Yikes.
Via Ian Guider
Earlier: Blue Rae
Previously: A Very Denis Coup
Location unspecified.
Darragh Ó Tuathail tweets:
I THINK this is anti-abortion….sure it made sense to the creator….
Representatives of BreastCheck and Professor Arnold Hill at the Oireachtas Health Committee this morning
Today.
Representatives of BreastCheck are answering questions at a meeting of the Oireachtas Health Committee.
It follows a meeting of the Public Accounts Committee around two weeks ago in which it emerged four cases are being taken against the State over alleged misdiagnosis of breast cancer through the screening service BreastCheck.
At the health committee meeting today, Labour TD Alan Kelly asked Clinical Director of BreastCheck Ann O’Doherty how many letters of apology have been issued to women by the HSE, on behalf of BreastCheck, since the screening service began and over the past year.
They had this exchange…
Ann O’Doherty: “I honestly cannot say that I have any comprehensive knowledge of what litigation cases are in front of…
Alan Kelly: “Well, the State Claims [Agency] have said four…”
O’Doherty: “I honestly, that’s something I wouldn’t know. And personally I’m only aware of BreastCheck having written one letter, from the HSE, on behalf of BreastCheck, having written one letter of apology. Now I don’t know – there could be more. But I would have thought it would have come to our executive group management meeting if there were because that would have certainly did, went at a very high level.”
“But I can’t promise, I can’t say when it was but I imagine it possibly was in the last year? But that’s the only one I know of. But I wouldn’t necessarily have a comprehensive…”
Kelly: “Is that normal, a letter like that would issue?”
O’Doherty: “Well I think that there was, this is all hearsay, but I know that it did come about at our executive management team meeting that there was a case settled and one of the things that the plaintiff wanted was a letter of apology. And there was a lot of discussion over who should sign it. It was issued and that’s the only one I personally know of.”
Later
O’Doherty: “I have been working for 30 years in breast cancer screening and I would probably say I haven’t had more than one medical legal case a year – where solicitors are involved. In my unit, in the last two weeks, we’ve had 15 and what my great concern is, in this country, that the litigation is going to cost so much that [inaudible] is going to have to come to us and say we’re going to have to stop screening because it’s just costing so much…
“I mean 15 in two weeks, and not having even had one a year. And it’s the same solicitors. There has been a huge focus on solicitors and litigation in the media. And we’re now seeing that. And that’s in my unit and we have four units.
“So yes, there is a huge concern: are we going to be able to continue screening?”
Later
Arnold Hill: “The issue in the health service where you have a test that if you line up 100 women with breast cancer and did a mammogram on all of them – ten of them, it won’t show.
“Now, in this country, those ten people, if they get a good solicitor, can get about a very large sum of money, ranging up to a million and I would suspect will go higher in the years ahead.
“That’s unsustainable. So if you could do anything, I think a woman, first of all, when they come and have a mammogram, like in BreastCheck where they sign and understand that there will, it’s not a perfect test, but in this country, if you’re one of those ten, it’s almost like you’re entitled to €1million in medical legal costs. That’s unsustainable.
“So what I would suggest to you is there needs to be urgent medical legal reform. Urgent. And we’ve known this for a long, long time and it is, the problem is that you have vested interests that will block it.”
Ice pops fashioned from resin studded with hundreds of thousands of multi-coloured Swarovski crystals by Chicago based artist David Jacob.
Jacob’s work is currently on display at the Nonfinito Gallery in New York, if you’re passing.
More here.

Met Eireann tweetz:
Dry and mostly sunny. Top temperatures 19 to 22 C, generally, with light easterly or variable breezes. But fresher along parts of the east and south coasts, with values of 15 to 17 C., due to local onshore sea breezes.
Twenty-two
Update:
Athlone right now. pic.twitter.com/0kCWJxE9Xj
— AthloneAT (@AthloneAT) May 23, 2018
Oh.
Editor-in-chief of Independent News and Media Stephen Rae
Small violin to hand?
When asked to confirm Mr Rae’s departure, INM declined to comment.
It is the latest development in a period of tumult at the media company, which has recently undergone a major change to its board membership and is fighting efforts by the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement (ODCE) to have inspectors appointed to the business.
INM has lost both a chief executive and a chairman in the past year.
G’wan the Gemma, Maurice, etc., etc.
Independent group editor-in-chief Stephen Rae to step down (Irish Times)
Previously: Discerning Fakes
Rollingnews
UPDATE:
“Since 2013 I have had the privilege and honour to lead the editorial department at INM.
“Now having completed by five-year term as group editor and following a transformation of the group into a digital focused newsroom and content hub, I am to leave the publishing business in a strong position and hand it over to a team of strong and dynamic editors.
“I leave the business at a time when all print titles are market leaders, in addition our online platform independent.ie has become the nation’s go-to news source.
“During my 25 years in INM I feel greatly fortunate to have worked with many extremely bright and exceptional people and to have guided the coverage on some of the biggest news stories our country has seen.”
“I am now looking forward to taking on new digital projects which will focus on my core interests of developing new revenue models for journalism along with the hugely important editorial fight against fake news.”
Statement released by Stephen Rae this afternoon.
“Uncover”
An exhibition of new photographs by Dublin-based fine artist Brian Teeling raising awareness and funds for Gay Switchboard Ireland.
Adam Shanley writes:
Uncover will feature over fifty portraits of subjects drawn from a diverse cross-section of Irish LGBT+ life and includes politicians, musicians, artists, activists and unsung heroes.
Figures include: Senator Fintan Warfield; theatre director, Garry Hynes; drag artist Veda Beaux Reeves; and broadcaster and designer, Brendan Courtney.
