Category Archives: Misc

Poet Kevin Higgins and a portrait of himself by artist Chris Banahan

Kevin writes:

This poem (below) refers, at the end, to my lack, thus far of a vaccination date despite my condition…

‘Liberals’ &’Death’

Two words that strut confident of
their own historical inevitability.
Everyone in time meets them,
though hopefully not both
ringing your door bell
the same day,
unless your name is
Nagasaki or Vietnam;

or you’re the first village
no-one’s ever heard of
successfully abolished
from thirty thousand feet
by a transgender person
pressing a button;

or you’re the first Somali in history
proudly turned into a pile of burning mince
by a drone designed by a woman of colour;

or you’re the wrong type of Australian
whose computer told us the names
of the obliterated
and so can only leave prison
in a fair-trade white cardboard box;

or you’re me, delighted
to expire unvaccinated rather
than spark a diplomatic kerfuffle
by sticking in my bicep
something as sinister sounding as Sputnik
without written permission from Brussels

who’ll surely deliver
a keynote speaker to my grave
to thank my corpse for its contribution,
and find a plausible way of saying:
I’m down here, getting acquainted with the snails
so they can be up there, polishing their idea of themselves.

Kevin Higgins

Riiight.

Meanwhile…

Ah here.

Meanwhile…

Via Irish Times Letters:

The news that just 0.1 per cent of cases of Covid are traceable to outdoor activity is shocking The Government has closed parks, bathing spots, children’s sports training, golf, tennis, rowing, and even fishing which, by its very nature of casting a line with a hook on the end, tends to dictate social distancing.

This information has had to be available to those who make these decisions. It is truly shocking that people have been denied access to sports, social meetings and some forms of exercise. A reversal is not only important, it’s vital.

Irish Times Letters

RollingNews

Last night.

Prime Time on RTÉ One.

Bonkers new set.

Daring new ‘feel’.

Fresh new faces.

Same bias.

FIGHT!

Meanwhile…

Meanwhile…

Ah now.

Thanks Fran Conlon

A scene from Cinema Paradiso (1988) where the local priest had ordered sections of movies to be censored

The cinemas in Italy
Had a state imposed morality
But it seems now’s the time
To abolish the crime
Of letting folk choose what they see

John Moynes

Miramax

From top Marlon Brando as South African lawyer McKenzie modelled on Sir Sidney Kentridge in A Dry White Season (1989); David Langwallner

The most famous lawyer on the planet is 98 years of age and has only recently retired. But would our internet generation know who Sir Sidney Kentridge is?

Whistle-blowing is a zeitgeist issue. It should be said one can get seduced by glamour and whistle-blowing has increasing glamour. Right up to Mr. Assange of whom more later. It has been the centrepiece of works of art from Henrik Ibsen ‘s An Enemy of The People (1882) and  Halder Laxness ‘Independent People’ (1934) to the filmic whistleblowing demonstrations: Elia Kazan’s On the Waterfront (1952), Lumet’s Serpico (1973) and Erin Brockovich (2000). It is noticeable that both Ibsen and Laxness show that stubborn principle in the face of official hostility is a recipe for personal disaster as Sir Sidney and I have found out to our personal cost.

The ambivalence of whistleblowing is embodied in Kazan, who shopped his communist colleagues in the McCarthy-era and showed that not all whistle-blowing is good or motivated for the right reasons.

Journalistic whistleblowing became a phenomenon with Emile Zola, who was convicted by a French court for criminal libel for his campaign to establish the innocence of Jewish army officer in his legendary pamphlet J’ Accuse.

An excellent  book by NUIG academic Kate Kenny, Whistleblowing: Towards a New Theory, 2019, Harvard University Press) makes the case, in fact, that journalists make life more difficult for whistle-blowers by spotlighting them and making them targets for scrutiny.

Ms Kenny writes:

“We see this clearly in the recent media obsession with well-known whistle-blowers such as Edward Snowden, Julian Assange and Chelsea Manning in which more attention is given to the individuals, their private selves and their personalities than to the information they report“.

Before his recent eviction and jailing for skipping bail and now presently unresolved extradition, Julian Assange was forced to seek refuge in London’s Ecuadorian embassy after facing an investigation by Swedish prosecutors into rape offences.

But, as those charges were dropped, the vengeful and hysterical US applied for his extradition for being in a conspiracy with Chelsea Manning “to commit computer intrusion” over the Collateral Murder video, the Afghanistan war logs, the Iraq war logs, and CableGate, which leaked diplomatic exchanges.

His extradition has been refused but he has been incarcerated. In fact, the judge in the Westminster Magistrates’ Court sensibly concluded that he could not be extradited to a country with scant or non-existent observance of human rights in its prison facilities, the obliquely named but utterly terrible Correctional Facilities.

Assange’s lifting from the Ecuadorian embassy after US pressure on April 11, 2019 evoked a Howard Hughes-figure: bearded, jagged, and aged, dragged in a semi-recumbent position and clearly terrified.

Meanwhile, Edward Snowden, who copied and leaked highly classified information from the National Security Agency in 2013 when he was a Central Intelligence Agency employee and contractor, has parked himself in Russia against the baying American hounds and is granted Russian citizenship.

