Author Archives: Bodger

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar in the Dáil this afternoon

This afternoon in the Dáil.

The Taoiseach said the following about the €450,000 PwC report which is expected to examine how and why the cost of the National Children’s Hospital has ballooned:

“The terms of reference for the review by PwC into the escalation of costs, that they are being revised at present. But the review will deal with accountability of relevant key parties, functions and roles. The prohibition against making findings against individuals will be removed.

“It will establish he sequence of events in relation to the cost increases experienced by the project; establish what was known; when and by whom; and will cover bodies including the NBH, [inaudible], committees, HSE and also the Department of Health.

“And it will also be asked to identify any areas where potential cost savings or reductions, which are consistent with the applicable contractual undertakings, may be found.”

Previously: Well Warned

Watch Dáil proceedings live here

Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin; Taoiseach Leo Varadkar

This afternoon.

During Leaders’ Questions which were answered by Taoiseach Leo Varadkar…

Fianna Fáil Micheál Martin raised the nurses’ strike and claimed there was “absence of substantive and meaningful engagement from the Government’s side” in terms of resolving the issues.

It followed the issuing of a press release by the Government last night in which Minister for Health Simon Harris and Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said they were willing to engage in talks “on the range of workplace-related issues other than pay to try to resolve the dispute”.

Mr Martin added:

“I put it to you Taoiseach that last night’s initiative, at the 11th hour, of the proposals that emanated from Minister [Paschal] Donohoe and Minister [Simon] Harris have only served to compound the problem, make it worse and escalate it.

“Because it concerns staff shortages, undergrad education, future nursing needs and so on. But it was sent out via press release, without any engagement with the INMO or the other unions.

“The INMO has said and director described it as ‘the most cynical move I’ve seen in a long time’ and the unions have rejected it as Government spin. And that it was massively disrespectful to the nurses and to patients.

“Now, Taoiseach, I would put it to you that we cannot solve, you  cannot solve industrial relation disputes by such cynical PR manoeuvres. That kind of ‘optics are more important that substance’ approach won’t cut it when it comes to an industrial dispute of this gravity and scale.

“What is required Taoiseach are meaningful steps to be taken. Substance must replace spin in relation to the resolution of this dispute.”

Mr Martin went on to suggest that well-known mediator Kieran Mulvey should be engaged to help with resolving the matters.

During his response, Mr Varadkar said:

“I appreciate that the nursing union felt that the offer to engage in further talks at the WRC was discourteous as they heard it through a press release rather than through a letter or direct contact.

“And we’ll make sure that doesn’t recur.

“At the same time though, we shouldn’t forget that tens of thousands of people found out through the media that their respite was being cancelled this week too. That their day care was being cancelled too. So I think we need to bear that in mind as well.”

Watch Dáil proceedings live here

Dublin Rental Investigator’s Twitter avatar; a letter sent to 64 Dublin City Council councillors from Dublin Rental Investigator last month (click to enlarge)

On January 14.

Dublin Rental Investigator tweeted a letter they sent to 64 Dublin City Council councillors about their concerns related to Spotahome.

Further to his…

This afternoon the account is tweeting to say they subsequently received responses from five councillors – three of whom, according to Dublin Rental Investigator, raised queries with the council…

And that the office of the chief executive of Dublin City Council has advised that Dublin Rental Investigator’s account should be monitored for reports of substandard accommodation in the Dublin City Council area and that the council should take action when necessary…

The account states that “it’s great they can depend on my work” but it would be more beneficial if they “monitored the platforms that actually advertise property in the first place”.

Dublin Rental Investigator tweetz:

Dublin Rental Investigator

Garda Keith Harrison at the Disclosures Tribunal last year

This morning.

In the High Court before Mr Justice Seamus Noonan.

An Garda Síochána agreed to quash the decision to commence disciplinary proceedings against Donegal-based Garda Keith Harrison.

Garda Harrison was told in July of last year that a superintendent had been appointed to examine four allegations of misconduct against him.

This followed the publication of Supreme Court judge Peter Charleton’s second interim report on the Disclosures Tribunal in December 2017.

In this report, Mr Justice Charleton rejected all allegations made by Garda Harrison and his partner Marissa Simms at the tribunal.

This morning, the High Court also awarded legal costs to Garda Harrison’s legal team.

Previously: Meanwhile At The High Court

‘Entirely Without Any Validity’

Rollingnews

Illustration of what a new apartment complex on St James Road in Greenhills, Dublin 12, will look like when it’s completed later this year

Carly Bailey, of the Social Democrats, tweetz:

They are currently seeking expressions of interest for apartments at this development [above]. €1750 or more for a one bed apt. €1950 or more for a two bed. Absolutely outrageous & unaffordable for most. Impossible to tackle #housingcrisis with rents like this!

