Yesterday evening.

The Department of Health, Hawkins Street, Dublin 2

Members of the Love Both Campaign claiming that since January, Minister for Health Simon Harris has tweeted or retweeted on the Eighth Amendment 134 times and just once on the trolley crisis.

They are calling on the Minister to “get his priorities straight” ahead of the forthcoming referendum to remove the Eight Amendment from the Constitution.

Meanwhile: ‘Irish Times’ poll: Public favour repeal of Eighth despite slip in support (Irish Times)

Sam Boal/RollingNew
s

From top: price comparisons between Dublin and Denver,Colorado where cannabis use has been legalised; Niall Neligan

Niall Neligan writes:

Today, the 20th of April marks an unusual date in the international calendar when cannabis activists across the world celebrate “4/20” or International Cannabis Day.

Last year approximately USD $1.5 Billion worth of medicinal and recreational cannabis was sold lawfully in Colorado.

Cumulatively, that amounts to almost USD $4.5 Billion in legal sales since regulation commenced on 1st January 2014. However, it is the tax revenue from sales which has captured the attention of state houses throughout the U.S. and beyond.

Since regulation commenced, Colorado has generated $683 million in additional revenue, with last year’s total amounting to USD $247 million, the majority of which is earmarked for public school funding.

Additionally, there are now approximately 18,500 people working either directly or indirectly in the legal cannabis sector in that state.

Another interesting point is that the price of a gramme of cannabis in the regulated states has been declining over the last eighteen months and the purchase price in Denver now averages about $7.79, which is in stark contrast to the $21.63 (€17.50) which a gramme commands on the illicit market in Dublin.

Whatever way you look at it; the sliding price has had the added bonus of pushing the criminal gangs out of the cannabis market in Colorado as the margins are no longer viable there.

The data from Colorado paints a rather bleak picture of just how much prohibition is costing Ireland not just in terms of revenue but also the day to day costs of prohibition in terms of prosecutions, Garda manpower hours, and court time.

The actual size of Ireland’s illicit market in cannabis is anyone’s guess; estimates range from €700 million to €1 Billion. Statistics from the CSO tells us that there were approximately 16,880 controlled drug offences in 2017.

Some 56 percent of those were prosecutions for possession of cannabis for personal use only under Section 3 of the Misuse of Drugs Acts 1977-2017.

To put this in plain language, the majority of drug prosecutions are of individuals who possess cannabis for personal use. In a regulated market, that figure would dramatically drop saving the state a considerable amount of money.

Furthermore, the cost of prohibition would be reversed into a tax positive as revenues from regulated sales would accrue to the state.

Within the next few years, several European states such as the Netherlands, Spain, Portugal and Germany are likely to introduce regulation for adult use. The question is, what impact will this process of regulation have on the Irish government?

The Irish State regrettably has a dubious reputation for being an outlier for social conservatism when common sense dictates otherwise.

Given the sea-changes happening elsewhere, the government cannot afford to stand still as other states join The Green Rush and reap the enormous economic benefits that accrues from regulation.

The solution is for the Government to introduce a comprehensive piece of legislation which regulates cannabis for both medical and adult use.

To arrive at that point the government must accept that prohibition of cannabis has failed.

Rather than reducing the supply of cannabis, supply has increased under the prohibition regime and demand has not abated. Put simply, the illicit market in cannabis exists because of prohibition.

No drug has ever been made safer in the hands of criminal gangs or unregulated amateur growers. By ending prohibition, and implementing a strict regulatory framework, the state will at least offer some protection to those adults who choose to use cannabis and more importantly to those who are self-medicating out of illness and relying on illicit cannabis obtained from the black market.

Regulation will transition the current unregulated and illicit market estimated to be worth approximate €1Billion per annum into a regulated market.

If properly done, a regulated market could generate as much as €300 million in additional revenue for the state each year and create 15,000 new jobs by 2025.

Additionally, regulation would have enormous social benefits, firstly it would take cannabis out of the hands of criminal gangs and amateur growers.

Secondly, it would afford greater protection to children and adolescents who experiment with cannabis. In the illicit and unregulated market, there are no protections.

Under prohibition, an adolescent doesn’t require an ID to buy cannabis, all he or she needs to know is where to buy it and when. Regulation on the other hand provides those protections by limiting access in a way that prohibition has failed to do.

