’ Italy, Florida, France, a Cruise etc.
Again every site has them. From Bettystown to Ballybunion.
The falling outs: these usually have to do with your particular site and your on-site behaviour: parking your car too close to next door, loud music, parties, dogs, teenagers, crying babies, gazebos and umbrellas, hedges – that kinda stuff. The other one is your location: is your spot better than theirs.
In pretty much every coastal site there is a Front. It’s so important to ‘van people it’s getting a capital F. Back then, in Ardmore, the Front was also known as Flamingo Road, and everyone else was Coronation Street.
Now if you are on family owned site and go season to season only with the permission of the ‘insert name of the owners’ then who gets on that Front is the stuff that elects Party Leaders,
(BTW every year these sites have a family, or for ‘van people ‘a crowd’ who are put off the site.)
If you are on a Resident Owned site, you simply pay for your spot on the Front, when one comes up that is, and the buyer is usually someone already on the site, and there usually tends to be a bitta non-transparency about the transaction.
Interestingly or to be expected I suppose, the selling price of these sites and ‘vans are a prominent feature of these caravan parks, or resorts as they like to be known as.
Either way, both set-ups manage new arrivals the same. What yer man does, what schools the kids go to, and are there babies and young kids. That can make or break someone’s entry into the ‘van crowd on that particular site. Are your kids nice, are they crying squalling kids, and are ye well off.
I hope there are more ‘van people about here, because I’d love to hear yere stories. Like when ye got the fridge that worked off the car battery, or the portable telly and half the site in ta’ watch the Royal Wedding, or using the local pub’s hot water tap and hand dryer for your wash and blow before the disco.
Or the free ‘van day when the Mammies went up to Cork to get the shopping and washing sorted, or the school books and uniforms.
Or the gas bulb catching fire after you’d had a feed of cider and were too afraid to get help from the adults; all that kinda stuff.
Anyway, I wanted to do this piece for the last while, because it’s part of my thing and it’s already been established that I’m not about July and August. Also, this weekend is when 90% of the ‘vans of Ireland commence their next tour of duty.
It is also that time for year for the Sindo to get a hard on about the Dublin Hamptons set and for a certain Solicitor of the same name, no relation, to come into his wankiest element.
Meh, lay’ve them at it, my ‘van is just my other home really, this year the Broad Band Man has set me up so I can still work without complications, and commute handily enough. The ‘van survived annuder Winter without leaving me with too many jobs to get done, it’s already open so I’m off.
I’ll sign off with the promise of an Irish caravan’er.
The rain’s warmer this time of year.
Frilly Keane’s column appears here every Friday. Follow Frilly on Twitter: @frillykeane
The City of London
What happens to Britain’s big banks
If they exit? Well let’s ask the yanks
We won’t get as much
As the mercantile Dutch
We’ll get something, for which we’ll give thanks.
John Moynes
Pic: Bigstock
What you may need to know:
1. The story of Chelsey “Sully” Sullenberger (Tom Hanks), the pilot who landed an Airbus A320 with 155 passengers on the Hudson River in 2009..
2. The Man with No Name directs the Man from Fed Ex.
3. This all-American biopic from Hanks and Clint Eastwood might come to the attention of Oscar voters.
4. Next year, members of the Academy will include Idris Elba John Boyega and, um, Ice Cube (there’s one vote in the bag for Kevin Hart in Ride Along 2).
5. There are nearly as many T-Hanx stories as there are Murricane stories. The Hanx ones are true.
6. Broadsheet prognosis: Oscar calling.
Release Date: December 2.
(Mark writes about film and TV at ScreenTime.ie)
In this latest instalment of their ‘100 years of Fashion’ series, Mode showcases the TARDIS of personal luggage, inside and out.