An integral part of being proud of who we are as LGBT+ people is not hiding our true selves despite adversity.
Brian Teeling’s portraits are an important reminder that some of us show our vulnerabilities visibly and with pride, while some more of us need the support and compassion of our community to uncover theirs.”
Name those people (pics 1-6), anyone?
Uncover at The Library Project, Temple Bar, Dublin 2 launching on June 25.
A new size comparison video from MetaBall Studios that lines up videogame bogeymen from Little Big Planet’s Sackboy to the leviathans of Gears Of War in order of bulk.
Previously: Know Your Monsters
From top: statue of Buddha at the Triratna International Centre; Darragh Murphy
We know the viewpoint of the Catholic Church, the Church of Ireland, the Presbyterian Church, the Islamic Centre, the Methodist Church, the Evangelical Alliance, and of Atheist Ireland. But what is the view in one of Ireland’s fastest-growing religions – Buddhism – on repealing the Eighth Amendment?
The short answer is there is no official Buddhist view on anything. With increasing numbers of Buddhists practising outside the traditional monastic-lay dichotomy, the nuances of one’s own personal support for an abortion comes down to Buddhist ethics, and the principle of taking responsibility for the karmic consequences of one’s own actions and intentions.
Like Jesus, the Buddha did not speak directly about the Eighth Amendment to the Constitution of Ireland. There is no Buddhist pope or Archbishop handing down edicts. The Dalai Lama, for example, is the head of just one of many schools of Tibetan Buddhism alone.
Elsewhere, there are Theravada, Mayahana, Zen and Pure Land demoninations. While the Buddha advised followers to test his teachings in their own experience, he did enunciate ethical training principles. Along with the centrality of going for refuge (committing) to the Three Jewels of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, these ethical guidelines are practised by all Buddhists.
The shortest list – the Five Precepts – enumerates for lay followers how an Enlightened Being would naturally behave, including abstaining from taking that which is not freely given (generosity), abstaining from sexual misconduct (contentment); abstaining from untruthful, harsh or divisive speech (truthful communication); and abstaining from intoxicants (mindfulness).
Yet it is the first precept which is most relevant here: abstaining from harming living beings (loving-kindness). This is connected to principle of non-harm, and is motivated more by the principle of respecting the dignity of life, rather than preserving life at any cost.
In the upholding or violation of the precepts, intention is crucial. If the practitioner is motivated more by unselfishness, love and generosity, then it is more likely to be a skilful act than if the person is motivated by greed, ill will or delusion.
As always, it is down to the individual Buddhist practitioner how (s)he interprets his or her actions. Ethically speaking, the first precept usually means moving towards a vegetarian diet and cultivating, through meditation, a more selfless, compassionate attitude towards all living beings.
What about abortion? Ordained Buddhists in the west are notoriously heterodox on most issues. A minority of Order Members in the UK will support Brexit, for example, while some Buddhist monks in Tibet continue to eat meat. One Buddhist centre in London counts a Conservative Party MP among its regular practitioners.
Many Buddhists will therefore interpret this first precept of non-harm as a contravention on abortion. Others will insist it requires a compassionate attitude balancing the mental and physical sufferings of the mother with that of the foetus.
The general attitude I encounter among Buddhists towards abortion is similar to that towards drugs. It is treated as a matter for personal morality and medicine, rather than one for the criminal courts. The bottom line for many Buddhists is whether repealing the Eighth Amendment will lead to less, or more suffering.
For centuries, traditional monastic Buddhism – in the form of the monastic Vinaya code, mostly laid down long after the Buddha’s paranirvana – was one of prima facie opposition to abortion, due to the traditional view of life starting at conception.
Science has recently caught up with Buddhism in many areas, not least in the area of neuroplasticity, and, since the 2012 Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness, the sentience of non-human animals. Yet it has yet to discover when consciousness begins in the life of a foetus.
Even if one is to go along with the traditional pro-life view, this would not prevent a stoically pro-life Buddhist from voting Yes in Friday’s referendum. After all, abortion rates have fallen in those countries, like Portugal and Switzerland, with access to safe, legal abortion in the first trimester.
In any case, for many modern followers of Buddhism not governed by the Vinaya code, this lack of certainty regarding when consciousness arises in the womb will lead them to give primacy to the suffering of the mother.
Too often in modern society, the governing question involves asking who is responsible for a certain act, and how they can be punished. The Buddhist alternative is to ask who is suffering, and how can we alleviate it.
At present, an average of three women and girls a day use unsafe abortion pills, rather than undertaking the expense and upheaval of going abroad – an effective income threshold for unplanned maternity.
It also seems that denying a termination in the case of rape, or in the case of a fatal foetal abnormality, would increase rather than reduce suffering, given the rise in suicide among women in poorer areas.
Whether you “support” abortion or not (and it remains a highly personal choice based on circumstances), ending the criminalisation of this activity seems in keeping with Buddhist ethics of compassion and non-harm.
It’s theoretically possible that, in some cases, terminating an early pregnancy (and thereby causing possible harm to the nascent living being in the womb) may save much more suffering than forcing an unwilling mother to carry to full term.
While the referendum campaign has been marked by no lack of rancour, there are moderate voices on both sides.
Whatever the outcome, one hopes that those who argue so fervently for the right to “love both”, extend their sphere of concern to the many other sentient beings, human and non-human alike, mothers and fathers, living decidedly unloved existences.
Darragh Murphy is a journalist training for Buddhist ordination with the Triratna Buddhist Community. He is writing here in a personal capacity. Follow Darragh on twitter: @DarraghPMurphy