In the unregulated illicit market which currently exists, there are no health warnings on packaging, no content controls, no limitations placed on purchasing and no safety guidelines on growing. Regulation would change that for the better as Colorado has proved.

Therefore, the time has come for the Government to do the right thing and initiate a Regulation of Cannabis (Medicinal & Adult Use) Bill. Incrementalism only delays the inevitable; delay now has a measured cost. Sensible regulation works, nonsensical prohibition does not.

Only comprehensive legislation and well-considered regulatory rules will change that, and change it for the better.

Today is as good as any day to remind them that change is in the air and on the streets across the world, as ‘cannabactivists’ mark 4/20 like never before.

Niall Neligan is a Barrister and Lecturer in Criminal Law at the Dublin Institute of Technology. His research field is Drug Policy Regulation and Law Reform.

Earlier: Happy 420 To One And All

From top (left to right): Michael McDowell SC, for Sgt Maurice McCabe, Supt ecoel Cunningham, Sgt McCabe; former Garda Commissioner Nóirín O’Sullivan; Supt Frank Walsh, former private secretary to former Garda Commissioners Martin Callinan and Ms O’Sullivan 

The Disclosures Tribunal is examining claims that a smear campaign was conducted against whistleblower Sgt Maurice McCabe.

There is currently a break in the tribunal’s hearings until April 30.

Earlier this week, and last week, the evidence given by witnesses mainly related to events in January 2014.

These events included former Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan’s appearance before the Public Accounts Committee when it was examining the quashing of penalty points, and what he’s alleged to have said about Sgt McCabe before and after that meeting; Mr Callinan’s meeting with the then chair of the PAC and Fianna Fail TD John McGuinness in a carpark on the Naas Road in Dublin; and comments made by celebrity solicitor Gerald Kean on RTE Radio One’s Marian Finucane Show – for which RTE subsequently paid out €180,000.

But one witness this week, Supt Frank Walsh, who was private secretary to both Mr Callinan and his successor Nóirín O’Sullivan, gave evidence that seemed relevant to a previous module which looked at the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation of 2015.

In that module, Judge Peter Charleton was tasked with examining if Ms O’Sullivan inappropriately relied upon unjustified grounds to discredit Sgt McCabe.

Readers may recall that central to the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation was the famous Mullingar meeting which whistleblower Sgt Maurice McCabe had with Supt Noel Cunningham and Sgt Yvonne Martin on August 25, 2008, and Sgt McCabe’s equally famous secret tape recording of the same.

Prior to the Mullingar meeting, in February 2008, Supt Michael Clancy requested Sgt McCabe to draw up a report about his dealings with the D family.

When Supt Clancy made this request, he said he would use Sgt McCabe’s report to see if he could get the DPP’s directions shown to the D family.

It came after Sgt McCabe had been confronted by members of the D family in public in October 2007.

[Ms D had made an allegation of ‘dry humping’ against Sgt McCabe in December 2006 and by April 2007, it was found to have no foundation by the DPP. Sgt McCabe was informed of the DPP’s full directions almost as soon as they were released by the Cavan state solicitor Rory Hayden in April 2007 but Sgt McCabe didn’t disclose this detail to anyone in An Garda Síochána until he gave evidence at the O’Higgins commission in May 2015].

Sgt McCabe obliged with Supt Clancy’s request and then subsequently Supt Clancy asked Supt Noel Cunningham to look at Sgt McCabe’s report. This gave rise to the meeting in Mullingar.

It was alleged at the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation – which ran from May 2015 to December 2015 and looked at allegations of poor policing in Cavan/Monaghan, as made by Sgt McCabe – that, at this Mullingar meeting, Sgt McCabe had admitted to engaging in a kind of blackmail-like scenario.

It should be noted that in order to put forward the false blackmail allegation at the O’Higgins commission, this necessitated counsel for the Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan and senior gardai to introduce the matter of the DPP’s directions in respect of the Ms D 2006 allegation to the O’Higgins commission.

This false blackmail allegation was put forward in three different ways.

