Author Archives: Bodger

This morning.

Government Buildings, Dublin 2

Fine Gael TDs respond to the alternative budgets presented by opposition parties a day ahead of the actual budget.

Hey, it’s a gig.

from left: Kate O’Connell TD (Member of the Public Accounts Committee), Peter Burke TD (Member of the on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform Committee and the Public Accounts Committee) and Colm Brophy TD (Chairman of the Budgetary Oversight Committee).

 Leah Farrell/RollingNews.ie

From top: IGB logo; the site of the former greyhound stadium in Harold’s Cross, Dublin 6; a valuation of the site by the Valuation Office and one taken by Savills

This morning.

In The Times Ireland edition.

Seán McCárthaigh reported that the €23 million the Government paid to buy the former greyhound stadium in Harold’s Cross, Dublin was “almost twice the value placed on it by consultants acting for its owners”.

In documents obtained by Mr McCárthaigh, under the Freedom of Information Act, he has found that…

On Monday, March 20, 2017…

Savills carried out a valuation of the site for the Irish Greyhound Board – which owned the site – and valued it at €10million to €12million.

Subsequent to Savills’ valuation, but also in March 2017,  the Irish Greyhound Board’s directors “expressed ‘disappointment’ at Savills’ valuation at a board meeting”.

Then, on Friday, April 10, 2017…

The Valuation Office inspected the site of the former greyhound stadium on Harold’s Cross Road, Dublin 6 – at the request of the Department of Education – and they valued it at €23million.

The sale of the site to the Department of Education for €23million was agreed in May 2017.

Mr McCárthaigh reports:

“The Department of Education bought the land at Harold’s Cross last year from the Irish Greyhound Board (IGB) to build much-needed schools in an area of Dublin with a growing young population.

“The department agreed to pay €23 million, but records obtained by a freedom of information request show that Savills, the estate agents working for the greyhound board, had valued the land at €12 million if it was going to be used for housing and €6 million without any change to its zoning status as land for recreational amenities.

“Land used for schools would generally cost the same or less than land used for housing.

At the time IGB, otherwise known as Bord na gCon, had debts of more than €21 million and the money provided by the department exceeded this amount.”

Good times.

Government ‘paid double for Harold’s Cross race track’ (Seán McCárthaigh, The Times Ireland edition)

FANGS

‘Count’-ing down to the Bram Stoker Festival (October 26-29), Ireland’s only neck-chomping podcast delivers Dracula re-animated.

Host Liam Geraghty writes:

In episode 2 of FANGS, we chat to cultural historian David J. Skal about the Harry Clarke Dracula illustrations that could have been…

…Vampirina Ballerina author Anne Marie Pace talks about creating a vampire book when you’re a scaredy-cat and Disney director Norton Virgien talks about adapting that book into an animated series in Brown Bag Films, Smithfield…

…We’ll also be ducking into the history of the cult British animated series Count Duckula with curator Georgia Taylor Aguilar and illustrator Steve Simpson who worked on the show as well as chatting with illustrator Debbie Jenkinson about the upcoming Gothic Graphic Novel Live at Bram Stoker Festival…

We’re strangely drawn.

*removes dentures*

I’ll get my cape.

Bram Stoker Festival

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=2&v=iQynxWwO0Gw

Last night.

On Dublin’s O’Connell Street.

Tom Duffy, a volunteer from Feed Our Homeless, recorded a live Facebook video claiming a woman in her 70s was sleeping outside Starbuck’s and that her son, in his late 30s or early 40s, was “wrapping her up like a baby” for the night.

In the video, Tom said:

“There’s a man, in his, I’d say, mid to late-30s, and he is now, at the moment, wrapping his 74-year-old mother in sleeping bags. And thank God, we had one sleeping bag left. We gave them an extra sleeping bag.

“…He’s tucking his 72, I think he said 72, or 74 years of age, mother. He’s wrapping her up there like a baby. This is 2018 on one of the busiest streets in Ireland. And no one seems to give a continental about it…”

Tom Duffy (Facebook)

This afternoon.

Outside Leinster House.

People Before Profit TDs Richard Boyd Barrett, Bríd Smith, Gino Kenny and PBP member and economist Brian O’Boyle launch their pre-Budget submission ‘Recovery For All’.

Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe will deliver Budget 2019 tomorrow in the Dáil at 1pm.

Mícheál Lehane, of RTÉ, reports:

People Before Profit has proposed spending an additional €2.9 billion to build social and affordable homes next year as part of its pre-Budget submission.

The party also wants to make all public transport free, which it says would cost €580 million annually and help reduce both CO2 emissions and traffic congestion.

Under its plan the party says that €3bn could be allocated to develop a National Health Care System that would include free GP care.

