Category Archives: Misc

From top: Nazi General Edwin Rommel (at left); David Langwallner

Philosopher Isaiah Berlin‘s famous parable or table top discussion, ‘The Hedgehog and The Fox‘ (1953) is about different forms of intelligence. The Hedgehog knows one big thing, the fox many things. Perhaps the ideal human intelligence ought to combine both?

I have always been fascinated by the ‘Desert Fox’,  Erwin Rommel. The reasons are obvious in my case. I have always been a Junker at one level but never quite a member of the establishment. I endorse the remark of Groucho Marx that one should never be a member of a club that would have one as its member. I also have an innate sympathy with the underdog and he was certainly in that position in the impossible war of The Afrika Corps. The man who won against impossible odds. A far better general than Montgomery.

Now, all judgments at one level must be context-specific. So, the negative. He was a National Socialist and a card-carrying member of the Nazi party. He was also a German General and initially very close to Hitler. He was a military man and, described by Desmond Young in his definitive biography,  the perfect fighting animal. It is quite clear that he was a great military strategist, resourceful, winning against odds and brilliant in the game of bluff and counter-bluff.

The relationship between the Anglo-Saxon and Germanic race has always been complicated. Similar Hapsburgian blood in their royal families, thickened by dynastic and familial inter breeding didn’t help. They were never natural enemies, but twice got pitted against each other. So, the officer class of both establishments always had respect for fellow officers of the same perhaps ruthless disposition – mitigated by an old-fashioned sense of compassion or honour.

As illustrated by the performance by Von Stroheim as the German Commander in Renoir’s ‘La Grande Illusion‘ (1939), some of the Junker class had a measure of civility. Regarding the rules of combat and proper treatment of prisoners during wartime, it is quite clear that most American, German, Japanese and to a significantly lesser extent British generals did not observe them, but Rommel largely did.

‘La Grande Illusion,’ a film of the first world war, says a lot about the need for pacifism and the somewhat courtly treatment of prisoners of war. It also demonstrates the futility of any war or any form of conflict that descends into tribalism, nationalism and chauvinism which is where we are now headed.

Renoir elaborated in commentary on the film that all cultures are cliquish and have their own rules, their own protocols and their own way of dealing with those who do not observe the rules of the game or the rule of law.

When it opened, a largely right wing audience in France went berserk, like the reception in the Abbey Theatre to ‘The Playboy of the Western World’ in 1907. Renoir’s acid comment was in effect that these people were doomed and the audience reaction showed that “people who commit suicide do not do so in front of witnesses.” He had touched a raw nerve.

Rommel, though not Renoir, was a tolerably-civilised Junker and given the awfulness of the military mindset and the circumstances, a tolerably civilised human being compromised by his service to awfulness.  The real mystery about him relates to his knowledge of the Van Stauffenberg plot and his final disenchantment with his mentor Hitler. He either knew of, or did not disavow, or plotted with the removal of Hitler – hence his death by cyanide pill in the back of the car.

As a new form of corporate and military industrial barbarism takes hold, the actual rakes of the game have shifted. Normal laws have given way to executive action, ouster clauses, emergency legislation driven by the pandemic and many of the decision makers now rough-hewn combatants engaging in inconsequential thinking that might be viewed historically in hindsight as a combination of blinkered vision and indeed war crimes or crimes against humanity.

When the rules of the game have become replaced by real or fake wars in an age of disinformation then the narrow tinsel of legality has broken down. Johnson venerates Churchill and references him like the Bible to in effect trumpet and blow up his own reputation. Churchill was a great man but also a war criminal not least in sanctioning Bomber Harris and the bombing of Dresden with the death of many innocent civilians as documented in Kurt Vonnegut’s ‘Slaughterhouse.’

So, Rommel does matter in a perilous age.

He was with a few contrary incidents very decent to prisoners of armed conflict and was a civilised European gentleman. Ultimately, he had enough of a barbaric and unstable regime and his subtle but recognisable opposition was enough.

Currently even that scant level of heroism within the establishment is perhaps enough. The last remnants of civilisation. And Renoir the hedgehog saw clearly in 1939 that we are on the brink of a precipice as we are now. People such as Rommel the Fox are needed to instill moderation. And for their unique skill sets of both military tactician and humanist.

David Langwallner is a barrister specialising in public law, immigration, housing and criminal defence including miscarriages of justice. He is emeritus director of the Irish innocence project and was Irish lawyer of the year at the 2015 Irish law awards. His column appears here every Tuesday and Friday. Follow David on Twitter @DLangwallner

Getty

This morning/afternoon.

There are approximately 5,000 homes in Donegal, Mayo, Clare, and Sligo affected by mica – a toxic mineral used in building blocks – with some houses having to be demolished.

The Department of Housing say it will only cover 90% of costs to homeowners.

However Agriculture Minister Charlie McConalogue told the Irish Examiner:

  “I remain committed to seeing the homeowners affected by mica achieve a 100% redress scheme that is fit for purpose and will support families to rebuild their homes and their dreams.