Now Sir Sidney is well near Denning’s age but as a QC in his prime – which extended to his 90s as a commercial silk in London – he represented Mr Mandela. The South African judicial establishment forgave that but could not quite atone for compounding the sins of justice and integrity to represent the family of the murdered Mr Biko. He had to hopscotch, disbarred, to London and throw himself on the mercy of Brick Court Chambers.

So, the great hero of the legal profession was thus, in effect, disbarred, stripped of his title of QC, and run out of South Africa with a bag of clothes for de facto whistle-blowing in his representation of a black activist or being a dissident. The categories merged and were dramatised in the film, A Dry White Season (1989), where he is played by Brando.

There is  a mid-1970s film by the legendary Italian film director Francesco Rossi called Illustrious Corpses. (1976). The film in effect demonstrates how many fighters against corruption in Italy, including communist judges such as Falcone became illustrious corpses.

So, Sir Sidney was a whistle-blower also in that tradition, but survived and prospered. The ludicrous Bar Council in Ireland – time surviving nonentities and beholden to a corrupt establishment – attempted to do something like this to me for blowing the whistle and engaging in legitimate anti-corruption representations.

The US has, since 1981 and now through the Sarbanes Oxley Act 2002, protected whistle-blowers. First, they are provided with double back pay, witness fees and lawyers’ fees. Employers who impose gagging orders are sanctioned and, most controversially, employees are given a financial inducement to blow the whistle – by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the IRS, among others.

However, it is noticeable that, although the US  often cracks down on corporate and private whistleblowing, Mr. Assange and Mr Snowden are examples of the way the US treats state whistle-blowers. It seeks to destroy them. The Obama regime waged a state-sponsored war against any recalcitrant who blew the whistle against his government. Sir Sidney blew the whistle against the Apartheid government and just as the Americans target Assange the South Africans targeted him.

Kate Kenny notes that for the establishment whistle-blowers are usually…

“…engaging in impossible quasi psychotic speech that places them in a new category in which they are excluded and banished and not acceptable to the organisation. This primary exclusion then paves the way for a second categorisation that portrays them as viable candidates for normative violence. From the perspective of colleagues and managers then, violence against whistle-blowers is not violence because [the whistle-blower is] not valid. “

The process of demonetisation, exclusion and in effect dehumanisation of whistle-blowers mentioned by the author is in effect a product of the corporatocracy.

The Ken Kesey book leading to the famous anti-establishment film One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1971) is in effect a last cri de coeur of the anti-establishment against oppressive statist oppression. In this respect I am all in favour of those conservatives who oppose an encroaching state and corporate fascism. As in an odd sort of way does the genuinely great Japanese documentary of relentless pursuit of a Japanese war criminal by a quasi-psychotic whistle-blower type. The Emperor’s Naked Army Marches On (1987).

And anyone who blows the whistle should contrast the image of sprightly and youthful Assange before his enforced exile with the raving husk of a human being pulled from the Ecuadorian embassy in London.

I have spoken out among others of the need for us to protect even a modicum of human rights in Ireland during this pandemic, which has reached the farcical proportions of not even allowing people go to church. Sir Sidney would I think see that as a pathfinder of civic dissidence.

The lion thus maybe in winter but the legacy stands. The line of human rights protection is now, at best, a thin, blue one and a social conscience is becoming a luxury precious few can afford.

Where the need for security will silence even the most fearless whistle-blower.

David Langwallner is a barrister specialising in public law, immigration, housing and criminal defence including miscarriages of justice. He is emeritus director of the Irish Innocence Project and was Irish Lawyer of the Year at the 2015 Irish Law Awards. His column appears here every Tuesday and Friday. Follow David on Twitter @DLangwallner

Pic: MGM/UA

O’Connell Street, Dublin yesterday

 

Daniel’s walking companion, historian Donal Fallon writes:

Yesterday I walked into the city ( within my 5km) and met a friend who did likewise (within his). We do this most weeks for exercise. As it was Easter we walked the city to the various sites. We decided to leave lilies, from a convenience shop on O’Connell Street, at the GPO.

Both of us were then approached by Gardai and had our details taken. We were exercising, within our 5km. People live in tiny apartments and need to get out and walk. The ability to go for walks is just about all that has kept me sane.

I’ve (mostly) supported the public health restrictions. I’ve tried my best and raised about 10k for hospitals and hospices despite my own livelihood being affected like many others. Dan likewise has done good. I’ve not seen my parents in 4 months. I’ve stayed within 5km. People are trying really hard. I see almost nobody.

Something changed in how this has all been policed since January. When you break absolutely no restrictions, but are made to feel like you have done something wrong, it is upsetting. It’s happening everyday to people.

I have tremendous respect for everyone working through this – as the son of a retired firefighter and care nurse I’m conscious of the stress all frontline workers would be under. But the atmosphere has to change. Most people are just trying their best, including us.

I think the bit that upsets me most about this is that what we did was a very simple little gesture. People are doing their best across Ireland, from care home workers to shop staff. A few lilies at the GPO just meant something would be marked even in this tough year.

Top pic: 1916 Easter Rising Tour