A letter from the Chief State Solicitor’s Office to the O’Higgins commission – which was furnished on the instructions of the then Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan on Monday, May 18, 2015 – referred to the Mullingar meeting, stating:

“Notes were taken at the meeting and countersigned by Sergeant Martin and a detailed report of the meeting was prepared by Superintendent Cunningham, and its contents agreed with Sergeant Martin and forwarded to Chief Superintendent Rooney. In the course of this meeting Sergeant McCabe advised Superintendent Cunningham that the only reason he made the complaints against Superintendent Clancy was to force him to allow sergeant McCabe to have the full DPP directions conveyed to him.”

Later that same day, the false blackmail allegation was put to Sgt McCabe – by Colm Smyth SC, for Ms O’Sullivan and senior gardai – when Sgt McCabe was in the witness box:

Smyth: “In the course of that [Mullingar] meeting, Sergeant, you advised Superintendent Cunningham that the only reason you made a complaint against Superintendent Clancy was to force him to allow you to have the full authority directions conveyed to you?”

McCabe: “That is absolutely false.”

Smyth: “Right.

McCabe: “Absolutely, Judge.”

Smyth: “The only reason, and this will be the evidence of Superintendent Cunningham, the only reason that you wrote those list of complaints for Superintendent Clancy, do you understand, that you made the complaints about Superintendent Clancy was that you wanted to put pressure on Superintendent Clancy to get the full directions from the authority conveyed to you.”

McCabe: “That is absolutely false. Absolutely.”

Smyth: “Fair enough.”

McCabe: “I have a clear recollection of that meeting…”

And later, when the legal team for Ms O’Sullivan and senior gardai submitted their written submissions to the O’Higgins commission, in June 2015, the false blackmail allegation was repeated yet again.

Part of the submissions read:

“Sergeant McCabe then made a series of complaints against other officers in Bailieboro Station, including Superintendent Clancy against whom he alleged a lack of support. Chief Superintendent Rooney appointed Superintendent Cunningham to investigate these complaints. Superintendent Cunningham attempted to meet Sergeant McCabe to discuss the complaints and finally did so on 25th August 2008. On this occasion, Superintendent Cunningham was accompanied by Sergeant Martin.

“It is understood that Superintendent Cunningham will give evidence that Sergeant McCabe said at that meeting that the complaint which he had made alleging lack of support, as referred to in the preceding paragraph, was a bid by him to have the full DPP directions conveyed to him and the complaining party. This is recorded in a report of the meeting prepared jointly by Sergeant Martin and Superintendent Cunningham.”

The O’Higgins commission broke after it heard evidence on May 19, 2015 and it didn’t resume again until June 24, 2015 – by which time the transcript of Sgt McCabe’s tape recording of the Mullingar meeting had been circulated among the legal teams.

When it resumed on June 24, 2015, the false blackmail allegation was dropped.

In the words of Kathleen Leader BL, for the Disclosures Tribunal, at this tribunal earlier this year, after Sgt McCabe’s tape emerged, “…the matter of a threat at Mullingar meeting was negatived.”

The Disclosures Tribunal – which is looking at allegations of a smear campaign against Sgt McCabe – looked at this series of events, and others related to the O’Higgins commission, in January and February of this year.

And at the tribunal, just like at the O’Higgins commission after Sgt McCabe produced his tape, the false allegation of blackmail was simply put down to error.

Significantly, it was said at O’Higgins – and it was repeated at the Disclosures Tribunal, not least by former Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan – that the error was that the word “to” should have been used instead of “against”.

But this reasoning has never fully explained why it was alleged Sgt McCabe had made a threat of force of some kind.

Where did that come from?

On Tuesday of this week…

Supt Frank Walsh, who was private secretary to former Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan and then private secretary to his successor Noirin O’Sullivan, was asked if he had heard rumours about Sgt McCabe in late 2013/early 2014 – a whole year before the O’Higgins commission began.

He told the tribunal this week:

“I suppose the motive that was being spoken about at the time was that he wasn’t happy with how the DPP’s directions were conveyed to him arising out of the alleged incident that occurred some years previously, and that perhaps that he was some way annoyed over this as well and was getting his own back on his management. They were the types of rumours.”

This rumour is uncannily like what was put in the CSSO letter, put to Sgt McCabe in the witness box at the O’Higgins commission and then what was put in the written submissions at the same.

It should be noted that the tribunal has heard Sgt Martin never gave evidence at the O’Higgins Commission of Investigation, never saw the Chief State Solicitor’s letter and never saw the written submissions.