St James’s Road, Greenhills, Dublin 12 (Daft.ie)

From a letter a woman received yesterday informing her she needed to have a repeat smear test

On Friday last.

The HSE sent out letters to 6,000 women informing them they needed to have a repeat smear test.

These 6,000 women would have initially tested positive for low-grade abnormalities after having a smear and would have then been subsequently advised to have an additional HPV test within 30 days of the initial smear test.

But their additional HPV test was tested – by Quest Laboratories – beyond the 30-day limit.

The practice of being advised to have an additional HPV test, on foot of a test showing up low-grade abnormalities, began in Ireland in 2015.

But the acting Clinical Director of the HSE’s cervical screening programme Peter McKenna said recently that the problem was only detected at the end of November last, while the scale of the problem unfolded in December.

A letter informing one of the 6,000 women she needs to go for a repeat smear after having her initial test in the summer of 2016, above, includes the lines:

“We appreciate that you may have initially become aware of this issue in the media and we apologise for this. This was not our intention.

“We would like to offer our sincere apologies for what has happened and for any inconvenience that this may cause for you. I assure you that we are working with the lab in question to ensure that this does not happen again.”

Previously: CervicalCheck And 6,000 Letters

 CervicalCheck: Two Lists

 

 

Oh.

This morning.

RTÉ website.

Graham writes:

 The bias NEVER ever stops….

‘I’m sick with upset’ – A patient’s view of nurses’ strike (RTÉ)

Earlier: This Won’t Hurt A Bit.

Yesterday: Bryan Wall: Nursing A Militancy

1. You tell us where you shared your first date and a little bit about it

2. Our photographer visits this special place

3. They use this information to take a memorable unique picture for you.

4. We print it, frame it and then deliver it your door

Do you remember the first time?

Irish start-up FirstDates.ie will make it immortal!

Robbie writes:

At FirstDates.ie you tell us where you had your first date with your partner and one of our professional photographers will go out and take a one-off bespoke picture of the venue where you had your first date.

It is then beautifully framed and delivered to your door. The perfect wedding present or gift for Valentines.

Through delivering 100’s of these orders, we discovered the same “First Date” venues were coming up again and again. Clearly love is in the air in these venues! And so we compiled a list (see below) especially for Valentine’s Day.

FirstDates

7 Top Places in Dublin to Bring Your Date… to make them Your Husband or Wife! (FirstDates.ie)

Irish-made Valentine’s Day gifts to broadsheet@broadsheet.ie marked ‘Irish-made Valentine’s gifts’. No fee.

RTÉ’s Caitriona Perry and Minister for Health Simon Harris on RTÉ’s Six One last night

Last night.

On RTÉ’s Six One.

Caitriona Perry interviewed the Minister for Health Simon Harris about the overrun at the National Children’s Hospital.

She pointed out he first learned about the cost overrun last August, the scale of the overrun last November November and that he won’t take any action until he receives a €450,000 report from PwC which is due to be finished by March of this year.

They had the following exchange:

Caitriona Perry: “Is that good enough or did you take your eye off the ball here?”

Simon Harris: “No, of course, I should be held accountable for the decision that I made when I advised the Government that we needed to proceed with this project.”

Later

Perry: “…It’s such an important project, you said yourself there for the children of this country. Why did it take from August until November for you to find out about the scale of the overruns?”

Harris: “So at the end of August, it became apparent that there was going to be a significant overrun but my department, as indeed as a Government minister, we did what we’re actually meant to do. We did due diligence. There were a number of expert reports commissioned. And ultimately the body that’s responsible for delivering the hospital – the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board – came back on the 9th of November with the scale of the overrun being clear.”

Perry: “Should you not have been demanding, day in day out, that someone tell you just how much this project was going over by?”

Harris: “I was very determined and confident that we had professionals in place to deliver this project. The board delivering the project is a ‘who’s who’ when it comes to construction and procurement issues. So I think actually the job of the minister is to put people in place, who have the professional skills to deliver a project.

“It’s also the job of a minister then, when challenges emerge, to make tough decisions. And the decision to proceed with this project was a tough one because of the scale of the cost. But I have no doubt the only decision I would have regretted was if I didn’t proceed with it.”

Mr Harris went on to say that he and his department were “seeking constant updates” while his Secretary General [Jim Breslin] is chairing a steering group on the matter – the Children’s Hospital Project and Programme steering group.

Watch back in full here

Meanwhile…

Illustration by Gary Reddin, from Sligo.

Gary Reddin (Facebook)

Previously: Gary Reddin on Broadsheet

Thanks Gary

Simon Hix, of the London School of Economics and Political Science, tweetz:

Latest @YouGov Brexit tracker “Brexit: right or wrong?” survey results now out (in the field on 30-31 January). “Wrong” consistently 7-8 points ahead now. E.g., here’s the trend

Simon Hix?