“Families affected are in this situation through no fault of their own.”

Previously: Cabinet row brews over mica homes compensation scheme (Irish Examiner, August 22)

This afternoon.

Meanwhile…

It’s satire!

Or is it?

Clearly.

That’s what they want you to think.

Stop it.

From top: Republic of Ireland senior squad; Ciarán Murphy, of Second Captains

This morning.

‘Today with Philip Boucher Hayes’ on RTÉ Radio One.

Further to  manager Stephen Kenny confirming some Republic of Ireland players have opted against the Covid vaccine…

…. Ciarán Murphy (top), co-host of the Second Captains football podcast, said:

“It’s interesting from the point of view of a dressing room and the dressing room dynamics. I’ll leave the immunology to the eminent professor [Cliona O’Farrelly, professor of comparative immunology and biochemistry at Trinity College Dublin was a fellow guest] and I might talk about the dressing room dynamics and we’ll stick to what we’re slightly better at here…”

“This idea that young men, in this situation, in the NFL or Premier League, young sportspeople, lead a very closeted life. And the richer and more successful they are, the more closeted they are.

“The more suspicion perhaps of mainstream media, to use that terrible phrase, there is amongst these people. And they might get talking about conspiracy theories or, you know, wild anti-vax theories that they would have seen on the internet.

“And this, it spreads in the dressing room in a way that is kind of maybe harder for us to understand, you know, for those of us who work in a regular work environment.”

“…Sportspeople live in a kind of weird…it’s a weird situation that they find themselves in often. And the stick, in this situation might actually be more effective than the carrot.”

Gulp.

Yesterday: Missed Shots

‘sup?

This morning.

Ballyconneely, Connemara, county Galway

Dublin tourists Leah Farrell and Devin McCarthy (top) are joined by cattle as they chill out on Mannin Bay Beach.

The current Indian Summer (waycist!) is expected to last into next week.

Milk would be a bad choice.

Eamonn Farrell/RollingNews

Above from left: Niall Rynee, Chairman of the Aviva Stadium Board; Martina Queally, Chief Officer, HSE Community Healthcare East; and Siobhan McArdle, Assistant National Director of COVID Operations with staff members at the Aviva

This afternoon.

Aviva Stadium, Dublin 4.

The stadium’s COVID-19 Vaccination Centre celebrates administering over 294,600 vaccine doses to the general public since the centre opened on March 3.

This is the equivalent to filling the 51,700-seated Aviva more than five times over.

Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

From top: Minister for the Environment, Climate and Communications and Minister for Transport Eamon Ryan, Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media Catherine Martin and Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly

This morning.

Government Buildings, Dublin2.

Ministers arrive for a cabinet meeting to discuss the lifting of covid restrictions..

Meanwhile…

RollingNews

David Donohue – The Turning

“I took a walk out on the tide.”

Broadsheet is honoured to present the premiere of the soulful new video from David Donohue (top).

A cult figure from his days with his band The Floors, the Carlow-born singer/songwriter unfurls his debut solo album All My Lonely Friends on September 24.

Produced by David Ayers and featuring a who’s who of local talent including Adrian Crowley and Clive Barnes, the album is easily the comeback of the year.

The Turning, a country-tinged ballad, is the first single and features striking guest vocals from Niamh Regan as well as appearances by Enda Gallery, piano; David Ayers, guitar; and Jono Connell, bass.

Nick says: Swim when you’re winning.

David Donohue

This morning.

Via Reuters:

A contaminant found in a batch of Moderna Inc’s (MRNA.O) COVID-19 vaccines delivered to Japan is believed to be a metallic particle, Japanese public broadcaster NHK reported, citing sources at the health ministry.

Japan yesterday suspended the use of 1.63 million doses shipped to 863 vaccination centres nationwide, more than a week after the domestic distributor, Takeda Pharmaceutical (4502.T), received reports of contaminants in some vials.

NHK, in a report published late on Thursday, cited ministry sources as saying the particle reacted to magnets and was therefore suspected to be a metal. Moderna has described it as “particulate matter” that did not pose a safety or efficacy issue.

That’s alright then.

Yesterday: Moderna Life Is Rubbish

Previously: Stuck On You


Above from left: grown up Coombe babies Patrick Quinlan; Eoin Conlan; Caoimhe Whelan and their Mothers Caroline O’Leary; Kathleen Burke and Helen Conlan

Yesterday.

Portmarnock, north county Dublin.

Mums Caroline O’Leary, Kathleen Burke and Helen Conlan met at the Coombe Women & Infants University Hospital in August 1991, their babies born within 12 hours of one another.

They formed a strong friendship and before leaving the Hospital, agreed to meet the following year when the babies were one year old.

The families have met every year since on Portmarnock Beach and this week they met to mark the children’s 30th birthdays.

In fairness.

Sasko Lazarov / Photocall Ireland