The party believes the Universal Social Charge and the Local Property Tax should be scrapped.

PBP want €2.9bn for affordable housing in Budget (RTE)

Leah Farrell/Rollingnews.ie

Yesterday.

Presidential hopeful Seán Gallagher explained why he wants the job.

Previously: How Was It For You?

Social Democrats TD Catherine Murphy, Minister for Communications Denis Naughten, and minutes of a meeting between Mr Naughten and David McCourt

This morning.

Social Democrats TD Catherine Murphy has called for time to be allocated in the Dáil this week to allow for the Minister for Communications Denis Naughten to make a statement and answer questions about the tendering process for the National Broadband Plan contract.

There is only one bidder up for the contract – a consortium which includes Denis O’Brien-owned Actavo, formerly known as Siteserv.

The consortium is led by a private investment firm called Granahan McCourt.

Last week it emerged that David McCourt, of Granahan McCourt, met with the Mr Naughten in New York last July.

During this meeting, Mr McCourt informed Mr Naughten that the British company SSE may withdraw from the consortium which it eventually did.

Mr Naughten also told the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Communications last week that he had “a number of discussions with David McCourt about this project”.

In a statement this morning, Ms Murphy said:

“We know that the Minister met Mr McCourt in New York yet the version of events he gave during the Oireachtas Communications Committee hearing does not tally with the version detailed in the minutes of the meeting released by his Department late on Thursday evening last.

“Apart from that glaring variation of events, the Minister, in the committee testimony, refers to having met with Mr McCourt on the issue of the NBP on ‘a number of occasions’.

“I urgently want clarity on the nature of these discussions – particularly given the revelations of how other bidders feel they were treated during the process.”

“With the Budget consuming a lot of time and attention this week I feel it is hugely important that this vital issue is not allowed to fall of the political radar.

“We are dealing with one of the most important State contracts that will ever be awarded and any sniff of impropriety or bad governance must be met with significant urgency and robust questioning until we are satisfied the process to date has been as it should be.

“That is why I have formally requested that the Government Chief Whip provide time this week for the minister to address the Dáil and take questions – as he did last April when similar concerns were raised about his interaction with key stakeholders in a business decision his department had a role in.”

Related: State broadband bidder Granahan McCourt sued for contract breach (Justine McCarthy, The Sunday Times)

Previously: “Here We Are Again”

McCourt In The Act

A ‘Robust’ Tendering Process

Emma Mhic Mathúna with her solicitor Cian O’Carroll at the High Court in June

This morning.

Following the death of mother-of-five and cervical cancer victim Emma Mhic Mhathúna, 37.

Emma’s solicitor Cian O’Carroll spoke to Seán O’Rourke on RTÉ Radio One.

In June, Emma sued both the HSE and the US laboratory which studied her smear tests, Quest Diagnostics, and agreed a settlement of €7.5 million.

Quest Diagnostics misread her two smear slides in 2010 and 2013 and she was diagnosed with cervical cancer in 2016.

Some 221 women have been affected by the CervicalCheck controversy.

Further to this.

Mr O’Carroll has asked why all of the errors haven’t been investigated.

He told Mr O’Rourke:

If you wanted to have a confidence in a laboratory, you must know that each error is investigated. And we’ve spoken to cervical screening experts around the world involved in Canada, Finland, New Zealand and the UK.

And they have all said to us here that it is essential that whenever a single critical error occurs that it’s investigated within the laboratory and that involves debriefing the person who made the error and finding out what caused it.

And that has never been done.

[Emma] was adamant all the way through that she wanted accountability. She was adamant all the way through that errors must be stopped. She said that so much money had to be paid by the laboratory would hopefully make them be more careful in future with screening.

But the State, the National Screening Service, has a primary obligation and, under the contract, they have the right to send in HIQA to investigate why those errors happened in those laboratories and they have an obligation to do it under normal standards of public health and public safety.

They haven’t done it.

…If you are going to have an analytical process, a scientific process within a laboratory – that must be investigated by a suitable set of cytologists who go in and that’s what HIQA do.

And I’m left wondering why is the HSE and the NSF so bent on avoiding the laboratory issue?

Why are they so determined to constantly refer to, as the minister again did yesterday, Minister Harris, spoke about Emma’s death in the context of the non-disclosure?

And didn’t acknowledge that non-disclosure did not kill that woman, failures in a laboratory in 2010 and 2013 did.

And it is inexcusable that today, following her death, there is still not a clear and determined statement from the State saying we will investigate why those slides and so many hundreds of others were critically misread in those laboratories.

In the US and in Ireland, it just so happens that Emma’s two errors were in the same laboratory Quest Diagnostics in New Jersey.

Listen back in full here