And yet, when news of what had happened at the O’Higgins commission broke in May 2016, the then Garda Commissioner Noirin O’Sullivan referred both Supt Cunningham and Sgt Martin to GSOC – despite her telling the tribunal that, at the same time, she understood what was put forward at O’Higgins to have been a mistake.

This is how Ms O’Sullivan explained her actions when she was questioned by Judge Charleton:

Noirin O’Sullivan: “This was what was in the public domain and this was what was causing the political and public disquiet and this was what had been erroneously reported in a number of media outlets and this was what was in the public and political mind, and, as I say, the position I found myself in, if I were to say that Sergeant Martin, for example, hadn’t done something, actually I don’t think anybody was within the frame of mind.

Judge Peter Charleton: “If you had said she had never given evidence, I would imagine people might well have believed you.”

O’Sullivan: “Not necessarily, Chairman, the position that we found ourselves in…”

Charleton: “Well, then the second thing was, if you actually read her statement, and this has come up a number of times, but, well, you know, she may well have her rights, but this statement which she gave, which could perhaps have been, to use the now very popular word, deployed at the O’Higgins Commission, was completely backing up Sergeant McCabe…”

O’Sullivan: “Oh, completely.”

Charleton: “…in relation to the Mullingar meeting, in the event that there was a misunderstanding about that.”

O’Sullivan: “Yes, completely, Chairman, and I think the unfortunate situation that everybody found themselves in, the erroneous facts and the distorted truths that were put into the public domain led to a situation which was completely unfair to everybody involved in this process from the outset.”

Despite this explanation, Judge Charleton told the tribunal (of the decision to send the two gardai to GSOC):

“That is something that I won’t understand until my dying day, particularly Sergeant Martin.”

In contrast…

Colm Smyth SC, who represented Ms O’Sullivan at the O’Higgins commission, apologised to Sgt McCabe for “the false matter that was put” in the CSSO letter – when he gave evidence to the tribunal earlier this year.

He said:

“Can I say this: it was remiss of me not to apologise to Sergeant McCabe in relation to that matter. It should have been done. And I’m not making excuses for it, but I think it happened in the context of the way matters were moving. Because this, again, was revisited in June. We were dealing — things were moving at a fast pace, but that is no excuse. There should have been — I regret that it was done. It was done on the explicit instructions of the client, who got it wrong.”

“…I think there was a misunderstanding as to the precise — the proper instructions should have been that this, just as I have related to you, we weren’t given the correct version, and there was a clear misunderstanding – not so much a misunderstanding, there were clearly wrong instructions.”

The tribunal is examining claims that a smear campaign was conducted against Sgt McCabe by former Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan – with the knowledge of former Garda Commissioner Nóirín O’Sullivan – as alleged by the former head of the Garda Press Office, Superintendent David Taylor.

Both Mr Callinan and Ms O’Sullivan deny the allegations.

The tribunal concluded its latest tranche of hearings on Tuesday.

A comprehensive post on the most recent evidence to follow.

Previously: Disclosures, Discrepancies and Nóirín

Disclosures Tribunal: Anomalies

Why Did Noirin O’Sullivan Ask GSOC To Inquire Into An Allegation That She Believed Was Just A Mistake?

Rollingnews

Illegal plants!

Today (April 20) is International Cannabis Day.

Colum O’Dwyer writes:

This day last year, I took a bunch of photos in in Hyde Park in London on 420 where a whole bunch of ‘marginal’ types gathered…thought they ,might be of interest…

420 in Hyde Park (Colum O’Dwyer)

Meanwhile….

This afternoon.

Custom House Quay, Dublin 1 from Midday.

Previously: Free Friday?

Anita Sethi (right) was told by BritaIn’s Prince Charles she didn’t look like she came from Manchester

Charles thinks that you shouldn’t be brown
If you come from Manchester town
Which is racist and sad
And just like his dad
The bigoted miserable clown

John Moynes

Pic via The Guardian

Will there be balloons?

Broadsheet on the Telly returns tonight at 10pm streaming LIVE above and on our YouTube channel.

Join us for a birthday special as we devour cake the news of the week from Ireland and ‘abroad’.

To celebrate 420, we will have a special item on the controversial ‘erb.

Expect: surprise guests in hostage video quality and some light swearing.

Previously: Broadsheet on the Telly

Broadsheet.ie